Concept
Tender and Prior Conditions
Excuse of conditions
Tender and Prior Conditions
Prevention and repudiation excuse a condition for one reason: the party who would profit from its failure helped cause it. Two more settings call for the same reasoning. In one, a party offers to perform and the other side refuses the offer. In the other, the event a condition requires could not occur because an earlier condition failed. Restatement (Second) of Contracts §§ 245 and 255 state the general formula: when a party's breach by non-performance, or its repudiation, contributes materially to the non-occurrence of a condition of one of its own duties, the non-occurrence is excused.1 The two settings below ask the same questions of different facts: who controlled the step on which the condition turned, and would strict enforcement let that party profit from the failure?
Rejected Tender
When a contract is silent about who performs first, the law supplies an answer, and for some exchanges the answer is that neither party does. Contracts for the conveyance of land or for the sale of goods are viewed as capable of simultaneous performance, so absent agreement otherwise they are construed as calling for both performances at once.2 When performances cannot be rendered at the same time, Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 234(2) takes over: the performance that requires the longer period must be rendered first, which is why a builder ordinarily works before the owner pays in full.3 The UCC provisions follow the same approach, and like the Restatement rules they are rules of construction only, so a contrary agreement displaces them.4
Morton v. Lamb is the classic source of the presumption of simultaneous exchange. Under it, each side's readiness to perform is a concurrent condition of the other side's duty, so a party who sues must show that it performed or was ready to perform.
Concurrent conditions create a standoff. Neither party's duty arises until the other is ready to perform, and a party who waits for the other to move may wait forever. Tender breaks the standoff. A tender is a demonstration of present willingness and ability to perform.5
The rule that gives tender its force is this: if one party's performance is a condition precedent to the other's duty, the improper rejection of a tender of that performance excuses the non-occurrence of the condition, and the other party's duty of performance becomes absolute.6 The alternative would reward refusal. A party who wanted out of the bargain could reject every offer and then argue that the other side never performed, relying on a failure its own refusal produced. Excuse puts the consequence of the refusal on the party who refused.
Suppose A agrees to sell a specific automobile to B for $10,000, and A refuses to accept B's tender of the money. B's condition is excused, A's duty to transfer the automobile becomes absolute, and B may file suit immediately for breach of contract and prevail.7 B need not press the money on A or try again, because the one offer was all the condition required and A's refusal is the only reason the exchange failed. The UCC rules on tender reflect this common law practice. A party who refuses a proper tender stands where a party who prevents a condition stands, and one principle governs both: a party cannot rely on the failure of a condition its own conduct produced.8
Excuse protects B only if the tender was proper. A tender demonstrates present willingness and ability to perform, so a party with no means of performing has tendered nothing. Technical defects are treated more leniently. If B offers a personal check, or the tender is defective for some similar technical reason, and A does not object on that ground, A will likely be found to have waived the objection (UCC § 2-605(1)(a)).9 The chapter develops waiver below. The practical lesson is that a party who means to reject for a defect should say so.
The excuse has a limit that exam questions test directly: a buyer who sues without ever having offered the price has no refused tender to point to.
The offer and the refusal that followed it separate the two buyers. A party who announces in advance that it will not perform presents a different case, governed by repudiation, in which the other side need not tender at all.10 Rejected tender covers the remaining case: the offer is actually made and met with a refusal.
Failure of a Prior Condition
The non-occurrence of a condition may be excused when the condition is itself subject to an earlier condition that has failed.12 Conditions can be stacked. One duty waits on an event, and that event waits on something else happening first, so a missing event at the bottom of the stack may trace to a failure above it. Prevention and repudiation look at what a party did. The prior-condition rule looks at sequence: could the required event have happened at all once the earlier step went unperformed?
The standard illustration is a building contract. A builder agrees to build six homes for $300,000 each on an owner's land, with the owner to designate the sites, and the owner never does.13 The builder's right to be paid depends on building the homes, so normally the builder could not recover without proving the homes were built, because the building is the condition precedent to the owner's duty to pay. But the owner's designation of the sites is an implied condition precedent to the builder's duty to build. Its failure is a legal excuse for the non-occurrence of the building, the owner's promise to pay becomes absolute, and the builder may recover the profits the job would have earned.14
A builder cannot erect homes where no one has said where they go. The building condition exists so that the owner receives what the owner pays for, but enforcing it here would let the owner withhold the one step that allows work to begin and then point to the unbuilt homes as proof that nothing is owed. The law will not demand of a party what the other side's own omission made impossible. The measure of recovery follows the same logic. Excuse treats the building condition as satisfied, which puts the builder where finishing the homes would have put it, and that position is the profit on the job. The limit from prevention and repudiation carries over: the builder must still show it would have been ready, willing, and able to build had the sites been designated, as the earlier discussion of proving ability to perform explains.
The same facts support a second analysis. If the owner is found to have impliedly promised to designate the sites on which the homes would be built, the failure to designate breaches that promise and gives rise to damages for the builder's lost profits.15 This route fits the prevention pattern of Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 245, under which a breach by non-performance that contributes materially to the non-occurrence of a condition of the breaching party's own duty excuses the non-occurrence.16 The owner's failure to designate contributed materially to the non-occurrence of the building, and the building is a condition of the owner's duty to pay. The two routes end in the same place, so a careful answer names the prior-condition excuse and notes the implied-promise route as an alternative.
A question in which a plaintiff sues for the price of work never begun invites a search for the step that kept the work from starting. If the defendant was to supply that step, as the owner was to designate the sites, the failure of the earlier step excuses the later condition and the defendant's duty is absolute. If the earlier step occurred and the plaintiff simply did not perform, there is nothing to excuse.