Concept
Warranty Applications
Course of dealing
Warranty Applications
Warranties in a sale of goods are default terms, so a course of dealing can move them in either direction. Under UCC § 2-314(3), unless excluded or modified under § 2-316, other implied warranties may arise from course of dealing or usage of trade.1 Section 2-316(3)(c) supplies the subtraction: an implied warranty can also be excluded or modified by course of dealing, course of performance, or usage of trade.2 Both provisions apply the general rule that, unless the parties agree otherwise, a course of dealing between them gives meaning to, supplements, or qualifies their agreement.3 The history can therefore put a warranty into a sale whose writing never mentions it, and it can take out a warranty the law would otherwise imply.
Trade usage can add a warranty term by fixing what “merchantable” requires for a particular kind of goods. For a pedigreed dog or a blooded bull to be merchantable, for example, trade usage may require that pedigree papers be produced.4 A written contract that never mentions papers does not displace that requirement, because the usage supplements the writing instead of contradicting it.5 Course of dealing, which § 2-314(3) names beside usage of trade, can likewise supply an implied warranty that the writing omits.6
Subtraction follows a different path from the formal exclusions. Under § 2-316(2), excluding the implied warranty of merchantability requires language that mentions merchantability and, in a writing, is conspicuous, and excluding an implied warranty of fitness requires a conspicuous writing.7 Section 2-316(3), however, begins “[n]otwithstanding subsection (2),” which signals exceptions to those requirements.8 Course of dealing, course of performance, and usage of trade appear among those exceptions, and notice takes the place of the formalities: the key is that the buyer is on notice based on the course of dealing, course of performance, or trade usage.9
Each of these sources can exclude a warranty without any statement in the writing. Trade usage did so in a cattle sale: the buyer inspected the cattle and cut out those that did not suit him, and under the usage his acceptance of the others “is irrevocable and without recourse,” which excludes all implied warranties.10 Course of dealing works the same way. When a seller and buyer have made several contracts on the understanding that the seller was selling “as is,” their next deal is “as is” too unless they expressly negate the earlier course of dealing.11 That result tracks § 2-316(3)(a): unless the circumstances indicate otherwise, expressions like “as is” or “with all faults” exclude all implied warranties.12 Commentary on product safety adds that, although a manufacturer's duty to warn and to provide safety devices sometimes may be nondelegable, a course of dealing like the one it describes normally should serve to exclude any implied warranty that the product could be safely used as sold.13
Notice also limits exclusion, as Frantz v. Cantrell shows. Cantrell was not a member of the roofing trade and was therefore unaware of the trade usage, and the court concluded that, to exclude the implied warranty of merchantability, both parties had to be engaged in the relevant trade, or the usage had to be one of which both were aware or should have been aware.14 Frantz involved a usage of trade, but the principle behind it reaches every source in § 2-316(3)(c), since each excludes a warranty only by putting the buyer on notice. A buyer outside a trade has no reason to know its practices, and a course of dealing is by definition a history between these parties, so a history the buyer never shared cannot exclude the warranty.
Dunmore's conduct is identical in the two sales, and the outcome differs because only Ames took part in the history. A history can exclude a warranty against a buyer who shared it, or against a buyer who is engaged in the trade or is, or should be, aware of the usage.
The Code's warranties are default rules, and they apply to consumers as well as to merchants. Consumer protection statutes may supplement the Code by making some duties that merchants owe consumers immutable, which the parties cannot vary by agreement.15