Concept
Payment When the Contract Is Silent
Obligations of the parties
Payment When the Contract Is Silent
Section 2-301 requires the buyer to accept and pay “in accordance with the contract.”1 That instruction has content only when the contract speaks, and many contracts name the goods and the price and stop. Yet “pay” is not a single act. A buyer who pays has settled three things: the form of the price (cash or credit), the time it changes hands, and the place. Where the agreement addresses one of these, the agreement controls. Where it does not, Article 2 supplies a default term for that point.
Each default estimates what the parties likely would have agreed had they discussed the point, and courts and legislatures draw it from common expectations, commercial practice, and public policy.2 A default fills only a gap, so it yields to an express term on the same subject, and it yields one subject at a time.3 A contract that fixes the date of payment but is silent on its form keeps the agreed date and borrows the Code’s rule on form.
The stakes are practical, because payment is the other half of the concurrent exchange described earlier in this chapter. Whether a seller may hold the goods until paid, and whether a buyer who has not yet paid is in breach, both turn on how and when payment was due. For any payment problem, first identify which of the three aspects is in dispute, then check whether the agreement already speaks to it. The first subsection below takes up the form of payment; the second takes up time and place, which rests on the earlier distinction between tender and receipt.
Cash Unless Credit Agreed
A contract that never mentions credit gives the phrase “in accordance with the contract” nothing to apply to the question, so Article 2 fills the gap with cash.4 If the agreement is silent, the buyer must pay cash on the barrelhead, and a buyer who wants credit must bargain for it.5
The rule looks backward at first, because in most commercial sales in which the parties do address credit, the seller extends it.6 A default is meant to approximate what the parties likely would have agreed, and that goal seems to favor a presumption of credit.7 The Code’s theory of the concurrent exchange points the other way. Absent contrary agreement, the buyer is entitled to full possession and control of the goods only where it concurrently tenders payment.8 Credit departs from that exchange: the seller releases the goods before the price arrives and bears the risk that it never does. A seller takes on that risk only by choosing to, and silence shows only that the parties agreed on the goods and the price. The Code therefore puts the burden of raising credit on the party who wants it.
Credit can enter a contract in two ways. An express term, such as payment thirty days after delivery, displaces the default, because the buyer’s duty is measured by the contract.9 Credit may also be established as a matter of fact from the circumstances of the deal, because a legally implied term is usually applied only when no pertinent contextual evidence establishes the term.10 An exam stem that reports conforming goods received and a price still unpaid is therefore asking whether the agreement, or the setting of the deal, said anything about credit.
The credit term alone moved the result. In the first version the foreman’s claim fails because nothing in the agreement or in the circumstances of the deal gives the company credit, and its own payment habit is not the nursery’s agreement. In the second version the claim succeeds because § 2-301 measures the buyer’s duty by the contract. A student who assumes that commercial sales are normally on credit will misjudge a silent contract. The analysis starts from cash at the exchange and reaches credit only when an express term or established circumstances put it on the table. Two neighboring questions stay separate: the buyer’s right to look at the goods before paying belongs to the later reading on inspection, and the exact time and place at which cash falls due come next.
Time and Place of Payment
Cash still leaves two questions open: when the money changes hands, and where. When the agreement addresses neither, § 2-310(a) answers both: payment is due “at the time and place at which the buyer is to receive the goods even though the place of shipment is the place of delivery.”12 The default ties payment to the buyer’s receipt of the goods, and its closing clause confirms that a seller who delivers at the place of shipment does not thereby pull the buyer’s payment back to that place.
The rule depends on keeping two events apart. Receipt means the buyer’s taking physical possession of the goods, so it occurs wherever the buyer is to take possession.13 Delivery in a shipment contract is the seller’s performance: the seller need only make an appropriate contract for shipment and get conforming goods into the carrier’s possession.14 That happens where the seller is, and the buyer is somewhere else. When the buyer collects the goods at the seller’s own premises, the two events coincide, and payment falls due at the time and place of delivery.15 The choice matters only when a carrier stands between seller and buyer, and there the Code chooses receipt.
Two reasons support that choice, and they work differently. The first is convenience. Unless the parties agree otherwise, a buyer may inspect before paying, and it should not have to travel to the seller’s city to exercise that right at the moment the seller hands the goods to a carrier, so the Code defers the duty to pay to the time and place of receipt, where inspection is easy.16 The second is incentive. Buyers generally do not want to pay until they are sure they have received what they ordered, and the seller, who controls what is shipped, is best placed to see that the goods match the order. Making the seller wait for payment until the buyer can judge conformity gives the seller a reason to use that position well.17 The inspection right itself, including what makes a time and place for it reasonable, belongs to a later reading in this chapter. Here it matters only as the reason the payment default sits where it does.
The dealer’s position turns entirely on where receipt occurs, and it does not depend on any claim that the trailer was defective. A buyer who receives conforming goods still pays on receipt, because the default governs only the timing and place of payment. What a buyer may do about nonconforming goods is a different problem, taken up in later readings.
Deferring the duty to pay does not hand the buyer the goods on credit. Absent contrary agreement, the buyer is entitled to full possession and control of the goods only where it concurrently tenders payment, so the seller must make the goods available for inspection but need not give them up until payment arrives.18 A seller shipping to a distant buyer can preserve that control by procuring a document of title from the carrier in appropriate form, such as a negotiable bill of lading to the seller’s own order, which obliges the carrier to follow the seller’s instructions about the goods.19 The law of documents of title is a separate subject; the result is what matters here. The seller can hold the goods until the buyer pays at the place of receipt, so the concurrent exchange survives the distance between the two cities.
Like every gap filler, the payment default yields to the parties’ own terms. A buyer may agree to pay against documents that arrive before the goods, and then the buyer pays before receipt because the contract says so; payment on receipt governs only in the absence of contrary agreement.20 The result follows from § 2-301, which measures the buyer’s duty by the contract.21 An exam stem that mentions payment against documents therefore signals that the default has been displaced on that subject, and a buyer who withholds payment until the goods arrive has breached.
Students make two recurring mistakes with this default. The first treats the handoff to the carrier as the moment the price falls due. That handoff completes the seller’s tender, but proper tender entitles the seller to “payment according to the contract,” and the default places that payment at receipt.22 The second mistake runs the other way and reads payment on receipt as permission to pay less. A seller who denies any breach of warranty is not required to give up the goods in return for a reduced price, and it does not breach by refusing to relinquish possession when the buyer will accept only on reduced terms.23