Concept
Inspection Before Payment
Obligations of the parties
Inspection Before Payment
The buyer's duty is to accept and pay "in accordance with the contract," so the price is owed for what the contract promised.1 A buyer cannot tell whether it is being asked to pay for that without looking at the goods. The Code therefore gives the buyer a right of inspection.2 Where goods are tendered, delivered, or identified to the contract for sale, the buyer may inspect them before paying or accepting, so long as the inspection occurs at a reasonable time and place and in a reasonable manner.3 The right attaches before payment and before acceptance. Those are the two moments at which a buyer commits itself to goods it might otherwise refuse.
Most buyers do not want to pay until they are certain they have received the goods they paid for.4 The Code builds that preference into its default rule. Sellers control the goods that are delivered, and so they are best placed to make sure the buyer receives what it ordered.5 A buyer who must pay first and examine later has parted with its money before it knows whether the goods conform. Examination before payment keeps the money with the buyer until it has checked.
The buyer bears the expense of inspecting. If it rightfully rejects the goods, it may recover that expense from the seller.6 The word "rightfully" ties the recovery to goods that genuinely justify rejection. A buyer who inspects, finds the goods acceptable, and keeps them has rejected nothing and has no claim against the seller for the cost.
Inspection also puts the buyer at risk. A buyer who fails to find a defect that would warrant rejection may be deemed to have accepted the goods and to owe the contract price.7 That is why the buyer must understand what counts as an opportunity to inspect. A look that misses a flaw a reasonable look would have found can leave the buyer holding goods it can no longer refuse.
A payment made along the way does not change this analysis. The secondary source treats a $500 down payment as a red herring in just such a dispute and stresses how explicit the Code is that the buyer may inspect "prior to making payment or accepting the goods."8 What decides the question is whether the inspection occurred at a reasonable time and place and in a reasonable manner. A deposit, standing alone, does not.
Inspection is the first step in a sequence that later readings complete. The buyer's right of inspection under § 2-513 leads, depending on what the buyer finds, to the buyer's right under § 2-601 to reject goods or a tender that fails to conform to the contract. It also leads to the seller's right under § 2-508 to cure an improper delivery.9 Each of those rights has its own requirements, and the treatise takes them up when it turns to acceptance and rejection. For now the connection is enough. The duty to accept and pay runs to conforming goods. The inspection right lets the buyer find out whether the goods conform. A buyer who inspects carelessly may lose the chance to refuse them.