Concept
Applying the Threshold Questions
Identification of goods
Applying the Threshold Questions
Three questions belong at the top of every sales problem, and the Code supplies the text for each. Article 2 applies, unless the context otherwise requires, to transactions in goods, and a hybrid transaction falls under it only to the extent its own subsection provides.1 Because Article 2 has separate rules for merchant and non-merchant sellers, the definition of “merchant” matters.2 That definition reaches a person who deals in goods of the kind, a person who by occupation holds himself out as having knowledge or skill peculiar to the practices or goods involved, and a person to whom such knowledge or skill is attributed through an agent, broker, or other intermediary.3 A transaction is “between merchants” only when both parties are chargeable with the knowledge or skill of merchants.4 Finally, goods must be both existing and identified before any interest in them can pass. Goods that are not both are future goods, and a purported present sale of future goods operates as a contract to sell.5
Earlier sections developed each question on its own. This section joins them into one working method and tests it on two sales that come out differently because of a single fact.
The order matters because each answer decides whether the next question has any work to do. A deal outside Article 2 never reaches the merchant or identification rules. Those rules serve transactions in goods, and goods are things movable at the time of identification to the contract, which land is not.6 A deal inside Article 2 raises the merchant question only if the rule you are applying asks it. Article 2 governs a householder's sale of one used saw as readily as a wholesaler's carload, because its scope turns on the transaction and not on the parties' status.7 A strong exam answer follows the same path. It frames the issue, shows that Article 2 applies because the item is movable and therefore a good (a painting is), and only then turns to the rule in dispute.8 Even then the Code does not displace everything. Preexisting principles of law and equity continue to supplement it unless a particular provision displaces them, so the threshold questions tell you which Code rules to consult without ending the common law's role.9
Step two is where the facts meet the statutory wording, because rules differ in whose status they test. Some name the seller alone. Others require a transaction between merchants, which is unavailable unless both parties are chargeable with a merchant's knowledge or skill.10 For each party a rule names, test the facts against the definition's routes: dealing in goods of the kind, holding oneself out by occupation as having the relevant knowledge or skill, or having that knowledge or skill attributed through an agent or broker.11 A few provisions name a financing agency instead of a merchant, and that role depends on what the person does. A financing agency makes advances against goods or documents of title, or intervenes by arrangement with the seller or the buyer to make or collect payment under the contract for sale, even by merely taking the seller's draft for collection.12 A bank that lends against the seller's goods or simply takes its draft for collection fits that language. A bank making a general loan with no tie to the goods or to payment under a sale does not appear to.
The residuary rule on risk of loss shows the method at work, because its text turns on one status fact. In any case not within subsections (1) or (2) of § 2-509, the carrier and bailee situations taken up later, the risk of loss passes to the buyer on receipt of the goods if the seller is a merchant, and otherwise on tender of delivery.13 Tender of delivery requires the seller to put and hold conforming goods at the buyer's disposition and to give any notification reasonably necessary to enable the buyer to take delivery.14
Consider two sales to the same buyer. Stan, a schoolteacher who has finished a woodworking project, sells his used band saw to Beulah. She agrees to bring the balance and a truck on Saturday. Stan keeps the saw ready in his garage and tells her so. Beulah does not come until a week after the agreed date, which we assume is longer than any reasonable time, and by then a thief has taken the saw from the garage. The loss falls on Beulah. Stan is not a merchant, so the risk passed to her on tender. Stan had done everything in his power to make conforming goods available, and Beulah had been given a reasonable time to take possession.15
Beulah also orders a new band saw from Big Box Store (BBS), a retailer that deals in tools. Two days later BBS tells her the saw has arrived and she may pick it up at any time during store hours. Before she comes, a flood in the store's stockroom ruins the saw. Because BBS is a merchant, the risk of loss does not pass to Beulah until she takes possession of the saw, so the loss is BBS's.16
Running the three questions over both sales shows where the answers diverge. At step one, each saw is a movable thing sold for a price, so Article 2 governs both deals, although Stan is not in business.17 At step two, the residuary rule asks about the seller alone. The answer is no for Stan, who sells one used saw, and yes for BBS, which deals in goods of the kind.18 At step three, Stan's saw exists and is the particular saw the contract describes. BBS's saw is harder. If BBS ordered it before any particular unit was designated for Beulah, the goods were not yet identified and were future goods, so the deal operated as a contract to sell. Assume the unit that arrived was the one set aside for her, and the gap has closed by the time BBS calls.19 The allocation of loss in both sales still comes from the residuary rule's text, which asks about the seller's status and the buyer's receipt or tender and says nothing about identification. Step two decides the outcome.
The seller's status controls because the rule follows control and insurance. A merchant who makes physical delivery at its own place continues to control the goods in the meantime and can be expected to insure its interest in them. The buyer controls nothing and is unlikely to carry insurance on goods not yet in hand.20 A person who owns goods, or would suffer a financial loss if they were damaged, has an insurable interest and may validly insure them.21 A casual seller who has done everything in his power to make conforming goods available no longer controls what happens to them once the buyer has had a reasonable time to collect, so the risk moves to the buyer at that point. Beulah was a consumer in both sales, and that fact decided nothing. A student who asks first whether the buyer was a merchant has read the rule as though it were phrased differently.
The phrasing of the rule determines whose status counts, and a provision that applies only in a transaction between merchants asks a different question. Such a rule is available only if both parties are chargeable with a merchant's knowledge or skill.22 Beulah is not a merchant in either deal, so a rule keyed to that phrase would be unavailable in both, even against BBS, which is a merchant by any measure.