Concept
Pullman Abstention Contrasted
The “adequate and independent state ground”
Pullman Abstention Contrasted
The adequate and independent state ground doctrine has a close relative that starts from the same premise and acts at the opposite moment. Both doctrines defer to the state courts as the final authority on state law. The state-ground doctrine defers after a state court has spoken, and Pullman abstention defers before.
In Railroad Commission of Texas v. Pullman Co. the Pullman Company and several railroads attacked an order of the Texas Railroad Commission in federal district court. They argued that Texas law gave the Commission no authority to issue it and that it violated the Equal Protection, Due Process, and Commerce Clauses. Porters who intervened adopted those objections but pressed chiefly a claim that the order discriminated against Black people in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment.1 The case thus stacked one state-law question (did the Commission have this authority?) on top of several constitutional ones. The Supreme Court reversed and remanded without deciding any of the constitutional claims.2
The Court's reasoning began with who decides what a Texas statute means. The Commission claimed its power under a statute that directs it to prevent unjust discrimination in the rates, charges, and tolls of the carriers it regulates and to prevent any other abuses in the conduct of their business.3 Whether that language reached this order was a question of Texas law, and the Court said that the last word on the statute, and so on the Commission's authority, belongs neither to the Supreme Court nor to the district court but to the supreme court of Texas. The Court did not disparage the district court's reading. Had it no choice but to decide Texas law, it said, it would hesitate long before rejecting that forecast. But however seasoned the judgment, it "cannot escape being a forecast rather than a determination."4
A forecast is a poor foundation for a constitutional ruling. A federal court of equity that rules on unsettled state law gives a tentative answer that a state adjudication may displace tomorrow, and the reign of law is hardly promoted when an unnecessary federal ruling is supplanted by a controlling state decision. The Court named two costs that equity could avoid: the waste of a tentative decision and the friction of a premature constitutional adjudication.5 The second cost was sharp here because the state-law question might end the case. If Texas law gave the Commission no warrant for its order, the Court observed, there is an end of the litigation, and the constitutional issue does not arise.6
The remedy was a stay, not a dismissal. Texas law offered review of the Commission's order in the state courts. It also offered a second route, in which the State could move to enforce the order and thereby put the state-law issue before a state court. Unless it was shown that these methods could not be pursued with full protection of the constitutional claim, the district court "should exercise its wise discretion by staying its hands." The Court remanded with directions that the district court retain the bill pending proceedings, to be brought with reasonable promptness in the state court.7 The federal court keeps the case, and the parties go to the state courts for the one answer the federal court cannot supply.
The two doctrines share a premise and differ in nearly everything else. Each serves restraint in its own way. The state-ground doctrine shows due respect for the state court and avoids rendering unnecessary or advisory opinions on federal constitutional questions.8 Pullman spares the federal court a tentative ruling and the friction of a premature constitutional adjudication.9 They divide along three lines:
- Pullman operates in a federal trial court at the start of a case, while the state-ground doctrine operates in the Supreme Court reviewing a judgment of a state's highest court.10
- Pullman applies before any state court has ruled, so the federal court's view of state law is only a forecast, while the state-ground doctrine applies after a state court has ruled and a state-law ground already supports its judgment.
- Under Pullman the federal court holds the case and waits, while under the state-ground doctrine the Court declines to decide the federal question.
A federal court deciding whether to abstain therefore starts by asking whether a state court has already resolved the state-law question. The answer shows which doctrine, if either, is in play, as the following variation on the Pullman facts shows.
No. The state-law question is already settled, so a state proceeding could say nothing new and could not make the equal protection question unnecessary. The federal court has nothing to wait for and decides the constitutional claim. Pullman rested on a state-law question that was both unsettled and capable of ending the dispute. Remove the first element and the delay buys nothing. Remove the second and a state ruling would leave the constitutional question exactly where it stood. The Court also framed the stay as an exercise of equitable discretion and conditioned it on a state procedure that protects the constitutional claim in full.11