258 U.S. 268 (1922)
The respondents brought this suit against the petitioner to recover for the death of two children, sons of the respondents.1 The petitioner owned a tract of about twenty acres in the outskirts of the town of Iola, Kansas, where it formerly had a plant for the making of sulphuric acid and zinc spelter.2
In 1910 it tore the building down but left a basement and cellar, in which in July, 1916, water was accumulated, clear in appearance but in fact dangerously poisoned by sulphuric acid and zinc sulphate that had come in one way or another from the petitioner’s works, as the petitioner knew.3 A travelled way passed within 120 or 100 feet of it.4
On July 27, 1916, the children, who were eight and eleven years old, came upon the petitioner’s land, went into the water, were poisoned and died.5 At the trial the Judge instructed the jury that if the water looked clear but in fact was poisonous and thus the children were allured to it the petitioner was liable.6 The respondents got a verdict and judgment which was affirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals.7
Whether the petitioner could be held liable for the deaths of the two children on the facts assumed to have been proved?8
A landowner owes no duty to keep his land safe for children or free from hidden dangers unless he has directly or by implication invited or licensed them to come there.9 Temptation is not invitation, and to establish an implied invitation the dangerous condition must be visible from a place where the children lawfully were, must have induced them to enter, and children must have been in the habit of going to the place.10 Infants have no greater right to enter than adults, and the mere fact that they are children imposes no duty on landowners to expect them and prepare for their safety.11
No. The children entered the petitioner’s land as trespassers.12 The established facts show that it is at least doubtful whether the water could be seen from any place where the children lawfully were.13 There is no evidence that it was what led them to enter the land.14 It does not appear that children were in the habit of going to the place.15
Therefore the conditions necessary to create a duty of care toward the children are absent.16 The petitioner cannot be held liable.17
The petitioner could not be held liable for the deaths of the two children.18
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by The Chief Justice And Mr. Justice Day
Justice Clarke dissented, joined by the Chief Justice and Justice Day.19 He maintained that the attractive nuisance doctrine articulated in Railroad Co. v. Stout and Union Pacific Ry. Co. v. McDonald remained sound law and that the facts of the poisoned pool presented a classic jury question under that doctrine.20
Clarke emphasized the pool’s appearance as an attractive swimming hole on a hot day, its proximity to a highway and paths, the absence of any fence or warning, and the presence of other children at the time, arguing that reasonable minds could differ on whether the petitioner should have anticipated that children would be drawn to the site.21 He concluded that the majority’s rejection of the humane doctrine in favor of a harsher rule improperly took the case from the jury and overruled long-standing precedent.22