Concept
Acceptance and Its Effects
UCC sale of goods: perfect tender and revocation of acceptance
Acceptance and Its Effects
Acceptance is the hinge of the buyer's position. Until the buyer accepts, a tender that fails in any respect to conform to the contract lets it reject.1 Once the buyer accepts, § 2-607(2) takes rejection away. Acceptance precludes rejection of the goods accepted; an acceptance made with knowledge of a nonconformity cannot be revoked because of it unless the buyer accepted on the reasonable assumption that the nonconformity would be seasonably cured; and acceptance does not of itself impair any other remedy the Article provides for the nonconformity.2 The buyer is left with a claim for damages and, on stricter conditions, a right to revoke.
The line falls at acceptance because the two choices burden the seller differently. A prompt rejection returns the goods in the condition delivered, so the seller can make them conforming and tender them again or sell them to someone else, and its loss stays small.3 A buyer that accepts takes the goods as its own.4 By then it has held the goods, often used them, and made them harder for the seller to cure or resell.5 The Code therefore asks more of a buyer who wants to undo an acceptance than of one who refuses a tender, as the later sections on revocation show.
On any buyer-side problem, ask first whether the buyer has accepted. If not, the any-respect standard of § 2-601 governs. If so, the buyer is limited to damages and, when its conditions are met, revocation. The subsections below cover acceptance by the buyer's words or acts, acceptance by its failure to reject effectively, and the consequences of either.
Acceptance by Words or Conduct
Section 2-606(1) names three ways to accept goods. The buyer may signify to the seller, after a reasonable opportunity to inspect, that the goods are conforming or that it will take or retain them in spite of their nonconformity. It may fail to make an effective rejection. Or it may do any act inconsistent with the seller's ownership.6 In each case the buyer takes particular goods as its own, by words, by action, or by silence when it should have spoken.7 This subsection covers the two affirmative routes. Silence follows in the next.
The first affirmative route is the buyer's own statement. A buyer that tells the seller, after a reasonable chance to inspect, that the goods conform has accepted them. So has a buyer that tells the seller the goods are defective but says it will keep the shipment anyway.8 Acceptance rests on the buyer's decision to keep the goods and does not wait on any belief that they are perfect. The decision carries the consequences of § 2-607(2): the buyer can no longer reject, its other remedies for the nonconformity survive, and it cannot later revoke on account of a defect it knew about unless it accepted on the reasonable assumption that the seller would cure.9 The reasonable-opportunity phrase has a matching purpose. Words spoken before the buyer has looked at the goods are not an informed choice, and the Code does not hold the buyer to them.
The second route needs no words. A buyer accepts by any act inconsistent with the seller's ownership, because a buyer that treats goods as its own cannot also maintain that they still belong to the seller, and a seller who watches the buyer behave as an owner may conclude the goods are staying. Rejection also loses its practical purpose once the buyer has acted on the goods. Its function is to return them as delivered so that the seller can cure or resell, and rejection is generally ineffective after the goods have been manufactured into parts.10
Atlan Indus., Inc. v. O.E.M., Inc. shows processing and resale at work. The buyer molded shipments of a plastic material into computer parts and sent them to its customer, who painted the parts and baked them in infrared ovens, where they warped.11 The material was nonconforming, because it would not tolerate the heat that the specified grade is meant to withstand, yet the court held that the molder had accepted it. A buyer that receives goods, processes them, and sells the finished product to a third person without any effort to reject has acted inconsistently with the seller's ownership.12 The nonconformity therefore did not answer the acceptance, and the court went on to ask whether the acceptance could be revoked because the defect was hard to discover, a question for later sections.
The act need not transform the goods. The buyer in Audio Visual Artistry v. Tanzer kept the audio-visual equipment in his home and hired another company to maintain it, which the court called an act inconsistent with the seller's ownership.13 In Lynx, Inc. v. Ordnance Products, Inc., the Maryland court recalled its holding in Fred J. Miller, Inc. v. Raymond Metal Products Co. that a buyer's continued use of 83 lengths of dredging pipe after the defect became apparent was plainly an acceptance. That holding made it unnecessary to decide whether the buyer's letter to the seller was an acceptance or a rejection.14 A buyer that writes that the pipe is defective while it keeps putting the pipe to work is treating the pipe as its own. The conduct carries the legal weight, and a seller who sees the use has no reason to expect the pipe back.
