Concept
Disclaimers and Remedy Limits
Exclusion or modification of warranties
Disclaimers and Remedy Limits
Subsection (4) of §2-316 sends the reader out of the section. It says that remedies for breach of warranty can be limited in accordance with the Article’s provisions on liquidation or limitation of damages and on contractual modification of remedy, which are §§2-718 and 2-719.1 Everything earlier in this chapter, from the construction rule of subsection (1) through the formal and general routes of subsections (2) and (3), asked whether a warranty comes into being at all. Subsection (4) recognizes a second tool that a seller uses after a warranty exists and has been breached, and it assigns that tool to the remedies provisions, which apply tests of their own.
Both tools serve the seller’s ultimate objective of avoiding responsibility for product defects and false representations, yet they operate independently. An effective disclaimer under §2-316 prevents a warranty from ever arising, so the seller has nothing to breach. Sections 2-718 and 2-719 assume that a valid warranty exists and was breached, and they speak only to the nature and extent of the remedy. A damages clause under §2-718 “liquidates” the buyer’s damages at a predetermined amount. A clause under §2-719 typically limits the buyer to repair or replacement of the product and allows no incidental or consequential damages, a category that includes damages for personal injuries.2
The two tools reach the courtroom as different defenses. A seller who pleads a disclaimer denies that the buyer has any cause of action, while a seller who pleads an exclusionary clause denies only that the buyer is entitled to the remedy demanded, consequential damages for example.3 A limitation of remedy can be viewed as a seller’s back-door method of avoiding substantial warranty responsibility for product accidents: it leaves the warranty standing and shrinks what the warranty is worth.4
Because each tool endangers the buyer in a different way, the Code tests each differently. A disclaimer endangers a buyer who never learns that a promise the law ordinarily supplies is missing, so §2-316 denies effect to disclaimer language that is inconsistent with an express warranty and permits the exclusion of implied warranties only by conspicuous language or by other circumstances that protect the buyer from surprise.5 A remedy limitation endangers a buyer who knows the warranty exists but may be unable to collect on it. The parties may limit remedies and may exclude consequential damages unless the exclusion is unconscionable, but an exclusive or limited remedy that fails of its essential purpose is not enforceable.6 More generally, an apparently fair clause that fails in its purpose or deprives either party of the substantial value of the bargain gives way to the general remedy provisions of Article 2.7 Those remedy-side tests belong to §2-719, and this chapter points toward them without developing them.
Two sets of facts show how differently the tools work. Bette Buyer buys a dehumidifier from No Sweat Company under a contract that gives a limited ninety-day express warranty and conspicuously disclaims the implied warranty of merchantability in language that mentions merchantability. Six months later the machine, which was defective when sold, overheats, catches fire, and ruins the flooring around it. Bette cannot sue on the express warranty, which has expired, and she cannot sue on the implied warranty, which was disclaimed. With no warranty there is no breach, and with no breach there is nothing to which damages of any kind can attach, so the cost of the floor, a consequential damage, is not recoverable in warranty.8 Without the disclaimer, the Code would have supplied that recovery, because §2-715(2)(b) defines consequential damages to include injury to person or property proximately resulting from any breach of warranty.9 The disclaimer removed the breach on which that rule depends.
Moulton shows the same structure on graver facts. A steering defect in the plaintiff’s fourteen-month-old car sent it off a bridge and severely injured him. His 12-month, 12,000-mile express warranty had expired, and the sales contract disclaimed the implied warranty of merchantability in accordance with §2-316(2). A one-year statute of limitations barred his tort claims, and the properly drawn disclaimer barred his warranty claim, so the law gave a gravely injured consumer no redress.10
A car bought for personal use marks the opposite pole. Its steering mechanism breaks during the warranty period, the car hits a wall, and the driver is injured. The warranty clause limits the buyer to repair or replacement of the steering mechanism and excludes consequential damages. The warranty remains in force and has been breached, so the only dispute concerns the remedy clause. Section 2-719(3) treats a limit on consequential damages for personal injury in the case of consumer goods as prima facie unconscionable, so the driver in all likelihood recovers consequential damages, including damages for injury to the person.11 The kind of loss, property for Bette and bodily injury for the driver, matters to that presumption, but only once a warranty stands. What separates the two outcomes is whether the contract leaves a warranty standing. Bette’s contract removed the warranty before the failure, so no remedy question ever arose. The driver’s contract kept the warranty and then tried to cap it, which brought the clause under §2-719(3).
Courts look at what a clause does and not at what it is called. A number of cases have held that “disclaimers” that were really remedy limitations, and so subject to §2-719(3) rather than §2-316, were unconscionable.12 Sellers also commonly use both tools in one contract, giving a limited express warranty, disclaiming the implied warranties, and restricting the remedies for the express warranty that survives. The Code anticipates the pairing: it treats the two provisions as separate and independent, yet §2-316(4) cross-references the remedy provisions, and the two work in tandem.13 A disclaimer eliminates the warranty altogether, so a buyer who has lost on the disclaimer may look for a way to attack it from the remedy side. Whether a disclaimer that satisfies every requirement of §2-316 can still be struck as unconscionable, directly or through §2-719(3), is the subject of the section on outside limits later in this chapter.