Concept
Purpose of the Comity Clause
Privileges and Immunities Clauses
Privileges and Immunities Protections
Purpose of the Comity Clause
Article IV, § 2, clause 1 of the Constitution provides: “The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States.”1 Lawyers call it the Comity Clause or the Privileges and Immunities Clause.2 The phrasing is awkward, but the command is concrete: a state may not engage in certain types of discrimination against citizens of other states.3 The neighboring clauses of § 2 concern other subjects. The next requires a state to deliver up a person charged with treason, a felony, or another crime who flees to it, on demand of the executive authority of the state he fled. The last dealt with persons held to service or labor who escaped into another state, a subject the Thirteenth Amendment's abolition of slavery overtook.4
The clause was modeled on the Fourth Article of the Articles of Confederation, ratified in 1781.5 That article opened by stating its aim, “to secure and perpetuate mutual friendship and intercourse among the people of the different States.” It then declared that “the free inhabitants of each of these States, paupers, vagabonds, and fugitives from Justice excepted, shall be entitled to all privileges and immunities of free citizens in the several States.” It also promised free ingress and regress between the states and the privileges of trade and commerce, subject to the same duties, impositions, and restrictions as the state's own inhabitants.6 The lineage shows the problem the clause answers: a loose league of states, each free to treat the citizens of the others as strangers.
The Court stated the purpose of the clause in Toomer v. Witsell. Like the clauses on either side of it, those on full faith and credit and on interstate extradition, its primary purpose “was to help fuse into one Nation a collection of independent, sovereign States.” To that end it was “designed to insure to a citizen of State A who ventures into State B the same privileges which the citizens of State B enjoy.”7 A traveler denied that equality did not have to rely on “the uncertain remedies afforded by diplomatic processes and official retaliation.”8 Without a provision “giving them equality of privilege with citizens of those States,” the Court said in Paul v. Virginia, “the Republic would have constituted little more than a league of States; it would not have constituted the Union which now exists.”9
The clause does not erase every line between residents and nonresidents. Some distinctions merely reflect that the country is composed of individual states, and they are permitted. Others are prohibited because they hinder the formation, the purpose, or the development of a single Union. Only privileges and immunities bearing on the vitality of the Nation as a single entity must be shared equally with nonresidents.10 Toomer falls on the prohibited side of that line. South Carolina charged nonresidents commercial shrimp license fees one hundred times what residents paid. The appellants argued that the fee was meant not to conserve shrimp but to exclude nonresidents and create a commercial monopoly for residents, and the Court struck the law down.11 A nonresident fee 25 times the resident fee for recreational sport hunting of wild game was upheld.12
In both cases the benchmark is the same: how does the host state treat its own citizens? The clause supplies no list of rights of its own. It promises the visitor equality with residents, so a rule that burdens residents and visitors alike gives the visitor nothing to complain about.
The sections that follow track the four questions that organize a claim under the clause. They ask whether the challenged law significantly burdens a fundamental right, privilege, or immunity within the clause; whether the state enacted it for the protectionist purpose of favoring in-staters; whether its discrimination is of a type the clause prohibits; and whether the state has a substantial reason for the discrimination.13 Keep this clause separate from the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. That clause does somewhat different work: it protects fundamental rights of federal citizenship, such as the right to interstate travel.14