Concept
Proving Undue Influence
Undue influence
Proving Undue Influence
A contract is voidable by the victim when the other party's undue influence induced the victim's assent.1 Undue influence, in turn, is unfair persuasion of a party who is dominated by the persuader or who, by virtue of the relation between them, is justified in assuming that the persuader will not act against the party's welfare.2 Those two rules state what a victim must establish. They do not say how.
The how is hard, because direct evidence of undue influence is rarely obtainable and a court usually has to infer it from the totality of the facts and circumstances.3 Courts respond with two devices. They accept circumstantial proof drawn from the victim's condition, the parties' relationship, and the fairness of the result. And when a relationship of trust is joined to a benefit for the person trusted, many courts shift the burden of proof to the party who benefited. The first subsection covers both devices for confidential relationships generally. The second covers lawyers and other fiduciaries, where the rules run stricter. Neither device changes the substantive test. Each decides only who must come forward with evidence, and how much.
The Burden-Shifting Presumption
The party who attacks a document as the product of undue influence ordinarily bears the burden of proving it by a preponderance of the evidence.4 A landowner who says a business acquaintance pressured him into a deed, and who can point to no relationship of trust, must therefore build the case from circumstances.
Courts that accept circumstantial proof look for roughly the same things. One formulation holds that four elements make out a prima facie circumstantial case, though many decisions require less, and the first element is facts showing the susceptibility of the party influenced.5 Connecticut states the four this way:6
- a person who is subject to influence;
- an opportunity to exert undue influence;
- a disposition to exert undue influence; and
- a result indicating undue influence.
Massachusetts frames the inquiry as an unnatural disposition, made by a susceptible person to the advantage of someone who had an opportunity to exercise undue influence and in fact used it to procure the disposition through improper means.7
Each element supplies one link in an inference that no witness can supply directly. Susceptibility shows that the person could have been overborne, opportunity shows that the influencer could reach the person, and disposition shows that the influencer was inclined to use that access. An unnatural result suggests that the effort worked. Relevant factors include the age and the physical and mental condition of the person influenced, whether that person had independent or disinterested advice, whether consideration was lacking or inadequate, the person's necessities and distress, the person's predisposition to make the transfer, and the size of the transfer relative to the person's whole worth.8 California's Civil Code § 1575 points to the same kind of facts: it defines undue influence in part as taking unfair advantage of another's weakness of mind, or taking a grossly oppressive and unfair advantage of another's necessities or distress.9
The elements operate as a sliding scale rather than a checklist. When the dependency is strong and the resulting contract is clearly disadvantageous to the weaker party, unfair persuasion may be inferred from those facts alone, without proof of any specific underhanded bargaining strategy. When the dependency is less intense or the terms are not patently unfair, evidence of improper bargaining or oppressive circumstances may be needed to bolster the claim.10
Many courts go further and take the burden off the challenger. Once the challenger proves a confidential relationship and a transaction that benefits the person in whom trust and confidence is reposed, the burden shifts to the benefited party to show that the transaction was not procured by undue influence.11 The burden shifts as well when a person in a fiduciary relationship with the grantor or principal benefits from the transaction.12 The two triggers do separate work. The relationship explains why the benefited party must answer, since someone who holds another's trust and then gains from a deal with that person is the one expected to show how the deal came about. The benefit explains why suspicion is warranted, since a trusted person who gains nothing has no reason to abuse the position. How heavy the benefited party's burden is varies. At times a court requires clear and convincing evidence, and because the decision is preeminently one of fact, a trial court's finding is rarely reversed.13
The first trigger is not automatic. No presumption of a confidential relationship arises from the bare fact that the parties are employer and employee; additional ties must be shown. The absence of confidentiality is especially apparent when the parties are negotiating the end of their relationship, because each is then expected to look after his own interests.14
A benefited party who must rebut the presumption draws on the same facts the challenger would use. Adequate consideration and independent or disinterested advice for the weaker party speak directly to whether the transaction was procured by undue influence.15
Moore v. Moore shows the presumption at work. A son ran the family farm for his aged parents, who had placed the farm properties in a trust for all of their children. While the father was dying and the mother was distraught, the son manipulated them into a contract transferring the properties to his own son for a fraction of their value on generous payment terms, which effectively disinherited his siblings. The son's position of trust and confidence with particularly vulnerable parents created the presumption and put the burden on the defendants. Every link in the inference was present: susceptible parents, an opportunity, a large benefit to the trusted son's side of the family, and an unnatural result.
