19 Md. App. 217, 310 A.2d 186 (1973)
Freda Thomas, the fifty-three year old widow of William Henry Thomas, brought suit against the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company and locomotive engineer James Kostik following the death of her fifty-five year old husband.1
On December 7, 1970, William Henry Thomas was driving his twenty-ton dump truck across the Rock Cut Quarry railroad crossing near Corriganville in Allegany County, Maryland, when it was struck broadside by a ninety-four car freight train hauled by two diesel locomotives traveling on the eastbound tracks.2 The collision occurred shortly before 5:30 p.m. under cold, dark, and clear conditions, resulting in the truck being pushed approximately 1100 feet down the tracks before stopping, catching fire, and causing the almost instant death of the driver.3
The Rock Cut Quarry crossing provided access from Maryland State Route 36 to a stone quarry, coal yard, and houses, with the highway running parallel about thirty feet south of the railroad right-of-way.4 Thomas had delivered a load of coal to the yard and was returning to Route 36 when the accident happened.5 The train, coming from Connellsville, Pennsylvania, to Cumberland, Maryland, was traveling at twenty-five miles per hour with its headlights on high beam, bell ringing, and whistle sounding the standard crossing signal of two long blasts, a short blast, and a long blast.6
The head brakeman, positioned on the left side of the locomotive, observed the truck's headlights emerging from the quarry area from about 1800 feet away after rounding a curve and had an unobstructed view down a straight stretch.7 He alerted the engineer twice, first noting the truck coming out and then warning that it did not appear to be stopping, with the second alert occurring when the train was about 900 feet from the crossing.8 The engineer, on the right side with limited leftward vision due to the locomotive's design, first saw the truck as it crossed onto the eastbound tracks when the train was sixty to seventy feet away and activated the emergency brakes around the time of impact.9
Evidence showed that Thomas had used the Rock Cut Quarry crossing multiple times previously, including delivering the coal load ten to fifteen minutes before the accident, and a witness following him observed the truck approaching at about ten miles per hour without fully stopping.10 The railroad had not erected the required warning sign at the crossing because it believed the road remained a private way, though the access road had been incorporated into the county system years earlier.11 Thomas's widow testified that she believed her husband had visited the quarry only once before and described him as a cautious driver due to having lost an eye in a prior mining accident.12
The case proceeded to trial in the Circuit Court for Allegany County before Judge James S. Getty, who at the conclusion of the entire case directed a verdict in favor of the railroad company and the engineer.13 Freda Thomas, as surviving spouse and personal representative, along with the deceased's collision insurance carrier, appealed the judgment to the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland.14
Whether the railroad company and engineer were free of primary negligence as a matter of law?15
Maryland law requires a railroad to erect warning signs at public road crossings under Code, Art. 23, § 205, rendering the company liable for injuries from neglect or refusal to do so.16 However, the absence of such a sign does not constitute primary negligence where the driver knew of the crossing and could not have been misled by its absence, as held in Glick v. Cumb. & W. Elec. Ry. Co.17
Yes. Applying the rule to the established facts, the train operated by the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company and James Kostik traveled at twenty-five miles per hour in a zone authorizing forty miles per hour.18 The headlights were on high beam, the bell was ringing, and the whistle sounded the standard signal of two long blasts, a short blast, and a long blast.19 The brakeman maintained a lookout and observed the truck headlights from eighteen hundred feet away after rounding the curve, while the engineer activated the emergency brakes upon seeing the truck at sixty to seventy feet.20 Although the railroad had not erected the required warning sign, William Henry Thomas was familiar with the Rock Cut Quarry crossing, having used it multiple times previously including ten to fifteen minutes before the accident.21
The evidence demonstrates no scintilla of primary negligence on the part of the railroad or engineer.22 The brakeman alerted the engineer twice regarding the approaching truck, first at approximately nine hundred feet from the crossing.23
The railroad company and engineer were free of primary negligence as a matter of law.24
Whether the deceased driver was guilty of contributory negligence?25
It is negligence per se for a person to attempt to cross railroad tracks without first looking and listening for approaching trains, with the obligation to keep looking as he proceeds across the intersection, as established in Campbell v. Patton and Sears v. B. & O. R. R.26 Under Md. Code, Art. 66½, § 11-701, the driver must stop within fifty feet but not less than fifteen feet from the nearest rail when a train approaches within approximately one thousand five hundred feet emitting an audible signal or is plainly visible and in hazardous proximity.27
Yes. Applying the rule to the established facts, William Henry Thomas failed to stop as required by statute when the train approached, emitting an audible whistle signal from one thousand to two thousand feet away, and was plainly visible.28 The witness following the truck observed it approach the crossing at about ten miles per hour without fully stopping, appearing only to slow down and take a glance.29 Thomas had used the Rock Cut Quarry crossing multiple times previously, including delivering a load of coal ten to fifteen minutes before the accident, yet proceeded onto the tracks without looking and listening adequately.30
The evidence shows that had Thomas looked and listened he would have both seen and heard the oncoming train as did others in the vicinity.31 His failure to comply with the statutory and decisional requirements of stopping, looking, and listening constituted contributory negligence that proximately caused the collision.32
The deceased driver was guilty of contributory negligence.33
Whether the doctrine of last clear chance applied under the facts of the case?34
The doctrine of last clear chance presupposes primary negligence on the part of the defendant, contributory negligence on the part of the plaintiff, and a showing of something new or independent which affords the defendant a fresh opportunity to avert the consequences of the original negligence and the plaintiff's contributory negligence, as set forth in Mackenzie v. Reesey.35
No. Applying the rule to the established facts, the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company and James Kostik were free of primary negligence, so an essential element for invocation of the doctrine of last clear chance is lacking.36 Even assuming primary negligence, there was no showing of any new or independent factor that would have afforded a fresh opportunity to avert the consequences, as the engineer first saw the truck when the train was sixty to seventy feet from the crossing and activated the emergency brakes around the time of impact.37
The brakeman's alerts occurred as the train approached, but the facts show no additional opportunity arose beyond the original circumstances.38 The doctrine therefore has no application here.39
The doctrine of last clear chance did not apply under the facts of the case.40