Concept
Tender in Sales of Goods
Conditions (express and constructive)
Tender in Sales of Goods
A sale of goods is where concurrent conditions do their most familiar work, because a seller can hand over goods and a buyer can hand over money in one exchange. Article 2 writes that logic into statutory terms. Tender of delivery is a condition to the buyer's duty to accept the goods and, unless otherwise agreed, to the buyer's duty to pay for them, and a tender entitles the seller to acceptance and payment according to the contract.1 Behind that rule stand the basic obligations: the seller must deliver the goods, and the buyer must accept and pay for them, in accordance with the contract.2 Tender is the act that connects the two.
Two questions organize what follows. What must a seller do to make a tender? And what does a tender do to the parties' duties once it is made?
What Tender Requires
Tender of delivery requires that the seller put and hold conforming goods at the buyer's disposition and give the buyer any notification reasonably necessary to enable the buyer to take delivery. The agreement and Article 2 determine the manner, time, and place.3 Article 2 spells out the seller's acts because a condition works only if both sides can tell when it has occurred, and § 2-507(1) makes tender the condition of the buyer's duties.4
Put and hold name two separate acts. To put goods at the buyer's disposition, the seller sets them apart and makes them available, so that the buyer can take them without needing anything more from the seller. To hold them there, the seller keeps them available long enough for the buyer to come and get them. A tender that vanishes before the buyer can answer it leaves the buyer nothing to accept, which is why the statute asks for both verbs. The standard also spares the seller: making the goods available is enough, and the seller need not press them into the buyer's hands.
Notification answers a different problem. A buyer who does not know the goods are ready cannot take delivery, so the seller must give whatever notice is reasonably necessary to enable the buyer to do so. The measure is what the buyer needs. A buyer who already knows when and where to collect the goods needs little or nothing more. A buyer with no way of learning that the goods are ready needs word from the seller, who alone knows when they are ready and can supply it at the least cost. Goods that sit ready and unannounced in a warehouse have not been tendered.
The goods must also conform. A buyer may reject if the goods or the tender of delivery fail to conform to the contract, and the seller has a right to cure an improper delivery; those rights belong to the perfect tender rule taught elsewhere.5
When the agreement is silent on manner, time, and place, Article 2 fills the gap: goods are delivered at the seller's place of business at a reasonable time. That default tells the retailer in the last version above where to go, and it gives any buyer a location it can identify without a word from the seller. The agreement still comes first, so a contract that calls for delivery elsewhere, or at a stated hour, displaces both defaults. The parties know their own circumstances, such as a buyer with its own truck or a seller with a fixed loading schedule, better than the statute does.
Subsections (2) through (5) of § 2-503 adjust the basic rule when the method of delivery changes. Each receives fuller treatment elsewhere, and the outlines below are enough for this chapter:
- Where the case falls under the section on shipment, tender requires that the seller comply with that section's provisions.6
- Where the seller must deliver at a particular destination, tender requires compliance with subsection (1) and also, in an appropriate case, tender of the documents described in subsections (4) and (5).7
- Where the goods are in a bailee's possession and are to be delivered without being moved, tender requires a negotiable document of title or the bailee's acknowledgment of the buyer's right to possession. A non-negotiable document of title or a record directing the bailee to deliver is sufficient unless the buyer seasonably objects, though risk of loss stays on the seller until the buyer has had a reasonable time to present it, and a refusal by the bailee defeats the tender.8
- Where the contract requires the seller to deliver documents, the seller must tender all of them in correct form, and tender through customary banking channels is sufficient.9
Each variant asks the seller to do whatever the method of delivery requires to place the goods, or the documents that control them, within the buyer's reach.
Tender as a Condition
Because tender is a condition, the buyer's duty to accept stays dormant until the seller tenders, and so does the duty to pay unless the parties have agreed otherwise.11 A buyer who declines goods that have not been tendered breaches nothing. A buyer who refuses conforming goods after a proper tender fails to perform a duty that has come due.
The rule runs in both directions. Unless the parties agree otherwise, the buyer's tender of payment is the matching condition on the seller's duty to tender and complete delivery. This is the concurrent-conditions rule of the preceding subsections: when the parties do not fix the order of performance, contract law fills the gap by requiring concurrent performances.12 The classic statement calls these mutual conditions to be performed at the same time. A party who was ready and offered to perform has fulfilled his engagement, while the party who neglected or refused to perform is the one in default.13 Each side's tender therefore conditions the other's duty, and the two performances ordinarily happen together at one time and place. If neither side tenders, neither is in breach.
The structure guards against an involuntary extension of credit. In a cash sale neither party has agreed to trust the other. A seller who had to release the goods before receiving payment, or a buyer who had to pay before the goods were offered, would be lending to a counterparty whose solvency and good faith cannot be checked, with a lawsuit as the only protection if the trust proved misplaced. Simultaneous tender removes that risk, because each party may wait until the other is ready to perform.
Tender carries two degrees of strictness. In the stricter sense it is an offer coupled with a present ability to fulfill all the conditions resting on the tendering party, and it must be followed by actual performance if the other party shows himself ready to proceed. Something less will still put the other party in default if he fails to proceed in some manner.14 The Code applies the same commercial realism to payment. It is normal to accept a check from a seemingly solvent party, so a buyer who offers a check has ordinarily tendered payment, unless the seller demands payment in legal tender and gives any extension of time reasonably necessary to procure it.15 A seller who wants cash must say so and allow time to get it.
A second rule governs the buyer who already holds the goods. Where payment is due and demanded on delivery of goods or documents of title, the buyer's right as against the seller to retain or dispose of them is conditional upon making the payment due.16 The first rule decides whether the buyer must perform; this one decides what the buyer may do with the goods while the price is unpaid. Without it, a buyer handed goods on a demand for payment could keep or resell them and leave the seller holding only an unsecured claim for the price, the very credit risk the cash structure is meant to avoid. The trigger has two parts, that payment be due and that it be demanded on delivery, so a buyer who took the goods under a contract that gave time to pay faces no such condition at the moment of delivery. The words as against the seller keep the rule between the two contracting parties.
The phrase unless otherwise agreed carries most of the weight in practice. Parties may fix the order of performance in any way they want, and the concurrency rule applies only when they have not.17 A contract that gives the buyer thirty days after delivery to pay is a credit sale, and the buyer need not tender payment as a condition of the seller's duty to deliver, so the seller must deliver first and wait for the money. The wording of § 2-507(1) anticipates this, because unless otherwise agreed modifies only the buyer's duty to pay. The seller's tender still conditions the duty to accept, so a buyer who refuses conforming goods tendered under a credit contract is in breach; what changes is the moment payment falls due. A seller who refuses to ship under a thirty-day credit contract because the buyer has not yet paid is the party in breach. A seller who refuses to ship under a contract silent on payment until the price is tendered is acting within its rights.
The usual exam error is to look for a breach in whichever party failed to move first, or to apply the concurrent-conditions rule to a contract that gave the buyer time to pay. The first question on any such stem is whether the contract extended credit; if it did not, the second is who tendered.