Concept
Course of Dealing
Usage, Course of Dealing, and Course of Performance
Course of Dealing
Parties who have transacted before rarely spell out what both already know, and the law lets their history fill in what the writing leaves unsaid. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts defines a course of dealing as a sequence of previous conduct between the parties to an agreement that is fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding for interpreting their expressions and other conduct.1 Each phrase narrows the source. Previous puts the conduct before the contract in dispute, between the parties ties it to these two people and no one else, and common basis of understanding requires that the history show what both sides took their words to mean. The Code treats that history as part of the deal itself: the "agreement" is the bargain in fact, found in the parties' language or inferred from other circumstances, including course of performance, course of dealing, or usage of trade.2 A course of dealing is best understood as the parties' own private usage of trade, developed in their prior dealings with each other. Because it is personalized, an established course of dealing prevails over any general usage of trade where the two conflict.3
Unless otherwise agreed, a course of dealing between the parties gives meaning to, supplements, or qualifies their agreement.4 The three verbs name three separate jobs. The history can explain a word the writing uses, add a term the writing omits, or trim the apparent breadth of a term the writing states. The practical reason is that a court reading a new contract without the history would substitute a stranger's reading for the parties' shared shorthand, and the party who relied on the shorthand would bear the loss. The words unless otherwise agreed keep control with the parties. Each side knows the history and can say in the new contract that it no longer applies, so a party who says nothing is taken to use the words as before.
Course of dealing is easiest to separate from its neighbors by asking whose conduct it records and when that conduct occurred. A usage of trade rests on a practice having such regularity of observance in a place, vocation, or trade as to justify an expectation that it will be observed in the transaction in question.5 Course of performance, taken up in the next section, looks at what the parties do under the contract being interpreted. Course of dealing looks at what these same two parties did in transactions that came before it. Suppose RRI and Acme contract for 100 anvils due June 1, and they have made the same contract in each of the prior five years. Each year Acme delivered between June 3 and June 5, and RRI never complained. For the sixth contract, those five years are a course of dealing "fairly to be regarded as establishing a common basis of understanding" that delivery in that window is acceptable.6 Had the late deliveries occurred under the sixth contract itself, they would be course of performance instead. How course of dealing ranks against express terms and other sources when they conflict is taken up in a later section. The subsections below ask which earlier transactions count, which kinds of history fail to qualify, and how a course of dealing can displace the Code's default rules.
Qualifying Earlier Dealings
Evidence of other transactions between the same parties is readily received when it shows the meaning they probably attached to the terms of a contract.9 Relevance sets the limit. An earlier transaction helps only if it resembles the present one and touches the term now in dispute, because a course of dealing is an inference that parties who handled a word one way before meant it the same way again, and an inference is only as strong as the resemblance between the two occasions. A single episode may reflect an accident or a one-time indulgence. A consistent run shows a pattern that both sides noticed and accepted, which is why the anvil history is persuasive: the same two parties, the same term, five years, and no objection. The conclusion about meaning is most strongly supported where all the evidence points to the same meaning,10 and steady repetition is what makes a history point one way.
A long and friendly history fails when it never touched the disputed term.
The trial judge decides whether the history comes in. Evidence of other dealings should be admitted where the testimony about the present bargain conflicts and the risk of wasted time and confusion of issues does not substantially outweigh its probative value, and many jurisdictions leave the call to the trial judge case by case.11 A detailed written contract does not by itself keep the history out. In Columbia Nitrogen Corp. v. Royster Co., the court refused to adopt so broad an exclusionary rule. It reasoned that the Code expressly allows evidence of course of dealing or usage of trade to explain or supplement terms intended as a final expression of the agreement. The test of admissibility, it held, is not whether the contract appears complete on its face but whether the evidence reasonably can be construed as consistent with the express terms.12 Admission is only the first step. The proponent must then persuade the factfinder that the course of dealing did exist and that it supports her position.13
The third step does most of the work, because a history that never touched the disputed term cannot explain it. The parties can prove the history themselves, since a course of dealing can be established by their own testimony, while a trade usage is usually established by expert testimony.14
Boilerplate Forms
Article 2 forms contracts liberally: a contract for the sale of goods may be formed in any manner sufficient to show agreement, including the conduct of the parties.17 That liberality tempts a party to treat years of repeated paperwork as conduct showing agreement.
