393 U.S. 23 (1968)
The State of Ohio maintains a series of election laws that impose significant requirements on new political parties seeking to place candidates on the ballot for presidential electors.1 Under Ohio Revised Code § 3517.01, a new party must obtain petitions signed by qualified electors totaling 15% of the ballots cast in the last gubernatorial election, amounting to 433,100 signatures for the 1968 election.2 Established parties like the Republicans and Democrats need only obtain 10% of the votes in the prior election to retain ballot position without new petitions.3 Additional provisions require new parties to hold primaries, elect central committees, and meet other organizational standards by early deadlines, including filing petitions by February 7, 1968.4
In January 1968, Ohio partisans of former Governor George C. Wallace formed the Ohio American Independent Party and collected over 450,000 signatures on nominating petitions.5 The party did not file these petitions by the February deadline, leading the Secretary of State to deny ballot access.6 The Socialist Labor Party had not appeared on the Ohio ballot since 1948 and had only 108 members in the state.7 It also sought ballot position but conceded it could not meet the signature requirements.8
Both parties filed suits in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio challenging the election laws under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.9 A three-judge district court ruled the laws unconstitutional and ordered space for write-in votes but denied requests for printed ballot positions, citing delays in filing suit and, for the Socialist Labor Party, its small membership.10 The Independent Party appealed and obtained an interlocutory injunction from Justice Stewart placing its candidates on the ballot pending appeal.11 The Socialist Labor Party's similar request was denied due to timing concerns that would disrupt ballot printing.12
The district court decided both cases on August 29, 1968.13 The cases reached the Supreme Court with argument on October 7, 1968.14 The Independent Party had over 450,000 signatures verified in number though not timely filed, and the Socialist Labor Party had maintained formal party structures but lacked sufficient support under the laws.15
Whether the political-question doctrine precludes judicial consideration of challenges to state laws regulating the selection of presidential electors?16
The political-question doctrine does not bar judicial review of constitutional challenges to state election laws regulating presidential electors.17 Such claims present justiciable controversies under the Equal Protection Clause.18 Precedents such as Baker v. Carr have rejected the doctrine in this context.19
No. The established facts establish that the Ohio American Independent Party and the Socialist Labor Party filed suits in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio alleging that Ohio Revised Code § 3517.01 and related provisions violated the Equal Protection Clause by denying ballot access.20 The three-judge district court reached the merits and ruled the laws unconstitutional in part.21 The Supreme Court granted review and explicitly held that the claims raise a justiciable controversy that cannot be relegated to the political arena.22 The facts show the suits directly implicate constitutional rights to vote and associate rather than nonjusticiable political questions.23
The political-question doctrine does not preclude judicial consideration of the challenges.24
Related opinions on this issue
Chief Justice Warren dissented, emphasizing that the Court had only seven days to consider the important constitutional questions presented by these cases.25 The rationale of the opinion of the Court, based both on the Equal Protection Clause and the First Amendment guarantee of freedom of association, will apply to all elections, national, state, and local.26 He argued that the parties' delay in filing suit and failure to comply with Ohio law meant the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying extraordinary relief.27
Warren stressed the need to preserve federal-state relationships and the opportunity for state legislatures to remedy defects before federal intervention.28 He noted that the ramifications of the decision may be comparable to those of Baker v. Carr, a case the Court had deliberated for nearly a year.29
Whether Article II, Section 1 of the Constitution grants states absolute power to impose any burdens they choose on the selection of presidential electors?30
Article II, Section 1 grants states power to direct the manner of appointing electors.31 This power remains subject to other constitutional limitations including the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.32 It cannot be exercised to violate express commands such as those in the Fifteenth, Nineteenth, and Twenty-fourth Amendments.33
No. The established facts demonstrate that Ohio claimed absolute power under Article II, Section 1 to impose the 15 percent signature requirement and early deadlines that effectively excluded all but the Republican and Democratic Parties.34 The facts show these burdens were applied to the Ohio American Independent Party despite its collection of over 450,000 signatures and to the Socialist Labor Party with its formal party structure.35 The Court held that the power to select electors may not be exercised in a manner that violates the Equal Protection Clause.36 Ohio's laws therefore exceeded the constitutional grant by imposing invidious discrimination.37
