Concept
Concurrent Performance of Duties
Obligations of the parties
Concurrent Performance of Duties
Section 2-301 states what each side owes: the seller must transfer and deliver, and the buyer must accept and pay, in accordance with the contract.1 It does not say who must move first. Two companion provisions supply the answer, and they read as mirror images. Section 2-507(1) makes the buyer's obligation to pay conditional on the seller's tender of the goods, and § 2-511(1) requires the seller to tender the goods only if the buyer tenders payment.2 Because each duty depends on the other, the two performances are concurrent. The seller need not deliver unless the buyer pays, and the buyer need not pay unless the seller delivers.
Both provisions say expressly that they apply "unless otherwise agreed," so concurrency is a default that the parties' agreement can displace.3 The qualifier echoes the basic rule that each side performs in accordance with the contract. Parties may make payment and delivery sequential, and a sequence they chose controls. When the contract is silent, the default stays in place: the seller has no duty to deliver if the buyer does not pay, and the buyer has no duty to pay if the seller has not tendered.
The credit term does the work in the second version of the hypothetical. A seller who extends credit has agreed to part with the goods before it receives the price, and it gives up the right to hold them until payment. The default puts the burden of bargaining on the party who wants the exception. When the agreement is silent about credit, the Code fills the gap by requiring the buyer to pay cash.4 The cash rule and the timing of payment come up again in a later section. Here the point is narrower: a credit term is the clearest way for parties to turn concurrent performance into sequential performance.
The case for the default is easiest to see by imagining the alternative. Suppose each party's obligation were independent of the other's. Each would have to perform even if the other had breached. The performing party could sue, but a suit costs money, and recovery of the loss is not guaranteed. When each duty is conditioned on the other's performance, a party facing a breach is excused from performing at all. It is spared the cost of performing and then recovering the value of that performance. It may still fail to recover its whole loss, but its expected loss from the other side's breach is smaller.5 That reasoning is what one expects from a good gap filler. Standard terms supplied by law rest on common expectations, commercial practice, and public policy, and they are meant to reflect what the parties likely would have agreed had they discussed the issue. A court that applies them is engaged in construction rather than fact-based interpretation.6
The CISG does not expressly state that the seller's duty of delivery and the buyer's duty of payment are concurrent. As under the UCC, these obligations are default terms, and the parties can alter them in accordance with Article 6.7
A recurring exam question asks whether concurrency lets a buyer who suspects a defect take the goods and pay less. When the seller denies the defect, the answer is no. Section 2-507(1) entitles a seller who makes a proper tender to "payment according to the contract." Nothing in the Code's provisions on tender requires the seller to give up the goods in return for reduced payment. If the buyer refuses acceptance except on reduced terms, the seller does not breach by refusing to relinquish possession.8 If the seller admits the breach, it may of course agree to the reduction, and no dispute arises.
Distance does not force the seller to surrender control early either. Even when the buyer is to receive the goods in a city far from the seller's place of business, the seller can keep full possession and control by procuring a document of title from the carrier in appropriate form. Examples are a negotiable bill of lading to the seller's own order or a nonnegotiable bill of lading naming the seller as consignee, and the carrier must then obey the seller's instructions about the goods.9