Concept
Buyer's Duties After Rejection
Rightful rejection
Buyer's Duties After Rejection
Rejection does not end the buyer's contact with the goods, and § 2-602(2) tells the buyer what the Code requires in the meantime. The subsection begins by making every duty it lists “subject to the provisions of the two following sections on rejected goods (Sections 2-603 and 2-604),”1 so those sections qualify all that follows. Three duties come next. After rejection, any exercise of ownership by the buyer with respect to any commercial unit is wrongful as against the seller.2 A buyer who took physical possession of the goods before rejecting them, and who has no security interest in them, must hold them with reasonable care at the seller's disposition for a time sufficient to permit the seller to remove them.3 And the buyer has no further obligations with regard to goods rightfully rejected.4
Only a buyer whose rejection took effect owes these duties. Rejection requires affirmative action, and a buyer who does nothing has accepted the goods.5 A buyer who fails to reject as § 2-602(1) requires has accepted too, and its rights with respect to the nonconforming goods no longer include rejection.6
The three duties ask little of the buyer: stay off the goods, keep them safe until the seller collects them, and then stop. The subsections below follow that order and note where §§ 2-603, 2-604, and 2-711(3) change the picture.
No Exercise of Ownership
Section 2-602(2)(a) makes any exercise of ownership over a commercial unit wrongful as against the seller once the buyer has rejected.7 Rejection leaves the goods at the seller's disposition, and a buyer who uses, alters, or sells them as its own takes the seller's choice away and contradicts the refusal it announced.
A buyer can accept by words as well as by conduct. One who signifies that it will take or retain the goods in spite of their nonconformity has accepted them.8 Section 2-606(1)(c) supplies the conduct rule: a buyer accepts goods by doing any act inconsistent with the seller's ownership, but an act that is wrongful as against the seller is an acceptance only if the seller ratifies it. The two sections divide the work. Section 2-602(2)(a) classifies the buyer's conduct as a wrong, and § 2-606(1)(c) leaves it to the seller to decide whether that wrong also converts the rejection into an acceptance.
Holding the goods is not acting as owner. The Code requires a rejecting buyer in possession to keep the goods safe for the seller,9 and possession alone does not mean acceptance: a buyer may reject after taking possession, and it keeps the right to reject even when it holds a security interest along with possession.10 The line between holding and dominion can still blur, as Clark v. Zaid, Inc. shows. The buyer there told the seller on the day of delivery that damaged furniture was entirely unacceptable and demanded that it be taken back. She later made a claim on a linoleum company for damage to the buffet. The court held that a genuine dispute of material fact barred summary judgment for the seller, because the factfinder had to decide whether she had effectively rejected the furniture or had, by making that claim, exercised such dominion, control, and authority over it as to constitute acceptance as a matter of law despite her earlier rejection.11
Courts applying the two sections together have found acceptance when a buyer goes on using goods after the defect is plain. In Lynx, Inc. v. Ordnance Products, Inc., the Maryland court recalled its decision in Fred J. Miller, Inc. v. Raymond Metal Products Co., where it found it unnecessary to decide whether the buyer's letter amounted to an acceptance or a rejection of the nonconforming pipe, because the buyer's continued use of 83 lengths of the pipe after the defect became apparent was clearly an acceptance under §§ 2-602(2)(a) and 2-606(1)(c).12 Woodward reaches the same result from the other direction. Buyers who tested machines, found defects, and kept using them “not in order to make further tests, but merely for the purpose of their own convenience or profit” had accepted them and had to rely on their warranty.13 The right to a reasonable opportunity to inspect keeps a buyer's silence from counting as acceptance until it has had time to inspect, but it does not let a buyer reject goods it has drastically changed and used and avoid a finding of acceptance, even when the defect was latent. Such a buyer keeps the remedies the Code gives for accepted goods.14
What the buyer knew matters to this line. One court read § 2-606(1)(c) to treat use of goods in ignorance of their defective nature as not “inconsistent” with the seller's ownership, because that is the only reading consistent with Code policy that leaves room for the other provisions of § 2-606.15 A buyer who has rejected has by definition found a reason to refuse the goods, so it cannot claim the benefit of that ignorance.
Step 2 carries a qualification, because some use of rejected goods is not dominion at all. The next subsection takes it up.
