Concept
The Buyer's Three Options
UCC sale of goods: perfect tender and revocation of acceptance
The Buyer's Three Options
Section 2-601 gives a buyer who receives a nonconforming tender a choice. If the goods or the tender of delivery fail in any respect to conform to the contract, the buyer may reject the whole, accept the whole, or accept any commercial unit or units and reject the rest.1 The Tennessee court in Audio Visual Artistry v. Tanzer called these the three options the UCC provides and treated the point as well settled.2 The choice is a default rather than a command. Section 2-601 makes it subject to the Article’s rules on breach in installment contracts, and it operates unless the parties have otherwise agreed under the sections on contractual limitation of remedy.3
The options differ in what they do to the goods. Rejection sends the goods back, so the seller must take them; acceptance keeps them, so the buyer takes them as its own.4 Acceptance also forecloses rejection of what was accepted, but it leaves the buyer’s other remedies for the nonconformity intact.5 The third option gives the first result to some units of a delivery and the second to the rest.
One delivery illustrates all three. A buyer contracts for 500 blue widgets in ten boxes of fifty, and two of the ten boxes arrive holding green widgets. The buyer may reject all ten boxes. It may accept the eight blue boxes and reject the two green ones. Or it may accept all ten and still sue the seller for the nonconforming delivery.6 This delivery runs through the three sections that follow.
The buyer chooses by conduct as much as by words, and a buyer that does nothing may find that it has chosen anyway, because buyers frequently accept by failing to reject in time.7 Each option carries a price, and the sections below name it, beginning with the broadest option, rejection of the whole.
Reject the Whole
The first option is the broadest. The buyer may “reject the whole,” and the whole means the entire tender, so a buyer facing a partly defective delivery need not sort the good units from the bad.8 In the widget delivery, the buyer may send back all ten boxes, including the eight that match the contract.9
Rejection requires a nonconformity, but not a serious one. The Code gives the buyer a right of rejection whenever the tender of delivery or the goods delivered are not perfectly in conformity with the contract, though it limits the exercise of that right to a reasonable time after delivery or tender.10 That standard is easier to meet than the one for revoking an acceptance. A buyer may reject if the tender fails “in any respect to conform to the contract,” but to revoke it must show, among other things, that the nonconformity substantially impairs the goods’ value to it. The rationale is that it makes good sense to require more from a buyer who has accepted the goods than from one who has rejected them.11
Rejection returns the goods to the seller and frees the buyer of the price. The seller must take the goods back,12 and a procedurally effective rejection or revocation allows the buyer to avoid the obligation to pay the price.13 The remedy works best when it comes quickly. Timely rejection lets the seller recover goods that can still be made conforming and tendered again, or simply sold to another buyer, which mitigates damages and curtails commercial loss. Rejection is generally ineffective once the goods have been manufactured into parts, and a buyer that held steel for three months and stamped all of it into parts rejected too late.14 A buyer that keeps the goods and says nothing risks more than a late rejection, because silence can itself amount to acceptance.15
The parties may change these defaults, but courts look for a clear expression before they find that a contract has done so. In a Nebraska cattle-purchase dispute, the agreement allowed the buyer, Albrecht, to reject any cattle that were not in merchantable condition, yet it did not describe that remedy as the sole remedy under the contract. Without a clear expression of exclusivity, the court explained, a remedy is presumed cumulative rather than exclusive under § 2-719(1)(b).16 The seller, Fettig, still urged the maxim expressio unius est exclusio alterius, “the expression of one thing is the exclusion of the other,” to confine the buyer to rejecting only unmerchantable cattle.17 That argument asked the court to find an exclusivity term by implication, and a term is found by implication only when the express language and the surrounding circumstances show that the parties impliedly intended it.18 Courts sometimes fill the gap by asking what the parties most plausibly assumed a term would require.19
None of this helps a buyer who has no nonconformity to point to. Section 2-601 speaks of a nonconforming delivery, so if the seller delivers goods that conform to the contract, any rejection by the buyer, in whole or in part, is wrongful as against the seller. The buyer is then in breach, and the seller may use the remedies Article 2 provides.20 A buyer who returns ten boxes of exactly the blue widgets it ordered because the market price has fallen has rejected a perfect tender and has breached.
