Concept
UCC Open-Term Rules
Court supplies an omitted essential term
UCC Open-Term Rules
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 204 answers a contract that is silent on an essential point in two steps. When the parties made a bargain sufficiently defined to be a contract but did not agree on a term essential to a determination of their rights and duties, the court supplies a term that is reasonable in the circumstances.1 Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which governs sales of goods, takes the same two steps and writes each into statutory text. Section 2-204(3) sets the threshold for a sale, and § 2-305 applies that threshold to price, the term that most plainly measures what a buyer owes.
Article 2 does not stand apart from the common law. The UCC provides in § 1-103(b) that preexisting principles of law and equity supplement the Code unless particular provisions displace them, so the drafters left the common law as a backdrop and changed a limited number of its rules.2 The firm-offer rule is one such change: a merchant's firm offer is not revocable for lack of consideration under § 2-205.3 The open-term rules in this section are another, and they serve the purpose behind the common-law demand for definiteness, which is to let a court determine whether a party has breached and what remedy fits the breach.4
Open Terms Under Section 2-204
UCC § 2-204(3) answers indefiniteness in a sale of goods: even though one or more terms are left open, a contract for sale does not fail for indefiniteness if the parties have intended to make a contract and there is a reasonably certain basis for giving an appropriate remedy.5 Those two conditions give a sale of goods the content that § 204 leaves to the phrase “sufficiently defined to be a contract.”6 An open term stops being a reason to deny enforcement and becomes a gap the court works around. The Restatement section speaks only of a term reasonable in the circumstances; the statute adds, in so many words, the remedy inquiry that the common-law definiteness requirement already serves.7
Each condition does separate work. The intent condition asks whether the parties meant to be bound, and the Code lets conduct answer it: a contract for sale may be made in any manner sufficient to show agreement, including conduct by both parties that recognizes the existence of a contract.8 The condition matters because a court that completed a deal no one regarded as made would impose obligations nobody accepted. The remedy condition asks what the court itself must be able to do. Before awarding anything, a judge must tell which party failed to perform and measure the loss, which is the function the definiteness requirement exists to serve.9
Treatments of the common law sort indefiniteness problems into four groups (an indefinite purported agreement, silence as to a material term, duration problems, and agreements to agree or negotiate) and give the UCC separate treatment.10 Article 2 answers each group in its own text:
- Silence as to a material term. Where the time for shipment or delivery is neither provided in the Article nor agreed, it is a reasonable time (§ 2-309(1)), and where nothing is said about price, the price is a reasonable price at the time for delivery (§ 2-305(1)(a)).11
- Duration problems. A contract for successive performances that is indefinite in duration is valid for a reasonable time, but unless otherwise agreed either party may end it at any time on reasonable notification (§ 2-309(2), (3)).12
- Agreements to agree. As to price, a price left to be agreed that the parties fail to agree on is a reasonable price at the time for delivery (§ 2-305(1)(b)).13
- Purported agreements too indefinite to enforce. The test is § 2-204(3) itself: an intent to contract and a reasonably certain basis for a remedy.14
The newsprint clause in Sun Printing is a clause of the third kind. It left the price of the paper, and the length of the term for which a price would apply, to be agreed fifteen days before each period expired, and it capped the price at the contract price charged by the Canadian Export Paper Company to large consumers.15 As to price, that is a price left to be agreed. Under § 2-305(1)(b) a failure to agree does not end the contract; it triggers a reasonable price at the time for delivery, provided the parties intended to be bound.16
Because the Code supplies a standard answer for each of these omissions, a court asked to remedy a breach usually has a yardstick against which to measure performance, and the remedy condition is met. A buyer and seller who intend to be bound and settle the goods and the price, yet say nothing about when delivery is due, therefore have a contract. Delivery is due within a reasonable time under § 2-309(1),17 and a failure to deliver within that period is a breach a court can recognize and remedy.18
The defaults operate only after intent is established. Section 2-204(3) protects a sale only if the parties have intended to make a contract, so a dispute over material terms that shows they never intended to contract leaves no contract and no gap for a default to fill.19 Conduct cuts the other way. When both parties act as if a contract exists, the open terms look like details left for later rather than signs that bargaining never ended.
