Concept
Executor and Administrator Promises
Whether the contract is within the Statute of Frauds
Executor and Administrator Promises
A contract by an executor or administrator to answer for a duty of the decedent is one of the classes the Restatement (Second) of Contracts places within the Statute of Frauds.1 An executor is the person a will names to settle a deceased person's affairs, and an administrator is the person a court appoints to do that work when no executor serves. The provision treats both alike, so either one is simply the representative of the estate.
In the standard illustration, John dies and his will names Susan as executor. A creditor of John's claims that Susan agreed to pay John's debt out of her own pocket. That agreement is within the statute, so it must be memorialized in a writing to be enforceable.2
The provision is the suretyship idea applied to estates. The debtor is the decedent, and a third person, the representative, promises to be personally answerable for the debt. That is the shape of the backup promises discussed earlier in this chapter, and the executor-administrator provision is merely a particular application of the rule covering a promise to answer for the debt, default, or miscarriage of another.3
The provision applies only when the representative promises to be personally liable for the decedent's debt. Had Susan told the creditor only that John's debt would be paid out of the estate's assets, the provision would not apply, because a promise to pay the decedent's debts from estate assets is not a promise of personal liability.4 A fact pattern that mentions an executor and a debt tempts students to demand a writing at once, but the question that decides the matter is whose money the representative promised to use.
The provision also reaches only a duty of the decedent. Because it speaks of a duty of the decedent, a debt that arises after death, such as a bill the estate itself runs up, falls outside it. No obligation of the decedent exists for the representative to answer for.5
Two questions therefore settle an oral promise by a personal representative. The first is whether the debt is one the decedent owed before death. The second is whether the representative promised to pay it personally rather than from estate assets. Only when both answers are yes is the promise within the provision.
The same close reading of a provision's own terms pays off elsewhere in the statute. In a case under the land provision, Wheelock's bid was successful, but he refused to let title to two of the parcels pass to Thies and took title to all five himself. Thies sued on the oral agreement, and Wheelock pleaded the statute of frauds as a defense to a contract for the sale of land. The court rejected the defense. The agreement concerned land, but neither party owned the property when they contracted, so it was not a contract for the transfer of an interest in land. The land would pass only later, between the owner and the buyer.6