Concept
Source and Scope of the Warranty
Implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose
Fitness for a Particular Purpose
Source and Scope of the Warranty
UCC § 2-315 implies a warranty that goods will be fit for the buyer’s particular purpose whenever two facts exist at the time of contracting: the seller has reason to know the particular purpose for which the goods are required, and has reason to know that the buyer is relying on the seller’s skill or judgment to select or furnish suitable goods. The warranty then attaches unless it is excluded or modified under the next section.1 Each clause does its own work. “At the time of contracting” fixes the moment at which the seller’s knowledge is measured, so a purpose the seller learns of only after the bargain is struck cannot create the warranty. “Reason to know” lets the buyer prove the seller’s awareness from the circumstances of the dealing, without any admission by the seller. “Select or furnish” reaches the seller who picks an item off the shelf and the seller who supplies goods to meet a described job. And “unless excluded or modified” makes the warranty a default term, one the seller can contract out of by following the rules taken up at the end of this chapter.
The warranty arises from circumstances, not from anything the seller says. Once a seller has held itself out as able to recommend goods that will satisfy the buyer, and has made a recommendation, the buyer is unlikely to investigate further.3 The law holds the seller to the assurance that conduct implies. It also pushes sellers who know they are being relied on to recommend only within their area of expertise, so that they do not falsely lull buyers into a sense of security.4 The fitness warranty is thus a species of implied warranty in general: an obligation the law imposes, because of the circumstances of a sale, without any representation or promise from the seller.5
An express warranty, by contrast, comes from the seller’s overt words or actions: an affirmation of fact or promise relating to the goods, a description of the goods, or a sample or model that becomes part of the basis of the bargain.6 An express warranty rests on what the seller said; the fitness warranty rests on what the seller knew and what the buyer trusted. One sale can produce both. Suppose a buyer asks a hardware salesman for a chain saw to cut stumps out below ground level, where the chain will meet dirt and rocks, and leaves the choice to him. The salesman picks one from several in stock and rings it up without a word. He has promised nothing, yet the implied fitness warranty has likely arisen. Had he added that this saw would work just fine, he would also have made an express warranty, and the buyer could claim under both.
Fitness has five elements, and the first three decide whether the warranty arose at all: the particularity of the buyer’s purpose for the product; the buyer’s reliance on the seller’s skill or judgment to select an appropriate product for that purpose; and the seller’s reason to know both the purpose and the reliance. Those three often predominate in importance.7 The chain-saw buyer satisfies all three: she stated a special purpose, trusted the salesman’s choice, and the salesman could see both.
Because the warranty rests on the reliance built into a particular sale, the seller’s occupation drops out of the analysis. Section 2-315 speaks only of “the seller” and sets no merchant requirement.8 The warranty of merchantability, in contrast, is implied in any sale of goods by a merchant seller that sells goods of that kind,9 and a merchant for this purpose is one who regularly sells goods of a particular kind.10 Two sales by nonmerchants show where the line falls.
Both sellers are nonmerchants. What changed the result was the disclosed racing purpose, together with the novice’s reliance on the hobbyist’s selection.
The same two conditions govern commercial dealings. In Kokomo Opalescent Glass Co. v. Arthur W. Schmid International, Inc., the buyer offered to buy a new glass-rolling machine if the seller thought it could be used in the buyer’s operation. The seller visited the plant and advised on the kind of machine to use. The machine could not roll the kind of glass the buyer wanted to roll, and the court found the warranty breached.11 The purpose reached the seller through the negotiations, and the buyer’s request for help disclosed its reliance. A buyer who never mentions the purpose that later matters fares differently. One buyer purchased expansion joints to absorb contraction and expansion in steam pipes. The buyer never told the seller that strong resistance to corrosion was a particular purpose for which the joints were required, and the seller could not be expected to infer from the circumstances that the buyer was relying on the seller to select such joints. The court held that the joints were not sold with an implied warranty of fitness for that purpose.12
Fitness and merchantability answer different questions. Merchantability requires that goods be at least fit for the ordinary purposes for which goods of that description are used.13 A particular purpose differs from an ordinary one because it envisages a specific use by the buyer that is peculiar to the nature of his business, whereas ordinary purposes are the uses customarily made of the goods in question.14 Shoes are generally used for walking on ordinary ground, but a seller may know that a particular pair was selected for climbing mountains.15 Goods can therefore suit every ordinary use and still fail the buyer’s special one, and that gap is the space the fitness warranty occupies. Reliance marks a second difference. It is one of the three elements that decide whether the fitness warranty arose,16 while merchantability attaches to a merchant’s sale of goods of that kind with no comparable element.17
Fitness thus occupies a middle position. Like an express warranty, it turns on what passed between these two parties, though here on the seller’s knowledge rather than the seller’s statement. Like merchantability, it is implied. But it is no general guarantee of quality: without a particular purpose, the seller’s reason to know it, and the buyer’s reliance, it does not arise.
A sale of goods can carry several distinct warranties at once, among them the warranty of title under § 2-312(1),18 so a claim is best sorted by asking what the seller said, how the goods failed, and what the seller knew. A leaky bucket needs no fitness theory. A merchant who sells one has breached the warranty of merchantability, which requires goods to be at least fit for ordinary purposes,19 so proof that the buyer meant to haul water and relied on the seller’s selection would be wasted effort. A buyer who tells a seller she is going camping in cold country and is told that a sleeping bag is good down to forty below holds an express warranty, because that affirmation became part of the basis of the bargain. Fitness is the right claim when the buyer’s purpose was not the ordinary one and the goods as delivered do not suit it.
Even after the warranty arises, the buyer must prove unfitness, which is the central issue of breach and is often uncontroverted in cases of substantial personal injury, and must prove causation and harm, which are embedded in breach and considered later.20 The sections below take the warranty apart in the order a dispute usually unfolds. They begin with the conditions that must exist before it arises, then turn to the recurring situations in which the buyer’s reliance fails even though the seller knew the purpose. After that come the limits on suing a remote manufacturer, the proof of breach and damages, and finally the ways the warranty coexists with other warranties or is excluded.