Concept
Unilateral Versus Mutual Mistake
Unilateral mistake
Unilateral Versus Mutual Mistake
Who held the false assumption decides how much the party seeking relief must prove. When both parties hold it, § 152 makes the contract voidable by the adversely affected party, unless that party bears the risk of the mistake under § 154.1 When only one party holds it, § 153 makes the contract voidable by that party on the same showing plus one of two further conditions.2 The first step in any mistake problem is therefore to classify the mistake, and the classification turns on a single question: whose assumption was it?
Mistake, in this doctrine, means an erroneous belief about a fact. It does not mean a bad judgment, a rash decision, or a deal that simply worked out badly.3 The belief need not be articulated, since a party holds one when it merely assumes a fact without considering alternatives.4 The labels then sort mistakes by who held the belief: a mistake is mutual when both parties share the erroneous basic assumption, and unilateral when they do not.5 Shared ignorance of the truth is not the test. What matters is whether both parties made the assumption.
A miscalculated bid illustrates the unilateral case. A paving contractor adds its labor column wrongly and quotes a price $40,000 under its true cost, and the owner, who has since turned away other bidders, accepts. Neither side noticed the slip. Even so, the assumption that the arithmetic was right belonged to the contractor alone: it built the figure, and the owner saw only a price it was willing to pay. This is the typical unilateral setting. One party makes a mathematical error in an offer, the other accepts, and the first then seeks to avoid the contract or have it reformed.6 Bert Allen Toyota, Inc. v. Grasz shows how the calculating party's own care enters the analysis. The dealer did not check its computer's calculations, although it knew the computer had made errors before, and the court found that it failed to exercise reasonable care.7 That finding bears on who carries the risk of the error: the more serious the negligence, the likelier the court is to place the risk on the party who could have avoided the error by taking greater care.8
The lakefront lot marks the mutual pole. A seller sold a prime waterfront lot for $500,000, knowing that the buyer meant to build a luxury home on it. Both parties believed the lot was suitable for building, and neither knew that it sat on porous, unstable land that cannot support a building. Because both understood the purpose of the sale, the mistake is the basis of the bargain.9 The false belief is one the parties held together, so § 152 governs. The contrast with the bid is the source of the belief. The contractor's figure came from one party's own work, while the lot's suitability was a premise both parties brought to the sale.
Aluminum Company of America v. Essex Group, Inc. adds a refinement: a party's indifference to the other side's motive does not defeat a shared mistake. ALCOA and Essex had written a price formula built on the Wholesale Price Index, a gauge for tracking non-labor costs. Essex's witness, Mr. O'Malley, did not share ALCOA's motive to protect itself. The court nonetheless held that he understood the agreement's functional purposes and had every reason to believe the formula was chosen on the prediction that it would, within tolerable limits, serve its purpose. He therefore shared the mistake of fact, and his mistake was Essex's. His testimony that Essex was indifferent to ALCOA's motivation was, as a matter of law, immaterial.10 The test, then, is whether a party understood the function the term was meant to serve, and it does not ask whether that party cared about the other side's reasons.
The label matters because the standards for judicial relief are higher where the proven mistake is unilateral than where it is mutual.11 The reason is reliance. Because the error affected the assent of only one party, the rules emphasize more strongly the protection of the other party's reliance, and relief is available only if the equities favoring release of the mistaken party outweigh the need to uphold the nonmistaken party's reasonable expectations.12 The gap is smaller than it first appears, however, because the elements of mutual mistake also take into account the reliance interests of the party against whom avoidance is sought.13
The mistaken party in a unilateral case must first prove every element required for mutual mistake, and then prove one of two alternatives.14 The first is that the effect of the mistake makes enforcement unconscionable.15 The second is that the other party had reason to know of the mistake, or that its own fault caused it.16 Either alternative supplies the added reason that justifies disturbing the other party's reliance, and later sections take each in turn. The classification also matters only for avoidance of the contract. In equity, a claim for restitution gives the unilateral-mutual distinction no weight and asks whether the claimant conferred an unintended benefit on the defendant in circumstances that would produce unjust enrichment unless the court awarded restitution. When an insurer mistakenly pays life insurance proceeds to the wrong person, for example, the rightful beneficiary may seek a constructive trust to require the recipient to convey the funds.17