Concept
Writing Versus Proof
Whether a memorandum satisfies the Statute of Frauds
Writing Versus Proof
The Restatement and the UCC both frame the writing requirement as a condition on enforcement. Under the Restatement (Second) of Contracts, a contract within the Statute of Frauds is enforceable if any writing, signed by or on behalf of the party to be charged, reasonably identifies the subject matter, indicates that a contract has been made between the parties or offered by the signer, and states the essential terms of the unperformed promises with reasonable certainty.1 Under UCC § 2-201(1), a contract for the sale of goods for $500 or more is not enforceable by way of action or defense unless a signed record indicates that a contract for sale has been made.2 Neither provision says that the writing forms the contract or proves that the parties made it.
That omission follows from the kind of defense the Statute is. It is an affirmative defense to enforcement, which the resisting party must assert affirmatively and on time, and it differs from a defense to formation such as lack of capacity, misrepresentation, or mistake.3 A writing that defeats the defense therefore does not decide whether a contract was formed.
The analysis starts with two questions: is the contract within the Statute, and is there a writing sufficient to satisfy it? A plaintiff who must answer yes to the first and no to the second runs into the Statute as a barrier. A plaintiff who produces a sufficient signed writing clears that barrier but not the burden of persuasion. She must still convince the trier of fact that the agreement was made as she alleges, and the writing, though it may help, will not necessarily be conclusive.4
A signed letter written in the middle of negotiations shows how far apart the two inquiries sit. Suppose an owner writes to a prospective buyer, Alice, about the sale of the house at 313 Windsor Drive before the two have reached a final agreement. The letter may satisfy the Statute against the owner, because a writing can do so even if the parties never intended to contract or to create evidence of a contract.5 The owner has lost only the defense that no writing exists. If the owner later decides not to sell, the owner can still prove that no contract to sell was ever completed, and then Alice has no claim.
The writing requirement can also decide a case against a claimant whose oral agreement was real. Terry and Clay made an oral agreement for goods that cost $5.10 each but were sold together for $5,100, so the sale is within UCC § 2-201. Terry wants to enforce it. Clay's letter is signed, because the Code treats as a signature any symbol executed or adopted with present intention to authenticate a writing, yet the letter fails the content test. It does not indicate that a contract has been made, and because it is phrased as a counteroffer, it suggests the opposite. Terry's own order form would satisfy the Statute against Terry, but § 2-201(1) demands the signature of the party against whom enforcement is sought, so the form does nothing against Clay. Had this been a common-law contract, that would end the matter, and Terry could not enforce the oral agreement against Clay.6
Even a writing that clears the Statute may prove little. The Restatement test asks only that the writing identify the subject matter, indicate a contract, and state the essential terms with reasonable certainty.7 Under the Code, a record is not insufficient because it omits or incorrectly states a term, although the contract is not enforceable beyond the quantity of goods the record shows.8 When the writing is skimpy or uncertain, the Statute may be only the first hurdle. The plaintiff must then cure the gaps or indefiniteness by interpretation, persuasive extrinsic evidence, or applicable gap fillers.9
The proposed 2022 amendments to Article 2 would raise the jurisdictional amount from $500 to $5,000, substitute "record" for "writing," and update the definition of "signed" so that a record that is not a writing may be signed by attaching or logically associating an electronic symbol, sound, or process with present intent to adopt or accept it.10 Those revisions concern the threshold and the medium of the record. A record in any medium still answers only the enforceability question.
When an exam stem supplies a signed writing, the answer should run in two steps. The first asks whether the writing satisfies the Statute, which turns on the content and signature rules covered earlier in the chapter. The second asks whether the plaintiff has proved that a contract was actually made on the alleged terms, and whether a thin writing leaves gaps that interpretation and evidence must fill. An answer that stops after the first step treats a necessary condition as a sufficient one.