Reasonable Mitigating Use
Read at full breadth, § 2-602(2)(a) would bar nearly every use of rejected goods, and a buyer stuck with a rejected machine could only leave it idle until the seller came. Idleness is indeed the default: a buyer in possession with no security interest holds the goods with reasonable care at the seller's disposition.17 But courts have not treated every use as dominion. Use that serves a legitimate purpose, and goes no further than that purpose requires, is not an exercise of ownership.
Testing is the first such purpose. Buyers who keep using machines after discovering defects have accepted them when they do so “not in order to make further tests, but merely for the purpose of their own convenience or profit,”18 which implies that use to make further tests is not acceptance.
Cooperating with the seller to make the goods work is the second purpose. When buyer and seller are trying to work the bug out of a complex piece of machinery, one court has said, courts should be hesitant to find that the buyer's acts are “inconsistent with the seller's ownership.” The parties should be encouraged to engage in that bargaining and adjustment, and the buyer should not be made to engage in it at its peril.19 Stratton Industries, Inc. v. Northwest Georgia Bank carried that tolerance far. The buyer there modified a novel carpet-dyeing system that did not work and kept running it after the seller ignored its rejection, and the court did not treat those efforts as acceptance.
Preventing a larger loss is the third purpose, and the clearest. In Keller v. Inland Metals All Weather Conditioning, Inc., the seller removed the Kellers' existing 5-ton dehumidifier when it installed a 7½-ton unit. After the Kellers rejected the new unit, the seller never tried to remove it, and the Kellers could not remove it themselves. The trial court found that turning the unit off would have raised humidity enough to damage the club's facilities and to make the pool area too uncomfortable for customers to use. The reviewing court upheld the conclusion that continued use was necessary to mitigate damages and was not inconsistent with the seller's ownership, and it repeated that “a buyer may use goods without accepting them if the use is a reasonable attempt to mitigate damages.”20
The permission ends where its purpose ends. Use that continues after the testing is done, or that serves the buyer's convenience or profit, is acceptance,21 and goods the buyer has drastically changed and used cannot later be rejected without a finding of acceptance.22 Keller marks the other edge: the use was necessary, the seller never acted, and the alternative was serious damage to the buyer's facility. When the facts are close, weigh the purpose of the use, whether stopping would have increased the loss, and how far the buyer altered the goods.
A use that passes every step is not an exercise of ownership, so the acceptance and ratification questions never arise. A use that fails is an exercise of ownership, and the seller may ratify it and hold the buyer to the sale. The next subsection turns from what the buyer may do with rejected goods to what it must do.
Holding Goods With Reasonable Care
Section 2-602(2)(b) gives the rejecting buyer a custodial task, but only when two conditions are met: the buyer took physical possession of the goods before rejecting them, and it holds no security interest in them under § 2-711(3). When both are present, the buyer must hold the goods with reasonable care at the seller's disposition for a time sufficient to permit the seller to remove them.24 The duty is custodial and temporary. Rejection leaves the decision about the goods with the seller, and the buyer's job is to keep them safe and available while the seller makes it.
The possession condition describes the usual case, in which the buyer takes delivery, inspects, and then rejects. The security-interest condition sets apart a buyer with money tied up in the goods, and the next subsection explains what that buyer may do instead.
The duty is to hold the goods and make them available, not to return them. In T & S Brass and Bronze Works, Inc. v. Pic-Air, Inc., a buyer rejected defective handles and invited the seller to inspect and sort them at the buyer's own facility. The court held that the invitation placed the goods at the seller's disposal and fulfilled the buyer's immediate obligation, so the buyer's failure to return them was neither acceptance nor waiver.25
The buyer need not absorb the cost of holding the goods. The Code counts among the buyer's recoverable expenses those reasonably incurred in the care and custody of goods rightfully rejected.26
The duty to hold carries no power to destroy. In United States ex rel. Whitaker's, Inc. v. C.B.C. Enterprises, Inc., a buyer rejected cabinets and asked the seller to retrieve them, and when the seller did not, the buyer removed and discarded them. The court held that even if the rejection had been rightful, the buyer had no right to do so. The options the Code gives a buyer when the seller is silent are not exclusive, but destroying rightfully rejected goods was inconsistent with the buyer's salvage obligation. The cabinets or their components might have served another buyer, the merchant seller was better placed to judge that, and the buyer could have reshipped them at the seller's expense.
A seller that complains the rejecting buyer never shipped the goods back therefore has little to stand on unless the buyer neglected the goods or refused the seller access. The seller's course is to come and collect them within a reasonable time.
