Concept
Avoidance and Restitution
Unilateral mistake
Avoidance and Restitution
Section 153 of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts supplies its own remedy: a mistaken party who meets its requirements holds a contract that is "voidable by him."1 Voidable means the mistaken party holds the choice. Avoidance is the principal remedy for mistake, and when the mistake is unilateral, the party who seeks it is the one who made the mistake. Avoidance brings the contract to an end, and each side must then restore any benefit, or its value, that performance before termination produced.2
Value is normally the market worth of the property or services, and the contract price may be evidence of that worth. The court has discretion to use another measure that fits the circumstances. If the party who conferred the benefit was more to blame for the mistake, the court may limit the value of consumed goods or services to the economic benefit the other party actually enjoyed.3
Only the mistaken party holds this power. Unilateral mistake is a ground for avoidance by the party who made the mistake, and the other party cannot invoke it.4 A seller who underprices by mistake may seek to cancel. The buyer who got a bargain may not use the seller's error as a way out of a purchase it later regrets.
What § 153 confers is the power to cancel. Nothing in its text or in the remedial rule lets a mistaken party keep the contract and also collect the extra cost the mistake produced. The relief on offer is exit with restitution, and it is not a price adjustment in the mistaken party's favor.
When the other party's own statement produced the error, a second route to cancellation may open. A party may rescind if its assent was induced by a material false representation on which it justifiably relied, even if the representation was made innocently. It need not show fraud or negligence by the other side.5 Compare § 153's alternative showing that the other party's fault caused the mistake.
Reformation, in which the court keeps the contract alive and corrects a term, is the exception, and courts use it sparingly. It is inappropriate when the mistake is so fundamental that reformation would alter the entire character of the transaction or defeat its basic purpose. It is also seldom the best solution when the contract is entirely executory.6 In the Alcoa–Essex dispute, the parties had mutually mistaken a pricing formula, and the price it produced fell far short of Alcoa's cost of performance. The court refused to let Alcoa avoid the contract altogether, because full release would have deprived Essex of its bargain and given Alcoa a windfall. It adjusted the price term to give Alcoa a profit in line with the parties' reasonable expectations.7
For a unilateral mistake, reformation of a written agreement requires more than the mistake. A court of equity will reform only if three things are shown. There must be a valid agreement that sufficiently expressed the parties' real intention. There must also be a written contract that failed to express that intention, and the failure must be due to mutual mistake or to a unilateral mistake accompanied by fraud or inequitable conduct by the other party.8
Mistake matters even when no one seeks avoidance. Specific performance is a discretionary remedy, and a unilateral mistake may be raised as a defense to it in circumstances where an action for restitution would not be permitted.9 A party seeking that order must also show terms clearer, more definite, and more certain than formation of a contract at law requires. The extra certainty helps the court frame its decree and tells the party enjoined what it must do.10
A payment made by mistake travels a different path. In equity, the line between unilateral and mutual mistake is not given weight. The question is whether the claimant conferred an unintended benefit on the defendant in circumstances that would produce unjust enrichment unless the court awarded restitution. If an insurance company mistakenly pays policy proceeds to the wrong person, the rightful beneficiary may seek a constructive trust to compel conveyance of the funds.11 The older law courts reached money by quasi-contract, or implied-in-law contract, actions. These claims need not have any relation to a contract. A plaintiff whose stolen watch is sold has such a claim, although it rests on a tort.12