Accept the Whole
The second option mirrors the first. The buyer may “accept the whole” even though the tender fails in some respect to conform to the contract,22 and acceptance means that the buyer takes the goods as its own.23 A buyer picks this option when the goods remain worth having despite the flaw, either because the defect is tolerable or because having the goods in hand matters more than having them perfect.
Accepting a nonconforming tender does not cost the buyer its claim for the breach. The official comment to § 2-601 says that a buyer who accepts a nonconforming tender “is not penalized by the loss of any remedy otherwise open to him.”24 Section 2-607(2) reaches the same result: acceptance “does not of itself impair any other remedy” the Article provides for the nonconformity.25 The buyer who keeps all ten boxes of widgets may therefore still sue over the green ones, since damages for breach remain among the remedies it holds.26
What the buyer gives up is the exit. Acceptance “precludes rejection of the goods accepted.”27 The buyer also owes the price: a seller suing for the price recovers it for “goods accepted,” a category that excludes goods whose acceptance the buyer has justifiably revoked.28 An acceptance made with knowledge of a nonconformity cannot later be revoked because of it, unless the buyer accepted on the reasonable assumption that the seller would seasonably cure it.29 The later sections on revocation develop that exception. For now the bargain is plain: the accepting buyer keeps a damages claim, loses the right to reject, and owes the price.
Acceptance does not require the word “accept.” A buyer accepts by signifying to the seller that the goods conform or that it will take or retain them despite the nonconformity, or by failing to reject within a reasonable time, and in either case its rights no longer include rejection.30 Connecticut Investment Casting Corp. v. Made-Rite Tool Co. states the rule under Vermont’s version of Article 2.31
Tanzer shows how conduct can fix the choice. The buyer there sent the seller “punch lists” asking for repairs and adjustments. The court held that a punch list is not a seasonable notice of rejection, because a request for repair is by its nature the opposite of a notice of rejection: a buyer who asks that an item receive more work is not saying that it will not keep the item.32 The buyer also kept all of the equipment except the items the court found he had specifically rejected, and he hired another company to maintain the installed goods, an act inconsistent with the seller’s ownership.33 A buyer who wants to reject must therefore say so, in time, in words that cannot be mistaken for a repair request.
Accept Some, Reject the Rest
The third option divides a single tender between the first two. The buyer may “accept any commercial unit or units and reject the rest,” keeping the units it can use and returning the others.35 In the widget delivery, the buyer may keep the eight blue boxes and send back the two green ones.36 The power has a boundary in its own wording: the buyer divides the tender along the lines of commercial units, not along any line it pleases.
A tender of two living-room suites, one with a torn couch, shows where the line falls. The buyer may accept the undamaged suite and reject the other. It may not reject the torn couch and keep the rest of that suite.37 The suite, not the couch, is the unit, so the buyer must take the damaged suite whole or reject it whole.
The Code defines “commercial unit” in § 2-105(6),38 and courts identify the unit by how the goods are sold and priced. One court treated a ton of bentonite as the unit where the bentonite was priced by the ton, and another treated a pound of film as the unit where the film was priced by the pound. Relying on those decisions, the court in Rocheux International of N.J., Inc. v. U.S. Merchants Financial Group adopted a pound of plastic as the commercial unit, although it had found no New Jersey case using weight that way.39 A single shipment can therefore hold many units, and pricing by weight can make the unit small.
The unit also marks how far an acceptance reaches. Section 2-606(2) treats acceptance of any part of a commercial unit as acceptance of that entire unit.40 Because acceptance precludes rejection of the goods accepted,41 a buyer that uses or keeps part of a unit loses the right to reject any of that unit, while the other units in the delivery stay open to rejection. Conduct counts here as everywhere. In Tanzer, hiring another firm to maintain the installed goods was an act inconsistent with the seller’s ownership.42
The same vocabulary appears in revocation. Section 2-608(1) lets a buyer revoke its acceptance of “a lot or commercial unit” whose nonconformity substantially impairs its value to the buyer.43 For decisions applying commercial-unit analysis when a buyer tries to carve up goods it has already accepted, see S & R Metals, Inc. v. C. Itoh & Co. (America) and Abbett v. Thompson.
The commercial-unit boundary has an evident function: a seller who takes goods back gets whole units rather than fragments of units. The third option is also a power, not a duty. A buyer troubled only by the torn couch may reject the whole suite, or accept both suites and sue for damages, as the preceding sections show. The chapter returns below to the limits that good faith and the seller’s right to cure place on rejection.