Concept
Rightful Versus Effective Rejection
Rightful rejection
Rightful Versus Effective Rejection
A rejection can be right without working, and it can work without being right. Section 2-602(1) explains why, because it regulates only how a buyer rejects: the buyer must reject within a reasonable time after delivery or tender, and the rejection is ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller.1 The text never asks whether the goods were defective, so every rejection raises two independent questions.
The substantive question asks whether the buyer had a right to refuse these goods. A rejection is rightful when the buyer has not yet accepted the goods, the goods or their tender fail to conform to the contract, and the seller either has no cure right or has not exercised it effectively and rightfully. It is wrongful when any of those conditions is missing.2 The procedural question asks whether the buyer followed § 2-602. Rejection within a reasonable time, followed by seasonable notice, is effective; missing either requirement makes it ineffective.3
Two answers to each question yield four combinations, and the combination decides whether the buyer ends up owing the price, owing damages, or owing nothing:
- A rightful and effective rejection succeeds on its terms. The buyer owes no price and takes on the post-rejection duties and privileges covered below.4
- A rightful but ineffective rejection is no rejection at all. By the passage of time the buyer is deemed to have accepted the goods, owes the price, and keeps at most the narrower remedy of revocation under § 2-608.5
- A wrongful but effective rejection is a real rejection. It ends the buyer's obligation to pay, but it breaches the contract and exposes the buyer to damages.6
- A wrongful and ineffective rejection never takes hold, so the buyer can be liable for the balance of the purchase price.7
The two middle combinations surprise students, because instinct says a buyer with good grounds should fare better than a buyer with none. The Code instead asks what the seller needs in order to act. Prompt notice lets the seller cure if it has a cure right, keep the goods as evidence against a carrier or subcontractor when quality is in dispute, act to save value in goods that may perish or decline, and cart the goods away.8 A silent buyer takes all of that from the seller and is treated as keeping the goods. A buyer who speaks in time lets the seller take the goods back and limit its loss, and if the buyer erred, the seller's remaining harm is a claim for damages.9 The next two subsections take the middle combinations in turn. On an exam, label every rejection on both axes before computing any money, because the label decides which party holds the claim.
Ineffective Rejection Becomes Acceptance
A buyer with a genuine complaint can lose the right to reject simply by letting the clock run. Section 2-602(1) makes a rejection effective only if it comes within a reasonable time and the buyer seasonably notifies the seller,10 and § 2-606(1)(b) completes the thought: a buyer accepts goods by failing to reject them effectively.11 The “reasonable opportunity to inspect” language protects the buyer's silence only until it has had adequate time to inspect; after that, silence operates as acceptance.12 The strength of the buyer's grounds does not change the result, because a rightful but ineffective rejection is no rejection at all.13
The order of the chain tracks what the seller loses by hearing nothing. It cannot cure, cannot retrieve goods that may lose value, and cannot preserve claims against third parties, so the Code leaves the loss of the rejection remedy with the buyer who stayed quiet.18 The fallback remedies exist but demand more. A buyer may accept goods it knew or should have known were nonconforming, so it cannot revoke merely because the tender fell short of perfect; revocation reaches only a nonconformity that substantially impairs the goods' value to the buyer.19 Revocation also requires notice to the seller within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered the ground, and before any substantial change in the condition of the goods.20 Damages for accepted goods survive, because a buyer does not lose its claim for breach of warranty merely by accepting.21 But the buyer must give timely notice of any claim for breach or be barred from any remedy.22
Connecticut Inv. Casting Corp. v. Made-Rite Tool Co. runs the chain from start to finish. The buyer inspected the latches it received, complained about some of them, and pressed the seller to deliver, but it never told the seller it would not keep what it had.23 A buyer that keeps pressing for delivery has not refused what it already holds, so there was no effective rejection and the buyer accepted the goods under § 2-606(1)(b).24 Revocation could not rescue the buyer, because notice of revocation must reach the seller within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered the ground.25 A message reporting late or nonconforming parts may preserve a damages claim, but it does not tell the seller that the buyer is giving up the goods. The buyer therefore owed the contract rate and, having proved no offsetting damages, owed the full price.26
EPN-Delaval, S.A. v. Inter-Equip, Inc. shows the same chain defeating a buyer whose complaint was sound. The nonconforming heads reached the buyer's plant in Mexico on April 24, and the buyer, whose quality control staff worked close by, should have found the problem shortly afterward.27 The court held that the buyer did not give notice of rejection within a reasonable time after delivery, so it accepted the heads.28 Each fallback then failed for the same reason. Revocation had to come within weeks, not months, and the buyer could not show that difficulty of discovery induced its acceptance.29 Damages failed because the buyer did not notify the seller of breach within a reasonable time after it should have discovered the nonconformity. Notice two months earlier would have put the seller in a better position to cure, and given the seller's flexible approach to nonconforming goods, it would probably have prevented the lawsuit.30 Where Made-Rite shows the price following acceptance, EPN-Delaval shows a single delay defeating rejection, revocation, and damages together, because each depends on timely word to the seller.