Section 2-606(1)(c) carries a proviso: if the act is wrongful as against the seller, it is an acceptance only if the seller ratifies it. The proviso governs use after an effective rejection. A buyer that rejects a machine and then keeps running it has exercised ownership wrongfully against the seller. The seller may treat that use as an acceptance, but the choice is the seller's, and the buyer cannot force it.15 Letting the buyer's own wrongful act settle the matter would hand the buyer the power to choose which claim it faces.
Read literally, subsection (c) threatens the inspection rules. All use of goods is in some sense inconsistent with the seller's ownership, so if any use counted, acceptance would occur at the buyer's first use, before it had a reasonable opportunity to inspect and while it still had a reasonable time to reject.16 Intervale Steel Corp. v. Borg & Beck Div., Borg-Warner Corp. resolved the tension by reading subsection (c) to reach only acts done with knowledge of the defect: once the buyer discovers the defect and acts inconsistently with the seller's rights, it has accepted.17 The Intervale buyer stamped all of its steel into parts and waited three months before rejecting, and the court held the rejection untimely and ineffective. It added that a latent defect found only after processing does not let a buyer reject goods it has drastically changed and used, although the buyer keeps its damages remedy for the seller's breach of warranty.18 Atlan reached acceptance through subsection (c) for a buyer that processed the goods before any problem surfaced. The two courts took different routes to the same place: goods that a buyer has transformed and passed along can no longer be rejected.19
Does a buyer who tries goods to learn whether they work act as their owner? Zabriskie Chevrolet, Inc. v. Smith says no. A new-car buyer found a serious defect within seven-tenths of a mile and a few minutes after leaving the showroom, and the court held that he never accepted the car, because a buyer does not accept goods until he has had a reasonable opportunity to inspect them.20 The dealer argued that a spin around the block before signing was that opportunity. The court called the argument unrealistic: a layperson cannot take apart a modern car to look for latent defects, so the first miles of driving are the buyer's first real chance to see whether the car is what he bargained for.21 The court left open how long a buyer may drive in the name of inspection, but it set out an earlier New Jersey decision holding that buyers of machines who found them defective and kept using them, not for further tests but for their own convenience or profit, had accepted.22
Set beside the Maryland pipe buyer, the car buyer shows where the line falls. Both used the goods, but the car buyer used them to find out whether they conformed, and the pipe buyer kept using them after the defect was known. Use that serves inspection stays on the buyer's side of the line. Use after the evaluation is over is the conduct the Code treats as ownership.
The same reasoning covers goods that cannot be evaluated without being put to work. Stratton Industries, Inc. v. Northwest Georgia Bank involved a novel carpet-dyeing system that failed to function. The buyer dismantled and modified it and ran it with another maker's products, and the court held those efforts justified, not an acceptance, given the equipment's novelty, its failure to work, and the seller's failure to respond to the buyer's first rejection.23 Limited use after a rejection that holds down the seller's loss may be treated the same way. In each situation the question is whether the use evaluates the goods or reduces the seller's loss, or whether it simply enjoys the goods as an owner would.
The third step does the most work on exam facts, because the same activity, whether driving, running, or installing, falls on either side of the line depending on when it happens relative to the discovery of the defect. A letter of complaint does not cancel continued use, since the use is the act the Code reads as ownership.
Acceptance by Failing to Reject
Rejection is an act, and the buyer must perform it on time. Section 2-602(1) requires rejection within a reasonable time after delivery or tender and makes it ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller.25 A buyer that misses either requirement has made no effective rejection, and § 2-606(1)(b) treats the failure as acceptance once the buyer has had a reasonable opportunity to inspect, even when the goods are wholly nonconforming.26 Acceptance then bars rejection under § 2-607(2).27 The previous subsection covered the buyer who accepts by what it says or does. This one covers the buyer who accepts by saying nothing when the Code expects it to speak, and the result is the same: a buyer holding wholly defective goods can lose the right to reject without ever having approved them.
The deadline settles a conflict between two kinds of regret. A buyer may regret the deal because the market price has fallen, and the rule for rejection favors one side's regret over the other's. The harder it is to reject, the easier it is for the seller to chisel by delivering goods that are just a bit nonconforming. The easier it is to reject, the easier it is for a buyer to escape a transaction because it is dissatisfied with the deal rather than with the goods.28 A prompt-notice requirement keeps the buyer from holding the option open while the market moves.
Timely notice also does practical work for the seller. A seller told promptly can cure, replace defective units, or resell the shipment while the goods retain their value. It can keep the goods as evidence for a claim against a carrier or subcontractor, and it can collect goods that might otherwise perish or decline in value.29 Prompt notice thereby mitigates damages and curtails commercial loss.30 A seller told after months faces goods that have been used, aged, or reshaped, which is why the Code reads a buyer's silence as a choice to keep them.
