Concept
The Due Process Clauses
Procedural due process
Process Due Before Deprivation
The Due Process Clauses
The Constitution twice promises that government will not take a person's life, liberty, or property “without due process of law.” The Fifth Amendment makes the promise against the federal government.1 The Fourteenth Amendment repeats it against the states: “nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”2 Because the operative words match, one analysis serves both clauses, and the identity of the acting government decides which clause applies: a federal agency answers to the Fifth Amendment, a state agency to the Fourteenth.3 The Fourteenth Amendment's due process language also protects “any person.” The clause just before it, on privileges or immunities, speaks only of citizens, so a noncitizen can invoke due process against a state.4
The guarantee does not forbid a deprivation; it forbids a deprivation without due process. Government remains free to take life, liberty, or property if it proceeds fairly, and the clauses plainly require some kind of process before it does.5 Two values explain that demand. The first is utilitarian: government proceedings affecting individuals should be designed for accuracy. The second is non-consequentialist and is often called the dignitary or intrinsic value of due process: respect for individuals demands that they have an opportunity to be heard by a neutral decisionmaker under fair procedures.6 Even when due process is given a purely procedural definition, it still protects against governmental abuse.7
Procedural due process is one of two doctrines that grow from the same words, and a fact pattern often turns on which one it raises. Substantive due process is addressed to what government can do. Procedural due process inquires into the way government acts and the enforcement mechanisms it uses.8 The sorting question is what the challenger says is wrong. A challenger who says the action violates a constitutional right raises a substantive claim. A challenger who says the action lacks adequate safeguards, such as notice and a hearing, raises a procedural claim.9 The two doctrines overlap in one respect: both require a court to decide what counts as “liberty” or “property.”10
A state measure confining people who carry a serious contagious disease shows the substantive claim surviving after the procedural claim fails. The measure gives notice and a full opportunity to be heard before any deprivation of liberty occurs, so it satisfies procedural due process. A challenger can still argue that, however fair the procedures, the substance of the law is so unfair and unreasonable that it violates due process. The state's goal of protecting the public is important, but less drastic ways of reaching it may exist, and confinement severely interferes with personal liberty. On that substantive question the measure is probably unconstitutional.11
A state university rule shows the reverse. Suppose the rule lets deans expel any student they believe guilty of cheating. It would clearly survive rational basis review. Even so, its application is left to the unchecked discretion of administrators, with no guarantee that an accused student will be heard. The absence of a hearing before a neutral decisionmaker may violate procedural due process, even though no substantive constitutional right is involved.12 Each example passes one test and fails the other, which is why the labels matter.
The rest of this chapter follows the three questions that structure a procedural due process problem: Has there been a “deprivation”? Is it of “life, liberty, or property”? Is it without “due process of law”?13 The first two questions are threshold questions. If government has not deprived a person of life, liberty, or property, it owes neither procedural nor substantive due process.14 The chapter takes up the protected interests first, then the kinds of government action that count as depriving someone of them. Only after those thresholds does it turn to the last question, what procedures are needed to assure fair treatment when a person's already acquired interest is at stake.15