Article II, Section 1 does not grant states absolute power to impose any burdens they choose on the selection of presidential electors.38
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Stewart dissented on the ground that Article II, Section 1 explicitly vests the appointment of electors in the state legislatures and that Ohio's even-handed requirements for demonstrating widespread support were within that power.39 He maintained that the Constitution does not require popular election of electors and that the Fourteenth Amendment imposes only limited constraints such as prohibitions on racial or sex discrimination.40 Stewart concluded that Ohio's system did not violate equal protection because the classification rested on grounds relevant to ensuring majority support.41
Whether Ohio's election laws deny new political parties and their supporters the equal protection of the laws by imposing substantially unequal burdens on the rights to vote and associate?42
State election laws that place substantially unequal burdens on the rights to vote and to associate for political purposes violate the Equal Protection Clause unless the state demonstrates a compelling interest that justifies the restrictions.43 Only invidious discrimination is forbidden but classifications that heavily burden fundamental rights require strict scrutiny.44
Yes. The established facts show that Ohio's 15 percent signature requirement, early filing deadline, and primary organization mandates gave the Republican and Democratic Parties a decided advantage while making it virtually impossible for new parties to qualify.45 The Ohio American Independent Party obtained more than the required 433,100 signatures yet was excluded for missing the February deadline.46 The Socialist Labor Party maintained formal structures but could not meet the threshold.47
These burdens heavily impaired the rights to associate and to cast effective votes.48 Ohio failed to show a compelling interest sufficient to justify the severe restrictions on these fundamental freedoms.49
Ohio's election laws deny new political parties and their supporters the equal protection of the laws by imposing substantially unequal burdens on the rights to vote and associate.50
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Douglas concurred on the ground that the First Amendment right of association, incorporated through the Fourteenth Amendment, lies at the root of the cases.51 He explained that Ohio's entangling web of election laws effectively foreclosed the ballot to all but the two major parties by abolishing write-ins, eliminating independent candidates, and defining political parties so narrowly that third parties could not qualify.52 Douglas emphasized that cumbersome machinery suffocates the right to organize and vote for dissenting views and that the Bill of Rights already performed the necessary balancing.53
Justice Harlan concurred in the result but rested the decision solely on the First Amendment right of political association protected by the Due Process Clause.54 He argued that by denying appellants any opportunity to participate in the procedure for selecting presidential electors, Ohio eliminated the basic incentive for political activity and deprived them of the substance of their protected rights.55 Harlan stated that the state may limit association only upon an impelling policy justification, which Ohio failed to provide.56
Whether the district court properly limited relief to write-in voting rather than ordering printed ballot access for the challenging parties given the timing of their suits?57
A district court may limit equitable relief in election cases to write-in voting when granting printed ballot access would cause serious disruption to the electoral process.58 The court must consider the parties' diligence, the feasibility of compliance, and the risk of interference with other voters' rights.59
No. The established facts establish that the district court ordered write-in space for both parties but denied printed ballot positions citing laches and, for the Socialist Labor Party, its small membership of 108.60 The Independent Party promptly sought and obtained interlocutory relief from Justice Stewart after the August 29, 1968 decision, and Ohio represented that placement on the ballot would not disrupt the election.61 The Socialist Labor Party sought similar relief later, leading to denial because reprinting ballots would cause confusion for absentee voters.62 The Supreme Court affirmed the limited relief for the Socialist Labor Party but modified the judgment to grant the Independent Party printed ballot access.63
The district court properly limited relief for the Socialist Labor Party but should have granted printed ballot access to the Independent Party given the feasibility shown in the record.64
Related opinions on this issue
Justice White dissented in No. 543 and concurred in No. 544.65 He maintained that neither the Due Process Clause nor the Equal Protection Clause prohibits Ohio from requiring appointment of electors through the political party process.66 White argued that the Independent Party made no effort to comply with the primary participation requirement and filed its challenge too late to participate in the primary.67
He concluded that the party was in no position to complain about later obstacles when it had ignored valid preconditions.68