Concept
Lost or Destroyed Memoranda
Whether a memorandum satisfies the Statute of Frauds
Lost or Destroyed Memoranda
A memorandum can satisfy the Statute of Frauds and then disappear. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts says that the loss or destruction of a memorandum does not deprive it of effect under the Statute.1 Every earlier test in this chapter (content, form, timing, signature) assumes the writing is in front of the court. This section covers the case where it is not, whether it was lost by accident or destroyed on purpose, and the answer is short: the memorandum keeps its legal effect.
The Restatement's comment supplies the reason, and the reason carries the whole section. The Statute was designed to serve an evidentiary purpose, but it is not a rule of evidence.2 A rule of evidence governs how a fact reaches the factfinder, and such a rule could insist on the original document. The Statute instead asks whether a signed memorandum exists. When the paper is gone, its contents may therefore be shown by an unsigned copy or by oral evidence, and the comment points to the evidence rules on proving the contents of writings for the mechanics.3
Treatise authority agrees. The writing need not even be introduced as evidence, and if it has been destroyed or is otherwise unavailable, its contents may be proved by parol or other evidence.4 An unsigned copy creates no conflict with the signature requirement, because that requirement tests the memorandum itself. The copy is only evidence of what the signed memorandum said.
Consider what the opposite rule would do. If loss defeated a memorandum, accidental loss would erase a signed commitment through no fault of the claimant. Deliberate destruction would be worse, because the party to be charged could shred the writing and then plead the Statute as a defense. The rule avoids both results by treating loss and destruction alike: in either case a signed writing existed, and only the form of proof has changed.
A guarantee recorded in a properly signed writing that has since been lost presents the standard problem, and it poses the question directly: if the writing were lost, how would one prove that it existed?5 The creditor answers with an unsigned copy, testimony, or both, offered to show that a signed writing existed and what it said, and that proof stands in for the original.6
The second creditor's failure marks the limit of the rule. The doctrine preserves the effect of a memorandum, and a claimant who cannot show that a signed memorandum ever existed has nothing for it to preserve. The party relying on a lost writing must still prove that a signed writing existed and what it said. The doctrine also sits uneasily with the Statute's purpose, since courts permit oral testimony to establish the existence of a lost writing, and enforcing a contract where the writing cannot be produced clearly derogates from the Statute's evidentiary function.7 The cost is real, but the existence requirement keeps it bounded, because a claim resting on an oral promise alone still fails.
On an exam, treat a stem that reports a missing writing as a question about evidence. Ask whether the facts show that a signed memorandum with the required content once existed. The absence of the original settles nothing in either direction.