Concept
Effect of a Firm Offer
Offer made irrevocable by statute
Effect of a Firm Offer
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 87(1)(b) makes an offer binding as an option contract when it "is made irrevocable by statute," and for a merchant's offer to buy or sell goods that statute is UCC § 2-205.1 The firm offer is, in effect, a statutorily created option contract.2 Its central consequence appears in the statute's own words: the offer is "not revocable, for lack of consideration," during the period.3 The rest of this unit elaborates that sentence. It covers what the offeree gets without paying, why the legislature gave it, and which option-contract rules come with it.
What the Offeree Gains
At common law, an offeree must provide consideration to keep an offer open, and without it the offeror may revoke at any time.4 Section 2-205 removes that requirement for a qualifying offer. It lets the offeror make a "gift" of a firm offer, so the offeree need not give any consideration and need not buy an option.5 The offeree also need not show detrimental reliance, because the promise need not be bargained for and no reliance showing is required.6 Form takes the place of bargain and reliance. The statute asks for a merchant offeror, a signed writing, and a term assuring that the offer will be held open.7
During the period, an attempt to withdraw accomplishes nothing. The offer is not revocable for lack of consideration,8 so the offeree's power of acceptance does not expire until the period ends, and the offeror cannot lawfully revoke before then.9
The offeree gets what the offerees in Normile thought they had: an offer they could delay accepting, for some specified or reasonable period, without losing the power of acceptance even if the offeror tried to revoke in the meantime. They were wrong, in part because the court found that the seller had never expressly promised not to revoke.10 A firm offer avoids that problem because the statute reaches only a signed writing that by its terms assures the offeree the offer will be held open.11
A neighbor who signs a paper offering to sell you his grill for $100 and promising to hold the offer open for five days stands in a different position. If he sells the grill to someone else on day two, you have no claim. He was not acting in his mercantile capacity, so no firm offer arose, and because you gave no consideration to keep the offer open, he was free to revoke.12 The signed paper and the promise to hold the offer open appear in both stories. What differs is the offeror's status as a merchant, and that status decides whether the statute reaches the promise at all.
The protection runs for the time stated or, if none is stated, for a reasonable time, but in no event for more than three months.13 Once the period ends, § 2-205 no longer holds the offer open, and the common-law default returns: without consideration, the offeror is free to revoke.14
Why the Rule Exists
Section 2-205 is intended mainly to limit an offeror's power to withdraw a firm offer when the offeree reasonably relies on its firmness.16 Construction bidding shows the problem. A prospective prime contractor won the prime contract and then sought to accept a subcontractor's bid, whereupon the subcontractor withdrew.17 Some pre-Code courts let the subcontractor withdraw on the ground that an offeror can always withdraw an offer for which it received no consideration.18
Section 2-205 changes the result in some of these cases. Where it is applicable and satisfied, the prime contractor's reliance is protected even though promissory estoppel does not apply.19 The statute works by making the offer irrevocable on its own terms. It does not ask the court to find that reliance occurred, so the offeree who has planned around the offer can count on it for the period.
The statute helps only when its terms are met, and Article 2 applies to transactions in goods, so an offer that is not for goods lies outside it.20 Failing § 2-205 does not necessarily end the offeree's case. The offeree may still invoke UCC § 1-103 and fall back on decisions holding promissory estoppel applicable, or may invoke the Restatement rule that an offer the offeror should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance of a substantial character before acceptance, and which does induce it, is binding as an option contract "to the extent necessary to avoid injustice."21 The two routes ask for different things. The statutory route turns on form and requires no proof of reliance. The reliance routes turn on proof of the reliance and give relief only as far as injustice requires.
An exam stem in which a contractor builds a quoted price into a winning bid and then learns that the quote has been withdrawn calls for two passes. The first asks whether every condition of § 2-205 is met, and if so the contractor needs nothing more. If a condition fails, the second pass asks whether the facts show the reliance that promissory estoppel or Restatement § 87(2) requires.22
Option-Contract Incidents
Because the Restatement treats a statutory firm offer as binding as an option contract, its rules for options are the natural frame for what the offeree may do.24 The offeror must keep the offer open for the period, and the offeree's power of acceptance lasts until the period ends.25 One incident concerns when an acceptance takes effect. When an acceptance is sent at a distance, the question is whether it is effective when sent or when received, and the mailbox rule is the traditional way of answering it.26 The Restatement treats acceptance of an option differently, so that it is operative only on receipt. Comment f to § 63 justifies the distinction on the ground that irrevocability already protects the offeree, so the mailbox rule is not needed to safeguard the offeree or to give it a dependable basis for knowing that the acceptance has occurred.27
Courts differ on this point, so the hypothetical has two defensible answers. Some courts, Worms v. Burgess among them, are unconvinced by the Restatement's reasoning and see greater merit in a standard, predictable rule for all acceptances.28 On an exam, state the Restatement rule first and then note that some courts would apply the mailbox rule.