Concept
Proving a Course of Dealing
Course of dealing
Proving a Course of Dealing
Unless the parties agreed otherwise, a course of dealing between them gives meaning to their agreement, supplements it, or qualifies it,1 but the party who wants that history to do the work must first prove that it exists. The definition sets the standard of proof. A course of dealing is a sequence of previous conduct between the parties that is “fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding.”2 Each part of that phrase screens out a kind of weak evidence, and the last part decides the forms problem taken up below.
The first question excludes dealings that involve only one side.
Contracts between a party and third persons are a different kind of evidence. They may show that party's customary practice and so shed light on the terms of the present agreement, and even one or two such contracts may be useful.3 They remain evidence of one side's practice, however, and a course of dealing is conduct between the parties themselves.4
The second question asks how often the conduct occurred. The more extensive or repetitious the conduct, the stronger the inference that it reflects what the parties intended. An isolated or single instance is more ambiguous, because it may be only a waiver of rights on one occasion or a disinclination to enforce them.5 A lessor who sees a tenant's duck once and does nothing has not necessarily shown that lessor and tenant share the same meaning of “animals.”6
The third question asks whether the earlier transactions resemble the present one. Evidence of other transactions between the same parties is readily received when it is relevant to the meaning they probably attached to a contract's terms. When the existence of a term is in doubt, similar contracts between the same parties are accepted as a way to show a continuing course of dealing and so the terms of the present bargain.7
The fourth question asks what the other side did with the conduct. Suppose that in April 2022 RRI and Acme contract for 100 anvils to be delivered June 1, 2022, and that they made the same contract in each of the five prior years. Each year Acme delivered between June 3 and June 5, and RRI accepted without objection. The deliveries and RRI's acceptance constitute a course of dealing “fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding” that delivery between June 3 and June 5 was and is acceptable.8
Acceptance without objection carries weight for the same reason it does under the contract in dispute. Conduct after formation under that contract is called course of performance, and performance tendered and accepted without objection is a strong indicator of what the parties must have intended.9 Restatement § 202(4) accordingly gives great weight to a course of performance accepted or acquiesced in without objection.10 A course of dealing carries the same logic back to earlier contracts: a party who watched the performance and said nothing probably read the term as the performer did. Had RRI protested every late delivery, the same five years would show a recurring quarrel and no shared understanding.
Once the transactions qualify, the proof is ordinarily factual. The parties' testimony can establish a course of dealing, while a trade usage is usually established by expert testimony,11 and the earlier contracts are themselves evidence of it.12 The trial judge acts as a screen. If the evidence fails to show a practice regularly observed, the judge can exclude it because it does not show a course of dealing or usage of trade as the Code defines them.13
The fourth question is also where one kind of repetition passes for a sequence of conduct and usually fails. Merchants who trade by exchanging forms often send the same boilerplate with every order. Suppose a seller's acknowledgment forms have each carried an arbitration clause on the reverse side, and the buyer never read the forms or discussed arbitration. The seller argues that the repeated exchange of forms is a course of dealing. Courts divide on whether a mere exchange of forms can be one, but it is hard to see how an exchange of papers that are often unread can be a sequence of conduct fairly regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding.14
The reasoning follows from what a common basis of understanding requires. Article 2 lets parties show agreement by their conduct,15 and the conduct that counts is the kind that shows both sides understood the same thing. An unread page reveals nothing about what its recipient understood. The sender's repetition proves only the sender's habit, and the recipient's silence proves little when the recipient never saw the clause, because silence signals acceptance only of what a party knows about. Visible conduct stands on different ground. A buyer who unloads late anvils five Junes in a row has seen each delivery and could have refused it, and that experience makes the acceptance evidence of understanding.
The same proof works on questions that have nothing to do with a word's meaning. In Southern Cotton Oil Co. v. Merchants National Bank a bank collecting sight drafts for the seller, Southern Cotton Oil, held them fifty-two days before the seller received notice of dishonor, and the appeals court upheld the finding that the bank acted reasonably in delaying.16 Relying on the Code's course-of-dealing provision (then § 1-205), the court reasoned that a course of dealing may establish the seasonableness of an action. In seven prior transactions the bank had delayed notice for nine to forty-five days, and the seller had never complained.17
The five questions can all be answered from those facts. The transactions ran between the same bank and the same seller, there were seven of them, and each raised the same question of how long the bank would hold drafts before giving notice. The seller's silence after each delay was acceptance of conduct it could see. The history mattered because a reasonable time has no fixed length, so the parties' own practice supplies the benchmark. The fifty-two-day hold exceeded every earlier one, but a seller that had tolerated delays of up to forty-five days without complaint was poorly placed to call a somewhat longer one unreasonable. Had the seller objected to each earlier delay, the same seven transactions would show a recurring dispute and no shared understanding.