Connecticut Investment Casting Corp. v. Made-Rite Tool Co. applies the rule to a buyer that complained a great deal. The buyer had a reasonable opportunity to inspect the barrel latches and did inspect them in early April. It returned only the nonconforming latches for rework, later decided to rework other latches itself, and in numerous conversations pressed the seller to deliver while the seller answered that it faced unanticipated difficulties.31 The Massachusetts court held that none of this was a rejection, because a buyer does not reject goods by pressuring a seller to deliver, and that the failure to give timely notice of rejection made the buyer an accepting buyer.32 The buyer had told the seller of two breaches, the late delivery and 179 nonconforming latches, but notice of some breach can preserve a damages claim without telling the seller that the buyer refuses the goods, and both rejection and revocation require that message.33 The buyer therefore owed the contract rate for the latches.
The buyer in ARB (American Research Bureau), Inc. v. E-Systems, Inc. also kept dealing with the seller after trouble appeared, and it came out the other way. It found the pre-production models of electronic metering equipment inadequate, yet let production go forward on the seller's assurances that the problems could be corrected.34 The D.C. Circuit held that the buyer's communications to the seller, beginning in January 1974, satisfied § 2-602, because notification means taking such steps as may reasonably be required to inform the other party in the ordinary course. The buyer had authorized production only on the strength of the seller's assurances, had never accepted the equipment as delivered, and was not waiving its right to conforming goods.35 What separated the two buyers was the content of what each said. The Made-Rite buyer pressed for delivery and never told the seller it refused the latches. The ARB buyer told the seller that the equipment as delivered was unacceptable. A request for repairs resembles the first message, as the Tennessee court said of the punch lists in Audio Visual Artistry v. Tanzer: asking for work on an item strongly indicates that the buyer means to keep it.36
A buyer that gives timely notice must still say enough, though the Code does not demand a detailed brief. It lets the buyer give quick, informal notice of defects, because quick notice lets the seller cure and keeps the deal alive.37 The limit is § 2-605(1)(a): a buyer that fails to state a particular defect that was ascertainable by reasonable inspection cannot rely on the unstated defect to justify rejection if the seller could have cured it had the buyer stated it in time.38 A sound notice therefore names the curable defects a reasonable inspection would reveal, and it says what the conversations in Made-Rite never said: the buyer will not keep the goods. A bare rejection that names no objection invites the suspicion that the buyer is escaping a deal gone sour, the pretext problem discussed under good faith above.
Courts ask whether notice of rejection came within a reasonable time, a period that leaves room for inspection. Four circumstances recur when they apply the standard.39
- The difficulty of discovering the defect, which turns on the nature of the defect, the complexity of the goods, and the sophistication of the buyer.
- The terms of the contract, including any clause that fixes a period for inspection or notice.
- The relative perishability of the goods.
- The parties' course of performance between delivery and the attempted rejection.
Each circumstance measures either what the seller loses from delay or how fairly the buyer can be charged with it. A defect that is hard to find excuses a longer wait, since the buyer could not have known sooner, though a sophisticated merchant buying simple goods earns little credit on this ground.40 A contract term fixing a period for inspection or notice records what the parties themselves expected. Perishable goods call for a short period, because every day of delay costs the seller part of the value it would recover on resale. Course of performance matters because a buyer that stays in contact after delivery gives the seller the information the deadline exists to secure.
In EPN-Delaval, S.A. v. Inter-Equip, Inc. the buyer ordered hemispherical steel heads and received elliptical ones, and it gave no notice of nonconformity until months after the heads reached its plant in Mexico. The durability of the heads and the absence of a contract clause requiring inspection within a fixed time favored the buyer. Against that, the defect was total and blatant, the goods were simple, and the buyer was a merchant whose quality-control staff worked twenty miles from the plant and would have found the problem without difficulty had they inspected.41 The court held the notice untimely and the heads accepted.