Security Interest and Resale
Section 2-602(2)(b) puts the duty to hold only on a buyer with no security interest under § 2-711(3),28 and that qualifier excludes a buyer who has paid for the goods or spent money on them. On rightful rejection, a buyer holds a security interest in goods in its possession or control for payments made on the price and for expenses reasonably incurred in their inspection, receipt, transportation, care, and custody, and it may hold the goods and resell them as an aggrieved seller would.29
The Code treats money a buyer has put into identified goods as a stake in them. A buyer that has paid some or all of the price of identified goods may in certain circumstances recover them from the seller, provided it stands ready to tender any unpaid balance.30 After rejection, the same payments appear as a security interest.
The interest answers a plain problem. A buyer that prepaid for goods it cannot use, or paid to inspect and sort them, would otherwise finance the seller's failure while it waited for repayment, holding the goods as a mere custodian. The security interest ties the goods to the debt. Holding them gives the buyer leverage, because the seller cannot take them back without making the buyer whole, and resale lets the buyer turn them into cash.
T & S Brass and Bronze Works, Inc. v. Pic-Air, Inc. shows the interest at work. The buyer had spent money inspecting and sorting defective handles, and the court held that it could retain the defective handles after sorting them from the acceptable ones, because it held a security interest in them for the cost of inspecting and sorting. The Code, the court noted, gives a buyer a security interest in rightfully rejected goods to the extent of its expenses of inspection.31
The interest also answers the argument that a rejecting buyer who holds and resells has acted as owner. In Deaton, Inc. v. Aeroglide Corp., the seller argued that the buyer's holding and resale of rejected equipment were acts inconsistent with the seller's ownership and amounted to acceptance. The New Mexico Supreme Court disagreed. A buyer who rightfully rejects has a security interest, the interest entitles it to hold and resell, and doing so does not violate § 2-602(2)(a).
The power to resell is the power of an aggrieved seller, so the buyer must use it in good faith and in a commercially reasonable manner. Deaton also shows how a buyer can forfeit the benefit of a power it holds. The buyer waited about two years to sell, while the goods deteriorated further; gave the seller no reasonable notice that it meant to sell privately; and sold only when a purchaser approached it. The court held that the resale failed the Code's requirements, noting that excessive delay can make a resale commercially unreasonable. Each limit protects what the seller still has in the goods: the proceeds reduce what the seller owes the buyer, and notice lets the seller object, collect the goods, or find a better outlet first.
The security interest also caps what the buyer may keep. A buyer that resells must account to the seller for any excess over the amount of its security interest. Suppose a buyer paid $20,000 for a machine, rightfully rejected it, and then sold it in a commercially reasonable sale for $22,000. It keeps $20,000 plus any reasonable expenses, and the other $2,000 belongs to the seller. An aggrieved seller owes no accounting for profit on a resale, but it resells goods that belong to it. The buyer holds only an interest that secures a sum, and once the sum is covered nothing remains for the buyer to claim.
On an exam, a rejecting buyer who is sitting on the goods calls for one question before any other: did it pay part of the price or reasonably spend money on the goods? If so, holding and resale are permitted and are not an exercise of ownership, provided the resale is in good faith, commercially reasonable, and followed by an accounting for any excess. If not, only the duty to hold with reasonable care applies.
Merchant Buyers' Added Duties
Two sections that § 2-602(2) is subject to expand what a rejecting buyer must or may do.33 Section 2-603 imposes an affirmative duty, and only on merchant buyers. Section 2-604 grants permissions, and to every buyer. The difference decides how exam problems come out.
Section 2-603 reaches a rejecting buyer only when three facts coincide: the buyer is a merchant, the rejected goods are in its possession or control, and the seller has no agent or place of business at the market of rejection. The buyer must then follow any reasonable instructions the seller gives about the goods and, absent instructions, make reasonable efforts to sell them for the seller's account if they are perishable or threaten to decline in value speedily. Each condition has a reason. A merchant knows the market and has outlets, so it can sell without learning the business from scratch. A seller with an agent or place of business at the market can deal with the goods itself. And the duty arises only where delay would destroy the value of the goods, which is why it stops at perishable or fast-declining goods.
