455 U.S. 720 (1982)
Sandia Corporation was organized in 1949 as a subsidiary of Western Electric Company.1 It manages the Government-owned Sandia Laboratories in Albuquerque and engages exclusively in federally sponsored research.2 Sandia receives no fee under its contract and owns no property except for $1,000 in United States bonds.3 Sandia and Western Electric receive royalty-free licenses for discoveries developed during the contract.4
The Zia Company is a subsidiary of Santa Fe Industries.5 Since 1946 Zia has performed management and maintenance functions at the Government's Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory for its costs plus a fixed annual fee.6 Los Alamos Constructors, Inc., a 1953 subsidiary of Zia, handles construction and repair work at the same facility under identical cost-plus terms.7
All three contracts provide that title to purchased property passes directly from the vendor to the Government.8 The Government bears the risk of loss for property procured by the contractors.9 The contractors place orders in their own names and identify themselves as buyers.10 The contracts employ an advanced-funding procedure under which contractors draw on a special bank account funded by Treasury letters of credit.11
New Mexico imposes a four-percent gross receipts tax on the privilege of engaging in business and an equivalent compensating use tax on property acquired out of state.12 Both taxes exempt the United States and its agencies and instrumentalities.13 Zia and LACI paid the gross receipts tax on their fixed fees without objection.14 In July 1975 the United States filed suit in the District of New Mexico seeking declaratory relief.15 The district court granted summary judgment for the United States.16 The Tenth Circuit reversed, and the Supreme Court granted certiorari.17
Whether New Mexico may impose its gross receipts tax on funds received by private contractors for salaries and internal costs under cost-plus management contracts with the United States?18
A state may not lay a tax directly upon the United States itself or on an agency or instrumentality so closely connected to the Government that the two cannot realistically be viewed as separate entities.19
No. The contractors are privately owned corporations that place orders in their own names and exercise substantial autonomy in day-to-day operations.20 They receive fixed fees or other benefits and remain distinct entities pursuing private ends.21 The advanced-funding procedure is merely an efficient method of reimbursement that does not alter the contractors' independent status.22
New Mexico may impose its gross receipts tax on funds received by the contractors for salaries and internal costs.23
Whether New Mexico may impose its compensating use tax on private contractors' use of government-owned property at federal facilities?24
A state use tax on a federal contractor's use of government property is valid when the contractor is an independent entity using the property in connection with its own commercial activities carried on for profit.25
Yes. The contracts are standard AEC management contracts identical in relevant respects to those upheld in United States v. Boyd.26 The contractors perform maintenance and construction work and procure materials with government funds while remaining privately owned corporations. Their use of the property constitutes a separate and distinct taxable activity that does not fall directly on the United States.27
New Mexico may impose its compensating use tax on the contractors' use of government-owned property.28
Whether New Mexico may impose its gross receipts tax on sales of tangible property to private contractors who procure goods for use at federal atomic laboratories?29
A state sales tax on purchases by a federal contractor is valid unless the contractor serves as a procurement agent. The contractor must be so closely associated with the Government and lack an independent role that the sale is in both a real and symbolic sense a sale to the United States itself.30
No. Although title passes directly from vendors to the United States, the contractors make purchases in their own names and are presumably liable to vendors.31 They do not obtain advance approval for each transaction and have not been formally designated as purchasing agents.32 The contractors therefore retain a substantial independent role.33
New Mexico may impose its gross receipts tax on sales of tangible property to the contractors.34