Concept
Statute of Frauds Basics
Statute of Frauds and oral modification
Oral Modifications and the Statute
Statute of Frauds Basics
A contract can be fully formed and supported by consideration, yet a court may still refuse to enforce it because nobody signed anything. That is the work of the Statute of Frauds, the common name for a group of statutes that forbid enforcement of certain classes of contracts unless there is a signed writing or an applicable exception.1 Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 110(1) introduces those classes. The classic examples are contracts for the sale of an interest in land, promises to answer for another person's debt, and contracts that cannot be performed within a year of the making. Each state has its own statutes, and some add categories, so the exact list on a given problem depends on the jurisdiction the problem assumes.
The demand for a writing comes straight from England. Parliament's act of 1677, titled “An act for prevention of frauds and perjuries,” declared that “no action shall be brought” on the listed agreements “unless that agreement ... or some memorandum or note thereof, shall be in writing, and signed by the party to be charged therewith.”2 The party to be charged is the person against whom enforcement is sought, which means the defendant. Only that person's signature matters. A seller who signs a sufficient memorandum can be held to the sale even though the buyer signed nothing, and a buyer who signed nothing can plead the statute when the seller sues.
Sales of goods have their own counterpart in UCC § 2-201(1). Except as that section otherwise provides, a contract for the sale of goods for the price of $500 or more “is not enforceable by way of action or defense unless there is some writing sufficient to indicate that a contract for sale has been made between the parties and signed.”3 As under the 1677 act, the signature that counts is the one belonging to the party against whom enforcement is sought.
The required writing is modest. The 1677 act asks only for “some memorandum or note,” and the UCC asks only for a writing “sufficient to indicate that a contract for sale has been made.”4 Neither formulation demands a formal contract, so a signed note that shows the parties reached a deal can do the job.
A covered contract that fails the statute is unenforceable against the party who has not signed. It is not void. The agreement still happened, and the Restatement says expressly that the statute does not make an unenforceable contract inadmissible in evidence for any purpose other than enforcing it in violation of the statute.5 The rule runs in one direction only. A writing is necessary for enforcement of a covered contract, but it is never sufficient. If the promise lacks consideration or a substitute for it, compliance with the statute will not make it enforceable.6
The reasons for demanding a writing explain why the statute covers the categories it does. The original purpose was evidentiary. A signed document gives a court proof that a contract exists and what it says, at a time when the parties could not testify for themselves.7 Scholars add two more functions. Signing a formal document cautions the parties that they are entering an important relationship, and the writing channels them by marking the line between mere negotiations, which are oral, and an enforceable contract, which is written.8 The statute does not always serve even its evidentiary purpose today. Courts allow enforcement on oral testimony about the contents of a lost writing, and other accepted methods exist for avoiding the statute.9 Reliance supplies one such method. A promise that the promisor should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance, and that does induce it, is enforceable notwithstanding the statute if only enforcement can avoid injustice (§ 139).10
A later change to a contract raises the same concerns. A modification is itself an agreement, and an oral one invites exactly the dispute the statute was written to prevent. Years after closing, the parties to a signed land contract may remember differently whether the price or closing date was changed by word of mouth. Restatement § 149 answers whether the statute follows a contract through its modifications. It treats a contract that modifies but does not rescind a prior contract as containing the original terms as modified, and it notes that the statute may apply independently of the original terms when the modification transfers property.11 The sections below work through that rule.