The merchant does not bear the cost of that effort. A buyer that sells under § 2-603 is entitled to reimbursement for the reasonable expenses of caring for and selling the goods. In one case, a buyer that cared for and sold nonconforming trees recovered the rent for a selling site and the wages of its salesmen and a night watchman as expenses of disposing of the trees for the sellers' account.34 A buyer who acts in good faith under the section has neither accepted the goods nor converted them. That protection is necessary because a sale is the plainest exercise of ownership, which § 2-602(2)(a) makes wrongful as against the seller.35
Section 2-604 applies to any buyer, merchant or not, once the seller gives no instructions within a reasonable time after notification of rejection. The buyer may then store the goods for the seller's account, reship them to the seller, or resell them for the seller's account, with reimbursement as under § 2-603, and none of those steps counts as acceptance or conversion. Where § 2-603 compels a sale because the goods cannot wait, § 2-604 lets the buyer choose among three ways of protecting or realizing on the goods, and it spares the buyer a finding of acceptance for conduct that might otherwise look like ownership. As the cabinet decision above shows, the listed steps are not exclusive, but a step outside the list must still respect the buyer's salvage obligation.
The two sections divide along three lines. Section 2-603 reaches only merchants; § 2-604 reaches every buyer. Section 2-603 applies where the seller has no presence at the market and the goods are perishable or fast-declining; § 2-604 applies once the seller stays silent for a reasonable time after notice. Section 2-603 compels reasonable efforts to sell; § 2-604 permits storage, reshipment, or resale and compels none of them.
Because § 2-602(2) is subject to both sections, even its statement that the buyer has no further obligations must be read with the merchant's duty in mind.36 A rightful rejection ordinarily frees the buyer of further duties, yet a merchant holding spoiling goods in a market where the seller is absent must still try to sell them, at the seller's expense.
Limit on Further Obligations
Section 2-602(2)(c) closes the list by fixing its length: the buyer has “no further obligations with regard to goods rightfully rejected.”38 “Further” looks back to everything above. The buyer must stay off the goods as owner; if it holds them without a security interest, it must keep them with reasonable care; and §§ 2-603 and 2-604 add what they add. Nothing else may be implied. The Code stops at the minimum the seller needs to deal with the goods, because every extra burden would shift a cost of the seller's failed performance onto the buyer. The limit remains subject to §§ 2-603 and 2-604, so a merchant holding spoiling goods in a market where the seller is absent must still try to sell.
Three consequences follow. The first is that the buyer owes no price. A buyer must accept and pay for the goods in accordance with the contract,39 so a buyer that accepts nonconforming goods owes the contract price and is left to its remedy for breach of warranty. In one case, a buyer who never revoked his acceptance of the equipment, which was still in his home at trial, owed the contract price and could recover only the damages he could prove under § 2-714.40 Goods rightfully rejected were never accepted, so no price falls due for them. Atlan Industries, Inc. v. O.E.M., Inc. reached that result for a buyer whose revocation of acceptance was justified: the court denied the seller's claim for the price.
The second consequence is that the buyer need not ship the goods back. In T & S Brass, the buyer's invitation to the seller to inspect and sort the handles at the buyer's own facility fulfilled its obligation, so keeping the handles was neither acceptance nor waiver.41 The third is that the care the buyer owes has a ceiling. Reasonable care is the measure of its responsibility, and a buyer that has met it need not do more to preserve the goods. The reasonable expenses of what it did are recoverable from the seller.42
The protection is written for goods rightfully rejected, and the earlier discussion of wrongful but effective rejection explains why the adjective matters. A rejection that is timely and communicated is effective, and an effective rejection is not an acceptance. Rejection is rightful only if the goods or the tender fail to conform to the contract,43 so a buyer that refuses a conforming tender has breached even though its rejection took effect, and the seller keeps the remedies the Code gives against a breaching buyer.44 The reverse failure is procedural. A rejection that is rightful in substance but ineffective in procedure leaves no rejected goods at all, because the buyer is treated as having accepted them, and its rights no longer include rejection.45
Having no obligations is not the same as having new powers. Subsection (2)(c) tells the buyer what it need not do, while the Code defines separately what the buyer may do: store, reship, or resell for the seller's account when the seller is silent, and hold or resell under a security interest. Throwing goods away appears on neither list, and it is something only an owner does, which § 2-602(2)(a) makes wrongful as against the seller.46 The buyer in the cabinet decision learned that salvage value is the question to ask, and the rule that it had no further obligations did not answer it.