The clock starts at delivery, and a buyer is charged with what the shipping papers show. In Van Dorn Co. v. Future Chemical and Oil Corp. the seller shipped more than 29,000 cans of each of two kinds where 20,000 of each had been ordered, and an invoice, a receiving record, and a packing list stating the quantities all reached the buyer.42 The Seventh Circuit treated the excess as a nonconformity and held that the buyer's failure to reject in time operated as acceptance of the excess cans, so the buyer owed the contract rate for them. The trial court had limited recovery to the cans ordered, reasoning that a seller cannot overship for its own convenience and then put the burden on the customer to object, and the appellate court reversed.43
Other delays produce the same result. In Intervale the buyer held the steel for three months and stamped all of it into parts, which made its rejection untimely and ineffective. Timely rejection lets the seller recover goods in a condition to cure or resell, and rejection is generally ineffective once goods have been manufactured into parts.44 In Euroworld, Inc. v. Blakey the party that received the engines did not inspect them for four months and reported problems only in the summer of 1980, nine months after the written agreement. The court read both delays, together with the party's delivery of two engines, as signifying acceptance.45
Missing the rejection window does not end the buyer's position altogether. Notice of rejection must come within a reasonable time after delivery or tender. The separate notice of breach that preserves any remedy under § 2-607(3)(a) runs from when the buyer discovers or should have discovered the breach, so the rejection deadline usually arrives first.46 A buyer too late to reject may therefore still preserve a damages claim and, in some cases, a right to revoke. The EPN-Delaval buyer tried the revocation fallback and failed, because the court found it should have revoked within weeks, not months, of the heads' arrival.47
Two separate questions govern every rejection. The first is whether it is effective, which turns on procedure, meaning timely notice. The second is whether it is rightful, which turns on substance, meaning whether the goods or tender failed to conform and whether the seller has no cure right still open.48 Effectiveness is defined by the procedure of notice without regard to the basis for rejection, so a wrongful rejection operates as fully as a rightful one, and the buyer that rejects wrongfully breaches even though the rejection takes effect.49 The two questions combine four ways:
- A rejection that is rightful and effective works. The goods fail to conform and notice was timely, so the goods go back to the seller and the buyer owes no price.
- A rejection that is rightful but ineffective is no rejection at all. The goods fail to conform, but notice was late or never given, so the buyer is deemed to have accepted, owes the price, and is left with damages and the narrower option of revocation.
- A rejection that is wrongful but effective is a real rejection. The goods conform but notice was timely, so the duty to pay ends, yet the buyer is in breach and owes the seller damages.
- A rejection that is wrongful and ineffective leaves the buyer holding conforming goods it has accepted, so it owes the price and has nothing to claim in return.
The middle two cells look backwards at first, because the buyer with the genuine complaint ends up holding the goods while the buyer in the wrong gets rid of them. The explanation lies in what the seller needs. A seller that receives no notice cannot cure, resell, or preserve evidence, so a buyer that lingers is deemed to have accepted, though it keeps an action for damages if the seller breached. A seller that receives timely notice can take the goods back and preserve their value. If the buyer was mistaken, the seller sues for damages under § 2-706 or § 2-708, not for the price, because it has the goods again.50
The order matters because a buyer with a flawless complaint about the goods can still lose the right to reject, and a buyer with no complaint at all can still reject effectively. Checking nonconformity first answers only the second question and leaves unexamined the first, which decides whether the goods are still the seller's.
Effects of Acceptance
Section 2-607(2) compresses the consequences of acceptance into one sentence that closes one door, narrows a second, and leaves a third open. Rejection is gone. Revocation survives only on the stricter terms taken up later in this chapter. The buyer's ordinary remedies for the breach remain.52 The rest of § 2-607 adds three duties that attach to an accepting buyer: it must pay for what it kept, tell the seller about the breach, and prove the breach. Acceptance thus leaves the buyer with real claims, and it changes what the buyer must pay, say, and establish to press them.
The bar on rejection follows from what acceptance does to the seller's position. In Intervale the buyer stamped all of its steel into parts before objecting, and the court held its attempted rejection ineffective and the steel accepted.53 A buyer may reject for relatively minor defects but may revoke only when the nonconformity substantially impairs the goods' value, the court explained, and the gap between the standards reflects the prejudice to the seller, since acceptance will most likely make it much harder for the seller to cure or resell.54 A buyer that has accepted cannot return to the any-respect standard of § 2-601 by relabeling its complaint. Revocation, the route that remains, asks for more.
