Concept
Defining Course of Dealing
Course of dealing
Course of Dealing
Defining Course of Dealing
Parties who have contracted before bring a shared history to their next deal, and the law lets that history help decide what their words mean. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts calls that history a course of dealing: a sequence of previous conduct between the parties to an agreement that is fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding for interpreting their expressions and other conduct.1 Four requirements sit inside that sentence. The conduct must be previous, it must pass between these same two parties, it must form a sequence, and it must fairly show an understanding both sides share. Each requirement keeps out something a student is tempted to let in.
For sales of goods, UCC § 1-303(b) says nearly the same thing. A course of dealing is a sequence of conduct concerning previous transactions between the parties to a particular transaction that is fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding for interpreting their expressions and other conduct.2 The two definitions differ in wording only slightly, so a lawyer can use either one to ask the same questions.
The word previous draws the most important line. Conduct under the contract now in dispute is not a course of dealing, however regular it is. It is course of performance, which the next section takes up. Whenever a pattern of behavior appears, ask when it happened and between whom: before this agreement or under it, and between these two parties or among others.
The requirement of a common basis of understanding does a different job. Suppose a lease forbids "animals," and Lessee keeps a duck inside where Lessor never sees it. That conduct may show what Lessee understood the lease to mean, but it does not prove that Lessor shared the view, because conduct by one party that the other neither knew about nor acquiesced in cannot supply a shared understanding.4 Repetition matters as well. The more extensive or repetitious the conduct, the stronger the inference that it reflects what the parties intended. A single instance is more ambiguous and may be only a waiver, or a disinclination to enforce rights on one occasion. If Lessor sees the duck once and does nothing, that alone does not necessarily show the parties share the same meaning of "animals."5 This is why the definition speaks of a sequence.
It helps to think of a course of dealing as the parties' own private usage of trade, developed through their prior dealings to control their transactions.6 Because it is personalized, an established course of dealing prevails over a general usage of trade where the two conflict.7 That also explains why the conduct must be previous and must pass between these same parties. A shorthand two people built tells a court about their words and nothing about anyone else's.
The Code gives the doctrine a structural role. "Agreement" means the bargain of the parties in fact, as found in their language or inferred from other circumstances, including course of performance, course of dealing, or usage of trade.8 Prior dealings are therefore one of the places the bargain is found, and a court may treat them as part of the agreement and not only as a tool for explaining it. With that settled, the next questions follow naturally: how course of dealing differs from its sibling sources, and what it adds when the signed writing is silent or incomplete.