Step two does most of the work. A stem that shows a few peripheral gaps and conduct by both sides recognizing a contract resolves for intent, while one that shows continuing disagreement over price and quantity resolves the other way. Step three seldom defeats a sale where a default supplies the yardstick, and step four applies defaults that yield to any term the parties actually chose.
Open Price Term
Section 2-305 puts the open-terms principle to work on price. Parties who so intend can conclude a contract for the sale of goods even though the price is not settled, and the price is then a reasonable price at the time for delivery if nothing is said as to price; if the price is left to be agreed and the parties fail to agree; or if the price is to be fixed by an agreed market or other standard set or recorded by a third person or agency and the standard is not set or recorded.22 The three triggers describe three ways a price can go missing: silence, a promise to settle the figure later that never ripens, and an outside benchmark that never materializes. Each leaves a court with a deal the parties meant to make and no number to enforce, and the statute gives all three the same answer.
Price is the paradigm essential term. It fixes what the buyer owes, and a court asked to find a breach ordinarily needs it to measure what was promised. The statute therefore anchors the missing figure outside the contract, in a reasonable price measured at the time for delivery, the moment the buyer receives what the money pays for. Section 204 states the general idea that a court supplies a term reasonable in the circumstances,23 and § 2-305(1) is the form that idea takes for price.
Every consequence in subsection (1) depends on its opening condition, that the parties intend to conclude a contract despite the unsettled price. A failure to agree on price therefore ends the matter only if the parties meant not to be bound without one; otherwise the court completes the deal. Conduct can show which it was, because a contract for sale may be made in any manner sufficient to show agreement, including conduct by both parties that recognizes the existence of a contract.24
A writing that conditions the deal on a price falls on the other side of the intent line, and subsection (4) governs it. Where the parties intend not to be bound unless the price is fixed or agreed, and it is not fixed or agreed, there is no contract. The buyer must return any goods already received or, if unable to, pay their reasonable value at the time of delivery, and the seller must return any portion of the price paid on account.25 Subsection (1) completes a deal the parties meant to make, and supplying a price on which they expressly withheld agreement would manufacture a contract they refused to make. With no contract, neither side owes performance or damages for failing to perform, and the only duties left are those that unwind what has already changed hands.
The open price is the same in the soybean-meal sale and the oven letter. What separates them is whether the parties intended to be bound without a price, and the letter answers that question in its own text.
When the contract lets one party name the price, subsection (2) attaches a condition to that power: a price to be fixed by the seller or by the buyer means a price for that party to fix in good faith.26 Power to name the price is power over the other side's obligation, and with no limit on it the open term becomes a weapon. A seller could name a figure no buyer would pay and so escape a sale it now regrets, and a buyer could do the reverse with a trivial figure. The good-faith condition keeps the open term from serving as an exit or a lever. A price that tracks the market looks like a good-faith price; a figure double the going rate, chosen only to be rid of the buyer, does not.
Subsection (3) addresses a different failure: a price that was to be fixed otherwise than by agreement of the parties and never was. When that happens through the fault of one party, the other may at his option treat the contract as cancelled or fix a reasonable price himself.27 The option belongs to the innocent party because that party would otherwise hold an unpriced contract and wait on someone whose inaction is the whole problem.
The common law resisted completing a price the parties had tried and failed to fix. When parties take a material term out of the field of implication, the question is whether they have in fact fixed their mutual obligations. If they agreed neither on a definite figure nor on a definite method of ascertaining it, a court that supplies one is not enforcing their contract but binding them to something they were patently unable to agree on.28 Section 2-305(1)(b) takes the opposite course for sales of goods whenever the parties intended to be bound. Outside sales of goods, the Second Circuit upheld in Arbitron, Inc. v. Tralyn Broadcasting, Inc. an escalation clause that let a licensor adjust the monthly fee if the licensee acquired additional radio stations. The clause let the licensor set the price once stated conditions arose, so it was not an unenforceable agreement to agree.29
Step two does the real work, since every other subsection presupposes a contract the parties meant to make. A stem that quotes a clause saying neither side is bound until the price is agreed resolves under subsection (4). A stem that shows shipment and acceptance with the price still open resolves under subsection (1), because conduct by both parties can recognize the existence of a contract.31