Concept
Between Merchants
Additional terms in an acceptance
Between Merchants
Subsection (2) of § 2-207 governs the extra terms in a reply, but only after the reply clears a threshold: it must be an expression of acceptance. That means it must be responsive enough to the offer to show an intent to contract, and a response that differs radically from the offer, particularly on dickered terms such as price, may not qualify.1 Once a reply does qualify, the subsection treats its additional terms in two steps. They are construed as proposals for addition to the contract, and between merchants they become part of the contract unless one of three exclusions applies.2
The words “between merchants” set a gate that both parties must pass. If either party is not a merchant, that ends the matter: the proposals do not become part of the contract, even if none of the three exclusions applies.3 Merchant status is therefore the first question to ask about any added term.
The Code’s definition of merchant is broader than the everyday word suggests. A merchant is a person who deals in goods of the kind or who, by occupation, holds himself out as having knowledge or skill peculiar to the practices or goods involved in the transaction.4 Comment 2 to § 2-104 restates the test as specialized knowledge about the goods, about business practices, or about both.5 A party need not sell the goods to qualify. Comment 1 reaches even a person who does not trade in the goods when that person is a professional user of them, as opposed to a casual or inexperienced seller or buyer.6 The inquiry asks whether the party’s occupation supplies the know-how for deals of this kind, not whether the party sells this particular product.
Ballet de la Forms, Inc., a manufacturer of dance apparel, needs to replenish its stock of fabric and sends Material Alterations, Inc., a fabric manufacturer, a written purchase order stating the description, quantity, and price of the fabric, the delivery date, and the payment terms.7 Ballet does not sell fabric, but it is a professional user of fabric, which is the kind of party Comment 1 counts as a merchant, and Material Alterations deals in the goods outright.8 If Material Alterations accepts with a form that adds terms of its own, the transaction is between merchants and the second sentence of subsection (2) applies.
A buyer outside the definition looks different. In Hill v. Gateway 2000, Inc., the Seventh Circuit recalled the earlier ProCD dispute: Zeidenberg bought the software at a retail store, an uncommon place for merchants to acquire inventory, and his corporation’s putting ProCD’s database on the Internet for anyone to browse, though it led to the litigation, did not make him a software merchant.9 Commercial use of the product after the purchase did not turn a retail buyer into a merchant.
When both parties are merchants, the default does real work. In Sethness-Greenleaf, Inc. v. Green River Corp., the buyer, GRC, acknowledged in its brief that both parties were merchants, which brought § 2-207(2) into play. GRC had ordered concentrate without specifying a time for payment, and the court found the terms in the seller’s invoices not so surprising, a point the discussion of material alteration develops below.10 The court also explained the practice behind the rule. Merchants do not negotiate the details of every transaction. They prefer to exchange forms stating the standard terms on which they do business, which saves time and effort, and the UCC facilitates the practice by letting a seller’s written confirmation operate as an acceptance even though it contains terms not found in the buyer’s offer.11
Change the buyer and the analysis changes. Carr Buff is not a vintage car hobbyist but a vintage car dealer, and he displays a restored 1957 Ford in his showroom. Rod Hott, a consumer, sees the car and makes a written offer to buy it for $100,000, delivered in one week and paid for on delivery. The next day Carr sends Rod an “Order Acknowledgment” stating, “I am pleased to accept your order for the 1957 Ford on the terms indicated in your order.”12 Suppose the form also carries a preprinted clause sending all disputes to arbitration, and suppose the acknowledgment operates as an acceptance. The clause is then only a proposal. Carr is as much a merchant as the fabric manufacturer above, but Rod is not, so the second sentence of subsection (2) never starts. As the original offeror, Rod may reject or ignore the clause and enforce the contract on the terms of his offer.13 His paying for the car and taking it changes nothing, because mere performance does not manifest assent to additional terms unless the offeror performs in a way that specifically indicates assent to them.14
The line between the two results follows who can be expected to read the forms. Terms in an acceptance can merge into the contract only between parties with business experience, and those are the parties who should pay attention to contract forms.15 Rod, a consumer, is not such a party, so he keeps the contract he offered, and the other side’s fine print binds him only if he chooses to agree to it.
Between merchants, inclusion is the default, not a guarantee, and an offeror who wants a term kept out must find an exclusion. The subsection names three:
- The offer expressly limits acceptance to the terms of the offer.16
- The additional terms materially alter the contract.17
- Notification of objection to the terms has already been given, or is given within a reasonable time after notice of them is received.18
The next sections take them in turn, beginning with the offer that limits acceptance to its own terms.