Conduct can produce acceptance by a different route, and Audio Visual Artistry v. Tanzer splits the outcome within one installation. The buyer kept nearly all of the installed equipment and hired a firm to maintain it, an act inconsistent with the seller's ownership.31 The court found that he had rejected or revoked only as to the phone system and the Escient music system. For the equipment still in his home he owed the contract price, and his remedies were limited to damages for accepted goods on proof of breach of warranty.32 Conduct can also undo a rejection that was timely when made. In one furniture dispute, the court found a genuine fact question whether the buyer had told the seller on delivery day that damaged furniture was unacceptable and demanded its return, or had instead exercised such dominion, control and authority over the furniture, by making a claim against a linoleum company for damage to the buffet, as to constitute acceptance despite her earlier rejection.33
Students most often skip the difference between notice of rejection and notice of breach. Notice of rejection must reach the seller seasonably after delivery, and it prevents acceptance.34 Notice of breach is a separate requirement. The buyer must give it within a reasonable time after it discovers or should have discovered the nonconformity, and without it the buyer cannot recover damages on accepted goods.35 The requirement serves the seller by letting it adjust or replace the goods, prepare for negotiation and litigation, and gain the repose a limitations period gives.36 A buyer that sends only the second kind of message may have preserved a damages claim, but it still owes the price. When a problem gives you a buyer who was right about the defect and wrong about the calendar, treat the rejection as ineffective, the goods as accepted, and the price as owed, and then ask what survives under revocation and damages.
Wrongful but Effective Rejection
A rejection can breach the contract and still work. Section 2-602(3) points the same way when it provides that the seller's rights with respect to goods wrongfully rejected “are governed by the provisions of this Article on Seller's remedies in general (Section 2-703).”38 The preceding subsection showed a buyer with a genuine complaint losing the right to reject because it missed the procedure. This subsection runs the other way: a buyer with no right to refuse that gives timely notice has rejected in fact, and the seller must look to its remedies for breach.
A rejection is wrongful when the buyer had no substantive right to refuse. The plain case is a conforming tender, because the buyer's duty is to accept and pay for goods in accordance with the contract.39 Whether the refusal is effective is a separate question, and § 2-602(1) answers it without asking about the buyer's reasons.40 Effectiveness depends on a procedure, timely notice, without regard to the basis for rejection, so a wrongful rejection is as effective as a rightful one. The buyer breaches, but its rejection still operates as one.41
The consequence for the seller follows from the definition of acceptance, which includes failing to reject effectively.42 An effective rejection prevents acceptance, and an action for the price lies only for accepted goods and a few special situations, such as goods that are lost, damaged, or not resalable.43 Integrated Circuits Unlimited, Inc. v. E.F. Johnson Co. applied that reasoning and treated the buyer's rejection as effective whether or not it was justified, because any effective rejection protects the buyer from a price action.44 If the buyer erred, the seller sues for damages under § 2-706 or § 2-708, not under § 2-709, because the seller already has the goods.45
This result can look backward. A buyer whose goods really were defective, and who stayed silent, ends up holding the goods and owing for them, while a buyer with no grievance who spoke up gets rid of the goods. The explanation lies again in what the seller needs in order to act. A seller who receives timely notice can take the goods back and preserve their value, which limits the loss.46 A seller who hears nothing can do none of that, so the silent buyer is treated as having kept the goods, although it still has its damages claim for accepted goods.47 The two halves of the rule therefore answer separate questions. Effectiveness decides who holds the goods, and it turns on whether the seller learned in time to act. Wrongfulness decides whether the buyer owes damages, and it turns on whether the buyer had a right to refuse. A price judgment on top of returned goods would leave the seller with both the goods and the money, which is why the price is reserved for goods the buyer keeps.
Section 2-703 serves as a pointer to the seller's general remedies, and what the seller recovers depends on what became of the goods.48 A seller that resells recovers under § 2-706, and a seller that does not can use the market-price measure of § 2-708.49 Both measures compensate for the buyer's breach and leave the goods with the seller.
Both wholesalers were equally wrong on the merits, so the merits cannot explain the different outcomes. What separated them was whether the seller learned in time that the goods were refused, and that is the only question § 2-602(1) asks about effectiveness.
Opinions and headings blur these labels, so the facts of what the buyer did deserve more attention than the adjectives a court uses. The heading of § 2-602 speaks of “Rightful Rejection,” yet the text regulates only the manner of rejection. The heading and Official Comment 3 mislead to the extent they suggest that only a justified rejection is effective.50 Judicial language drifts the same way. One footnote states that a rejection wrongful under the Code is deemed ineffective and the goods are viewed as accepted.51 Integrated Circuits rejected that formulation. It quoted Blue Sky Forest Products, Inc. v. New Hampshire Doors Co. for the point that a statement that a wrongful rejection constitutes acceptance is incorrect, because the remedies for wrongful rejection are separate and only an ineffective rejection may be an acceptance.52
Lynx, Inc. v. Ordnance Products, Inc. quotes an earlier Maryland decision stating that a rejection that was “unwarranted and ineffective” could leave the buyer liable for the balance of the purchase price.53 The statement is accurate when both adjectives apply, but the liability for the price comes from the ineffectiveness, because ineffectiveness is what converts the refusal into an acceptance. A student who treats the two words as interchangeable will wrongly award the seller the price against a buyer who gave timely notice. The reliable method is to ignore the labels and ask two questions of the facts. Did the buyer have grounds to refuse? Did the buyer reject within a reasonable time with seasonable notice? Only the second answer decides whether the price is available.
Effectiveness also assumes that the buyer afterward behaves like one who has rejected. Section 2-602(2)(a) makes any exercise of ownership over a commercial unit after rejection wrongful as against the seller, a duty taken up next.54