Concept
Tender, Delivery, and Receipt
Obligations of the parties
Tender, Delivery, and Receipt
Article 2 obligates the seller to transfer and deliver the goods and the buyer to accept and pay, each in accordance with the contract.1 That statement leaves two questions open: what must a seller do to perform the duty to deliver, and when has it done so? Article 2 answers both through tender, the seller's act of putting conforming goods at the buyer's disposal.2
The buyer's side of the bargain waits on tender. Under § 2-507(1) the buyer's obligation to pay is conditional on the seller's tender of the goods, and § 2-511(1) in turn requires the seller to tender only if the buyer tenders payment.3 The moment of tender therefore decides when the buyer's payment duty comes into play.
Three terms must stay apart to apply that rule. Tender is the seller's act of putting the goods at the buyer's disposal. Delivery is the duty the seller owes under the contract, and tender is how the seller performs it. Receipt is the buyer's taking of physical possession.4 A buyer who collects goods at the seller's counter experiences all three at once. The distinctions matter when the events come apart, as they do when goods must travel: the seller acts long before the buyer sees anything, and someone must decide whether that earlier act is tender or whether tender waits for arrival.
The subsections below first set out what makes a tender good, then show how a contract authorizing shipment puts tender ahead of receipt.
What Tender Requires
Tender of delivery requires the seller to put and hold conforming goods at the buyer's disposition and to give the buyer any notification reasonably necessary to enable the buyer to take delivery.5 The tender must come at a reasonable hour, and the goods must stay available for the period reasonably necessary for the buyer to take possession.6 A seller whose act falls short of these requirements has not tendered, so the condition on the buyer's duty to pay remains unmet.7
Each requirement guards against a different way a buyer could be left unable to act. Without notice, the buyer cannot take delivery of goods it does not know are ready, and the seller alone knows when it has set them aside. A reasonable hour keeps the seller from choosing a moment the buyer cannot practically meet, such as a time when the buyer's premises are closed. A tender that vanishes before the buyer can respond gives the buyer nothing, so the goods must wait long enough for the buyer to arrange pickup and collect them. Conformity ties the whole exercise to the contract; without it, a seller could complete every logistical step with goods the buyer never agreed to buy.
Steps three through five carry the most factual variation, since reasonableness depends on the circumstances of the sale. Where the parties have addressed the point, their agreement governs. Time, place, and manner of delivery are open to agreement, and § 1-302(b) lets the parties set standards for the reasonable time of tender.8 A contract that fixes a receiving window therefore supplies the standard for a reasonable time of tender, while a contract silent on the hour leaves the question to reasonableness.
Conformity deserves emphasis because a seller can do everything the second supplier did and still fail. A seller who gives perfect notice and holds the goods available for a week, but whose goods differ from what the contract described, has taken every logistical step without tendering, because the seller's duty is measured against the contract.9 What a buyer may do with nonconforming goods, including rejecting them and the seller's chance to cure, belongs to other readings. For tender, it is enough that notice and availability cannot make up for goods that miss the contract.
Tender is the seller's act, but a buyer can take delivery only if it is in a position to receive. The buyer is therefore responsible for furnishing facilities suitable for receipt of the goods.10 The seller controls the goods up to the moment of tender, and the buyer controls its own premises, equipment, and staff, so each side carries the part of the exchange it is positioned to manage.
Tender must also be kept distinct from receipt. Receipt is the buyer's taking of physical possession, and because tender occurs when the goods are put at the buyer's disposal, tender comes first.11 A seller who has properly tendered at its warehouse has performed even though the goods still sit on its floor; the buyer's task from that point is to come and take them. The next subsection shows how the gap between tender and receipt widens when the contract authorizes shipment.
Shipment Contracts and Receipt
The seller's duty to deliver is measured against the contract, so what a seller must do to deliver depends on what the parties arranged.13 The previous subsection covered the simplest arrangement, in which the seller tenders by putting conforming goods at the buyer's disposal.14 Many sales involve goods that must travel, and for those the Code supplies a second rule. If the contract authorizes shipment and does not require the seller to deliver the goods to a particular place, tender of delivery occurs under § 2-504(1) when the seller arranges for shipment and puts the goods into the carrier's possession.15 In this kind of contract, called a shipment contract, the seller's performance is complete at the seller's end of the journey, although the buyer has not yet seen the goods.
Tender falls at the carrier's dock because the handoff completes everything the seller agreed to do. A seller who agreed only to ship has promised to make an appropriate contract for shipment and to get conforming goods into the carrier's possession.16 The buyer's physical possession comes later and somewhere else, which is why the Code treats it as a separate event. Receipt consists in the buyer's taking physical possession of the goods, so the seller's tender occurs before the buyer receives them, and tender of delivery does not mean that the buyer has received anything.17
A handoff to a carrier tenders delivery only if the seller does it in the manner the Code requires. In La Casse v. Blaustein, a package that was underinsured, misaddressed, sent by fourth-class mail, and marked with a theft-tempting inscription failed that test: the court held that § 2-504 was not met, and the risk of loss did not pass.18 The case arose over risk of loss. For tender, it shows that a careless shipment does not carry the legal effect of a proper one.
Whether a handoff to a carrier is tender at all depends on the kind of contract the parties made, so a fact pattern that gives one date for shipment and a later date for arrival is first asking what the contract required. Trade terms usually answer the question. A term such as F.O.B. the seller's place of business makes a shipment contract, in which the seller's only obligations are to make an appropriate contract for shipment and to get conforming goods into the carrier's possession. A term such as F.O.B. the place of destination requires the seller to transport the goods to that place at its own expense and risk and there tender delivery.19
The same trade terms also allocate risk of loss, a question for another chapter. For tender, the only question is where the seller's duty to deliver is complete.
The gap between tender and receipt matters most for payment. A buyer may agree to prepay, as when it agrees to pay against documents that arrive before the goods, but absent contrary agreement the default rule of payment on receipt applies.20 In a shipment contract, then, tender at the carrier's dock satisfies the condition on the buyer's duty to pay, while payment itself falls due when the buyer receives the goods. Shipping also does not strip the seller of control. Even when the buyer is to receive the goods in a city far from the seller's place of business, the seller can keep full possession and control by procuring a document of title from the carrier, such as a negotiable bill of lading to the seller's own order or a nonnegotiable bill naming the seller as consignee. Documents in that form require the carrier to obey the seller's instructions about the goods.21 Later sections on payment and inspection develop these defaults.
A student who equates tender with receipt will date the seller's performance from the goods' arrival and conclude that goods in transit have not been tendered. In a shipment contract that conclusion is wrong, because the contract itself puts tender at the carrier's dock and leaves receipt for later. The opposite error treats every handoff to a carrier as tender and overlooks the destination contract, which requires delivery at a particular place.