A court may decline to treat that history as a course of dealing. Mere receipt of forms without objection may not be held to establish assent to their terms under UCC § 2-207, even where the forms are sent repeatedly over time.18 The reasoning in Step-Saver Data Systems, Inc. v. Wyse Technology and Premix-Marbletite Manufacturing Corp. v. SKW Chemicals, Inc. turns on a distinction between (a) a repeated manner of performance and (b) the repeated sending of forms. The reason for the distinction is pragmatic. A party is certainly aware of how the other side keeps performing, and if it does not object over a sufficient period of time, it is assumed to have acquiesced in that manner of performance. The same cannot be said of forms sent again and again, which are often not read until a dispute arises.19 A buyer who watches fifty shipments arrive on the fifth of the month knows exactly what they looked like, while a buyer who files fifty acknowledgments knows nothing about their reverse sides. Silence can signal acceptance only when the silent party saw what it was silent about.
Dealings With Third Persons
A course of dealing is a common basis of understanding, and an understanding is common only if both sides took part in the conduct that produced it. A history involving only one of the present parties shows what that party did and nothing about what the other took the words to mean. The animals clause shows the point.
The evidence is not worthless, but it travels a different route. A party's contracts with third persons may show that party's customary practice and thus supply insight into the terms of the present agreement, and even one or two such contracts may be useful.21 The mystical phrase res inter alios acta has beguiled some courts into excluding such evidence, though it is generally admissible when relevant. The same evidence can also help prove a usage of trade, but only if the practice has such regularity of observance in a place, vocation, or trade as to justify an expectation that it will be observed in the transaction at issue; a usage is usually proved by expert testimony.22 Where that showing is made, the practice enters the case as a usage of trade, not as the parties' private history.
Displacing Default Rules
Article 2 fills gaps with default rules, and a course of dealing can show that there is no gap to fill.
B will argue that the prior course of dealing establishes the parties' implied intention that delivery and installation are part of the contract terms.25 Without that history, the Code supplies a place of delivery: depending on the facts, S's place of business, S's residence, or the place where the six computers are actually located. The parties may specify the place in the contract, but having failed to do so, the law imposes a constructive term, one based on their presumed intention or imposed without regard to their intent.26 A default exists because the parties were silent and the law must guess. The agreement the Code recognizes includes what is found in the parties' course of dealing,27 so where the history shows what these two parties actually expect, no gap remains for the guess to fill.
Implied warranties yield to the same history. An implied warranty can be excluded or modified by course of dealing, course of performance, or usage of trade.28
A court may well hold that the parties' course of dealing excludes any implied warranty. And if tire dealers and farmers commonly address the risk of defective used tires in the same way, a usage of trade might exclude the warranty as well.29 The farmer kept buying on terms he had heard and accepted, so silence on later purchases signals continuity of the first bargain. A farmer who buys a single tire from the same pile after no such conversation has no history to carry forward, and a course of dealing could not support the exclusion. The same carry-forward governs as is sales: if seller and buyer made several contracts over the years on an as is footing, their next deal is as is too unless the parties expressly negate the previous course of dealing.30
Price follows the same pattern. The reasonable price the Code supplies is not necessarily the fair market value of the goods. Evidence of a prior course of dealing between the parties might show a price below or above what is claimed to be the proper market, and without more, a court could justifiably hold that the course-of-dealing price is the reasonable price.31
Not every dispute over an open term turns on the parties' history. When a buyer's requirements shrink, the question is whether the buyer acted in good faith. A buyer that drastically reduces its requirements solely to cut losses on the very requirements contract in question may be found in breach, and the Code comments say that a reduction merely to curtail loss is not in good faith.32