Concept
Bilateral and Unilateral Contracts
Acceptance: bilateral versus unilateral contracts and acceptance by promise or performance
Acceptance by Promise or Performance
Bilateral and Unilateral Contracts
Every acceptance problem starts with the offer, because the offer says what response it wants. An offer may invite or require acceptance by an affirmative answer in words, or by performing or refraining from performing a specified act, or it may let the offeree select terms in the acceptance.1 Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 30 is the section that lets an offeror specify performance as the form of acceptance.2 The first two options, words and conduct, produce the two traditional types of contract.
The offeror controls which response counts. An offeror may prescribe the manner of acceptance and so may require either a return promise or a return performance.3 Courts sometimes have to decide whether a term about manner is a prescription the offeree must follow to form a contract or only a suggestion the offeree may ignore.4
The response the offer requests sorts the resulting contract into one of two types. In a bilateral contract, both parties have promised future performance at the moment of acceptance, and most contracts are of this kind. In a unilateral contract, the offeree accepts by rendering the very performance the contract requires, so the act of acceptance also completes the offeree's duties and only the offeror still has a promise outstanding.5 The classification tells you who is bound when the contract forms. In a bilateral contract, both parties are bound as soon as the return promise is given. In a unilateral contract, the offeror is bound once the act is rendered, and the offeree never owes a performance.
The Restatement (Second) and the UCC avoid the labels 'bilateral' and 'unilateral,' but many courts still use them. A lawyer in such a jurisdiction gains nothing by announcing that the terms are out of fashion.6 The categories also earn their keep because the special problems of notification, revocation, and part performance arise when the offeror has invited acceptance by performance.7 Bilateral contracts come first, since they are the norm.
Bilateral Contracts
Acceptance is a manifestation of assent to the offer's terms, made in the manner the offer invites or requires.8 When the offer invites an affirmative answer in words, the offeree accepts by giving it.9 Words of acceptance invariably amount to a promise of future performance. The offeror's promise sits in the offer and the offeree's promise is the acceptance, so at the moment of formation each party holds an outstanding promise.10 The offer must in fact ask for a promise. Where it does so unambiguously, only a return promise that manifests an intent to be bound will accept it.11
The answer need not be spoken or written. An offeror may prescribe conduct as the signal of acceptance, and if the conduct only signals assent, the contract remains bilateral. Suppose an owner offers to sell a farm for $2 million and requires the offeree to raise a flag on a flagpole to accept. The flag is a symbol, legally no different from a paper marked 'I accept.' Once it flies, the owner has promised to convey the farm and the offeree has promised to pay.12 The prescribed act is not the offeree's performance under the contract, which is payment of the price. The contract would be unilateral only if the offer made paying the price itself the means of acceptance.
The bilateral label does not dispense with consideration. A promise counts as consideration for the counter-promise only if the performance it promises would itself be consideration, and the bare utterance of promissory words adds nothing. When B says to A, 'If you pay me the $50 you owe me, I promise to give you a DVD worth $10,' B's promise is unenforceable, because A would merely be doing what A was already legally obligated to do.13
Unilateral Contracts
An offer may instead invite acceptance by performing a specified act, and the offeree then answers with conduct.15 The offeree never promises anything, so once the act is done only the offeror has a commitment outstanding.16 The offeree's consideration is furnished in full at the moment of acceptance, and the offeree has no further duty.17 Offers of rewards are the usual setting, and the standard illustration is Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.
In that case, the company advertised that it would pay £100 to any person who contracted influenza after using its smoke ball three times daily for two weeks according to the printed directions, and it added that £1000 sat on deposit at a bank to show its sincerity.18 The advertisement asked for no promise. It asked for use of the ball as directed, so performing that use accepts the offer. Falling ill afterward parallels the fire in an insurance contract. It is an event that makes payment due, and it is not the act that forms the contract.19
The first consequence of this structure is that the offeree is never bound to start or finish. Even an offeree who begins may stop, and a promise to do the act, volunteered when none was requested, is a nullity.20 Suppose an offer reads, 'I will pay $100 for the return of my dog, Barfy.' The reply 'I accept. I will search for your dog' does not accept it, and neither does the first hour of searching.21 The words 'I promise' that closed Sidney's deal with Bertram accomplish nothing here. An offeror who asks for the act has a reason. A promise to perform may be worthless to the offeror, or it may be unreasonable to expect a firm commitment to complete the act.22 The reason is strongest when success is speculative, because an offeror is unlikely to want a bare promise from someone who may be unable to perform even if willing.23
The second consequence is that the contract forms only when the requested act is complete.24 Until then no contract exists, and on the traditional view the offeror keeps the power to revoke all along, even when the offeree is one step short of finishing the requested walk across a bridge.25 The Restatement (Second) answers with an option contract, which arises when the offeree tenders or begins the invited performance, if the offer invited performance and not a promissory acceptance.26 Whether the offeree must also notify the offeror that the act was done is a related question. Later sections take up both problems.
Which form an offer takes depends on what it asks for, and the same price can sit on either side of the line. A seller who offers a piano for $400 if the buyer promises to purchase it has asked for a promise, and the buyer's promise forms a two-promise contract. A seller who instead promises to sell the piano for $400 if the buyer pays $400 has asked for the money. The buyer's promise to pay then accepts nothing, and the contract arises when payment is made.27 These results assume the offer says clearly what it wants. In case of doubt, Restatement (Second) § 32 reads an offer as inviting the offeree to accept either by promising to perform or by performing, as the offeree chooses.28
In the usual unilateral contract, the offeror is the only promisor, but the roles can reverse. A homeowner who pays an insurer a $500 premium and asks for the insurer's promise to pay $200,000 if fire destroys the house has performed first and requested a promise. When the insurer gives it, the only promise outstanding belongs to the offeree, and the result is a reverse unilateral contract. The most common example arises when an offeree silently accepts services rendered in the expectation of payment. If the insurer had instead made the offer, requesting payment, the homeowner's payment of the premium would be the act of acceptance.29