Concept
The Power of Acceptance
Termination of the power of acceptance and irrevocable offers
Offer Termination and Irrevocability
The Power of Acceptance
A valid offer puts a power in the offeree's hands. Under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 35(1), the offer gives the offeree a continuing power to complete the manifestation of mutual assent by accepting it.1 The offeror has already stated the terms. The deal still lacks the offeree's assent, and the power of acceptance lets the offeree supply it.
That power can end, and § 35(2) says what follows when it does: a contract cannot be created by acceptance of an offer after the power of acceptance has been terminated in one of the ways listed in § 36.2 A late reply finds nothing to accept. If the power ended by rejection, the purported acceptance can at most qualify as a new offer by the former offeree, which the original offeror may take up or turn down.3
Section 36 lists four ways the power ends: a rejection or counteroffer by the offeree4, lapse of time5, revocation by the offeror6, and the death or incapacity of the offeror or offeree.7 The terms of the offer supply a fifth, because the power also ends when a condition of acceptance fails to occur.8 Each event gets its own section below, followed by the exceptions that keep an offer open against the offeror's wishes.
Often the offeree ends her own power. The test is objective: would a reasonable person in the offeror's position understand the offeree's words and conduct as an intent not to accept the offer? Once the offeree makes that manifestation, the power to accept ends.9 What the offeree privately meant counts for less than how a reasonable offeror would take her words.
The comparison shows that a stated deadline marks only the outer edge of the power. The stated or reasonable duration is the longest period an offer could remain open, and the offer may end sooner if another terminating event comes first.10 Checking the deadline and stopping is the common mistake. The real question is whether the power was still alive when the offeree purported to accept. Priya's early “no” answers it even though most of the ten days remained.
The same logic explains why irrevocable offers are exceptions. Unless an offer qualifies as an option or as a firm offer under UCC Article 2, an undertaking to keep it open for a particular period does not bind the offeror. The offeror may revoke at any time before acceptance, whether or not the offer says it will be held open.11 The common-law rule rests on the requirement of consideration, which is why even an offer stated to be firm can be revoked.12 What keeps the power alive against the offeror's wishes is an option contract, a promise that meets the requirements for the formation of a contract and limits the promisor's power to revoke an offer. The traditional devices for creating one are giving consideration and affixing a seal.13