Robertson v. Robertson marks the limit. A farm manager held a position of trust and confidence with an elderly grantor, and the deed recited $100 for land worth between $100,000 and $250,000, yet the court found that the plaintiffs had raised only suspicion and offered no actual proof of undue influence. The difference between the two decisions lies in the proof. The Kansas record showed a trusted son manipulating vulnerable parents in a crisis, while the Missouri record showed a relationship and a lopsided price and nothing about how the deed was obtained. A claimant in a jurisdiction like Missouri's should therefore marshal evidence of susceptibility, opportunity, and an unnatural result, and should treat the presumption as a bonus rather than the whole case.
Lawyers and Fiduciaries
The second route in § 177(1) reaches a party who, by virtue of the relation between the parties, is justified in assuming that the other will not act in a manner inconsistent with that party's welfare.17 A client dealing with the client's lawyer fits that description, and courts apply the burden-shifting presumption to lawyer-client contracts with particular force. A business transaction between lawyer and client is presumptively invalid, meaning voidable by the client, and so is a testamentary provision in favor of the lawyer who prepared the will.18 Voidable carries its usual sense: the client holds the power either to avoid the transaction or to ratify it.19
The burden falls on the lawyer because of the fiduciary duty the lawyer owes the client, which requires the lawyer to show that the transaction is free of undue influence. “Lawyers cannot act like other people, at least not when doing business.” They share this disability with other fiduciaries.20
The four showings answer different ways a trusted adviser can corrupt a deal. The first goes to substance, since a client who received balanced terms has little to complain of. The second and third go to information: a client cannot weigh a proposal without knowing what it will do, or discount the lawyer's advice without knowing the lawyer sits on the other side of the table. The fourth supplies what disclosure cannot, because the lawyer's explanation remains the counterparty's own account, while independent advice gives the client a loyal check on it.
Some courts require the lawyer to carry this burden by clear and convincing evidence. The New Jersey Supreme Court has said the presumption “can be overcome only by the clearest and most convincing evidence showing full and complete disclosure of all facts known to the lawyer and absolute independence of action on the part of the client.”22 Miller v. Sears applies a comparable standard. A client could rescind a contract for the sale of property because the attorney failed to establish that he had fully disclosed all material terms, and the attorney bore the burden of proving compliance with fiduciary duties by clear and convincing evidence.23
The client's side of the case is correspondingly light. When a contract between a fiduciary and the person depending on the fiduciary produces an unfair result for the latter, it is set aside on the ground of undue influence, and entering the unfair bargain is the only misconduct required.24 Some courts drop the undue influence inquiry altogether: if the lawyer “got the better of the bargain,” the agreement can be invalidated unless the lawyer “can show that the client was fully aware of the consequences and that there was no exploitation of the client’s confidence.”25 The farm purchase shows the effect. A lawyer who buys a farm from an estate the lawyer represents bears the loss if the farm falls in value, and faces rescission if it rises. From the lawyer's side it is a heads-you-win, tails-I-lose transaction, and good motives are no defense.26
The duty also follows the lawyer outside the practice of law. Suppose a lawyer represents a builder in unrelated litigation and then enters a building contract with that builder. The lawyer's ongoing fiduciary duty to the builder affects that relationship too, so any term that is unfair to and not in the best interests of the builder is presumed to be the product of undue influence and is avoidable by the builder.27 The same principle governs fiduciaries generally: the terms of the transaction must be fair and fully explained to the other party, and the fiduciary bears the burden of proving compliance with those obligations by clear and convincing evidence.28
None of this bars the dealing. No per se rule prohibits a lawyer from contracting with a client on matters beyond legal services, and in a proper case a court will even grant specific performance to the lawyer.29
The consequences of failing the test fall in more than one place. Even a valid transaction that violates no disciplinary rule will be strongly construed against the lawyer who drafted it.30 If the presumption is not rebutted, a lawyer's loan to a client is avoided and the client must repay only the principal and the cost of the money to the lawyer.31 Discipline runs on a separate track: the lawyer may face disciplinary charges and even disbarment, and courts differ on whether the disciplinary standards govern a civil contract dispute directly, serve as evidence of proper contractual conduct, or do not apply at all.32