Concept
When Subsection (3) Controls
Exclusion or modification of warranties
When Subsection (3) Controls
Section 2-316(2) begins “Subject to subsection (3),” and subsection (3) begins “Notwithstanding subsection (2).”1 Those two openers make the formal route optional. A seller who follows subsection (2) gets a predictable result. A seller who misses it can still exclude implied warranties by one of three general methods, and a disclaimer that qualifies under subsection (3) need not mention merchantability at all. The methods are “as is” or similar language, the buyer’s examination of the goods or refusal to examine them, and course of dealing, course of performance, or usage of trade.2 Later sections take each method in turn. This section explains how subsection (3) fits with the formal rule already covered.
The second route exists because of what the formalities protect. Comment 1 says the section shields a buyer from “unexpected and unbargained language of disclaimer” by “permitting the exclusion of implied warranties only by conspicuous language or other circumstances which protect the buyer from surprise.”3 The required word and the conspicuous presentation are one way to prevent surprise, and the circumstances in subsection (3) are the other. Comment 6, as a South Carolina court quotes it, describes the three methods as situations in which “the circumstances surrounding the transaction are in themselves sufficient to call the buyer’s attention to the fact that no implied warranties are made or that a certain implied warranty is excluded.”4 A buyer told that the goods are sold “as is,” a buyer who has looked them over as fully as desired, and a buyer who has bought from this seller on the same terms for years already know what the formalities were meant to tell them. The merchantability warranty also rests on a merchant’s usual superior information about goods of its kind, and an examining or repeat buyer has narrowed that gap, which is one way to see why the Code lets these circumstances do the work.5
A failed formal disclaimer has therefore not necessarily failed. When a clause falls short of subsection (2), the next question is whether the facts fit subsection (3). The South Carolina court framed the inquiry in just that way. It asked whether a genuine issue of material fact existed on whether the disclaimer “falls within the exception prescribed by Subsection (3)(a),” a question that looks to whether the circumstances surrounding the transaction themselves called the buyer’s attention to the exclusion.6
Subsection (3) must still be read with the buyer’s position in mind. Consumers of new products typically know little about a product’s dangers, have minimal power to bargain for more safety, and have few skills for valuing warranties or their exclusion, and sellers benefit most from disclaimers that buyers do not see or understand.7 Suppose any loosely worded circumstance could replace the required word and the conspicuous presentation. A seller could then tuck a bare “no warranties” sentence into a form, point afterward to some background fact, and claim the exclusion, which is exactly the surprise Comment 1 targets. The sound reading confines subsection (3) to what its text describes: circumstances that by themselves tell the buyer no implied warranty is being made.
Change the invoice to say the tractor is sold “as is,” and the result changes. That expression itself calls the buyer’s attention to the exclusion, so it can work under subsection (3)(a) without ever mentioning merchantability, unless the circumstances indicate otherwise.8 How conspicuous such a term must be is a separate question, taken up below.
Each method also carries a limit in its own text. The “as is” route works “unless the circumstances indicate otherwise,” and the language must, in common understanding, call the buyer’s attention to the exclusion and make plain that there is no implied warranty.9 The examination route reaches only “defects which an examination ought in the circumstances to have revealed,” so a buyer who looked as fully as desired, or who refused to look, loses the warranty only as to those defects.10 The dealing route rests on a shared understanding drawn from the parties’ past. If seller and buyer have made several contracts over the years with the understanding that the seller was selling “as is,” their next deal will be “as is” too unless they expressly negate that course of dealing.11 The Code adds that course of performance and usage of trade can also exclude or modify an implied warranty.12 These limits keep subsection (3) a set of narrow alternatives instead of a general escape from subsection (2).
Subsection (3) speaks only of implied warranties. Express warranties follow different rules, and the analysis there starts by sorting out which of two scenarios the facts present. In one, the parties sign a contract that contains both an express warranty and a disclaimer of all express warranties. In the other, the seller makes an express warranty and the parties afterward sign a contract containing the disclaimer.13