The first duty is to pay. Section 2-607(1) provides that the buyer must pay at the contract rate for any goods accepted.55 A buyer that keeps goods has received the seller's performance, and a rule that let it keep them while withholding the price would turn every quality complaint into a discount the contract never granted. The duty reaches everything accepted, including excess. In Van Dorn the buyer ordered 20,000 cans of each of two kinds, received more than 29,000 of each, failed to reject the excess in time, and had also agreed to pay for the cans, so it owed the contract rate for all of them.56
The contract rate is only the starting figure. The buyer then asks to be credited for what the nonconformity cost it. A buyer that accepts a new car with the wrong sound system, for example, owes the full contract price minus whatever it can prove in damages for the missing equipment.57 A buyer that does not pay can be sued for the price, because acceptance supports a price action under § 2-709(1)(a), and an attempted rejection or revocation that proves ineffective leaves the acceptance in place.58
How much the accepting buyer finally pays depends on what it can show. The latch buyer in Made-Rite accepted goods that were late and partly out of specification, and the court held that the seller could recover the full contract price, because once goods are accepted the buyer's recourse is a suit for damages and the trial judge had found that the buyer suffered none.59 That buyer had told the seller about the breaches, so its claim was preserved, but no proven loss stood behind the claim to set against the price. The steel buyer in Intervale owed the price less the scrap value of steel already turned over, yet it did not owe the full amount, because it had notified the seller of the breach within a reasonable time and could withhold payment to the extent of the damages the seller's breach caused it.60 Each was an accepting buyer with a damages claim, and the outcomes differ because a damages claim reduces what the buyer owes only by the loss the buyer establishes.
The Intervale buyer's right to withhold depended on a step the Code makes a condition of every remedy for accepted goods. Section 2-607(3)(a) requires the buyer, within a reasonable time after it discovers or should have discovered any breach, to notify the seller of the breach or be barred from any remedy.61 The bar is severe, and its reasons are practical. Notice opens the way to settlement through negotiation, and it lets the seller inspect the goods and investigate the complaint while the facts are fresh, so that the seller can limit its own loss and defend itself if the dispute is litigated.62 A buyer that has kept goods for some time could otherwise present a claim after the evidence has gone stale. That is why the clock runs from when the buyer discovers or should have discovered the breach, a moment that can fall well after delivery.
The notice itself can be informal. The Code prescribes no form or content. The notice need only tell the seller that the transaction is still troublesome and must be watched, and where the parties have dealt more than once it should identify the particular transaction.63 Lynx applied those limits against a buyer that had accepted fuzes and then asserted a breach for the first time in defending the sellers' suit for the balance due. A letter blaming a cash-flow problem partly on a quality problem at the sellers was equivocal and did not identify the contracts in dispute, and the filing of a defense cannot itself serve as notice, so the buyer's defense failed for want of the notice that is a condition precedent to any remedy.64 Notice of breach also asks less of the buyer than notice of rejection or revocation does. The Made-Rite buyer had told the seller of two breaches, and the court still held that notice of some breach may preserve a damages claim without sufficing for rejection or revocation, since both require that the seller be told the buyer does not wish to keep the goods.65 A notice of breach tells the seller that something is wrong and a claim may follow. What a notice of revocation must say, and by when, belongs to the revocation sections below.
The neighboring shop stands where the Lynx buyer stood, holding a defect it could prove and no remedy it could invoke. Proof is the third consequence of acceptance. Section 2-607(4) places on the buyer the burden of establishing any breach with respect to the goods accepted.66 In Sessa v. Riegle the buyer of a $25,000 horse had accepted it through an agent who examined the animal and indicated that the buyer would take it, so later telephone calls could not amount to an effective rejection. The court put on the buyer the burden of proving breach of warranty and noted that the seller would have borne the burden of showing conformity had the horse not been accepted.67 The same burden follows the buyer into any later attempt at revocation, where it must prove each requirement.68
The last clause of § 2-607(2) leaves the buyer's other remedies intact. Keeping nonconforming goods does not cost the buyer its claim for damages,69 and the Code supplies the main one in § 2-714: a buyer that has accepted goods and given notice may recover damages for any nonconformity of tender.70 The contract's terms on quantity, quality, and function operate as an express warranty that the goods will conform, so keeping nonconforming goods leaves the seller's breach actionable even though rejection is gone.71 The measure of those damages belongs to the study of remedies. What matters here is which path the buyer is on. In Audio Visual Artistry v. Tanzer the Tennessee Court of Appeals held that a buyer who kept most of the equipment in his home had to pay the contract price for it, and that his remedies for that equipment were limited to damages for breach of warranty, because recovery of the purchase price is available only on rejection or revocation. The court also noted authority treating warranty damages and the remedies for rejection or revocation as mutually exclusive.72 The Texas court in Selectouch Corp. v. Perfect Starch, Inc. drew the dividing line at final acceptance. Only a buyer that has finally accepted and can no longer revoke is limited to § 2-714, while a buyer that rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes may recover under § 2-711, including so much of the price as has been paid.73