140 N.J. 43, 657 A.2d 420 (1995)
Plaintiffs, a group of more than 150 families, purchased homes in The Greens at Voorhees, a development of 523 single-family homes and townhouses built by defendants John B. Canuso, Sr., John B. Canuso, Jr., and their companies Canetic Corporation and Canuso Management Corporation on a 145-acre tract in Voorhees Township, Camden County.1 Fox & Lazo Inc. acted as the brokerage firm that marketed the homes for the development.2 The purchases occurred between 1984 and 1987.3
The Buzby Landfill consists of a nineteen-acre portion owned by RCA and a contiguous thirty-seven-acre parcel owned by Voorhees Township.4 Those two tracts were the site of a landfill from 1966 to 1978.5 Although the Buzby Landfill was not licensed to receive liquid-industrial or chemical wastes, large amounts of hazardous materials and chemicals were dumped there.6
Tests done by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and Energy revealed that leachate was seeping from the landfill into a downstream lake.7 Additional tests indicated the presence of hazardous waste in ground water, in marsh sediments taken from the landfill, and in lakes southeast of the landfill.8
Defendants were aware of the existence of the Buzby Landfill before they considered the site for residential development.9 A 1980 EPA report warned that the proposed housing development on land adjacent to the site had all the potential of developing into a future Love Canal if construction was permitted.10 A copy of the EPA report was in the Canuso defendants' files.11 Those defendants also met with a DEPE employee to discuss the prospects of building homes near the landfill.12
One of Fox & Lazo's marketing directors urged his firm and the individual Canuso defendants to disclose the existence of the Buzby Landfill to home buyers.13 Each refused that request and instead followed a policy of nondisclosure.14 Defendants' representatives were instructed never to disclose the existence of the Buzby Landfill, even when asked about such conditions.15 After plaintiffs had purchased their homes, the DEP discovered that hazardous chemicals from the landfill were migrating through the groundwater toward the development.16 The DEP notified the homeowners of the potential danger.17 The value of the homes declined substantially after the disclosure.18
Plaintiffs filed suit against the Canuso defendants and Fox & Lazo, alleging common-law fraud, negligent misrepresentation, and violations of the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act.19 The trial court granted summary judgment dismissing the claims of seven plaintiff-families on the ground that there was no duty to disclose conditions on someone else's property.20 The Appellate Division reversed that judgment and held that class certification should have been granted.21 The Supreme Court granted defendants' motion for leave to appeal.22
Whether a builder-developer of new homes and the brokers marketing those homes have a duty to disclose to prospective buyers that the homes have been constructed near an abandoned hazardous-waste dump?23
A builder-developer of residential real estate or a broker representing it has a duty to disclose off-site physical conditions known to it and unknown and not readily observable by the buyer.24 The duty applies if the existence of those conditions is of sufficient materiality to affect the habitability, use, or enjoyment of the property and therefore render the property substantially less desirable or valuable to the objectively reasonable buyer.25
Yes. Plaintiffs comprising more than 150 families purchased homes in The Greens at Voorhees between 1984 and 1987 from the Canuso defendants, who developed the 145-acre tract, with Fox & Lazo acting as the marketing broker.26 The Buzby Landfill received large amounts of hazardous materials from 1966 to 1978 and lay near the development boundary, with DEP monitoring confirming leachate seepage and groundwater contamination. Defendants possessed actual knowledge through the 1980 EPA report in their files and DEPE meetings.27 They maintained an explicit policy of nondisclosure.28 Sales personnel were directed to withhold the information even when asked.29 Brochures portrayed only a bucolic setting.30
The landfill condition was unknown and not readily observable to buyers.31 Its materiality is confirmed by the substantial decline in home values after DEP notification of migrating chemicals.32 Professional sellers with superior information access therefore bore the duty to disclose.33
The builder-developer and brokers had a duty to disclose the existence of the nearby hazardous-waste dump to the prospective buyers.34
Whether the duty to disclose extends to off-site physical conditions known to the seller that materially affect the value or desirability of the property?35
Yes. The court rejected any meaningful distinction between on-site and off-site conditions because the proximity of the Buzby Landfill materially affected market value, as demonstrated by the substantial decline in home values once DEP disclosed the migrating contamination.38 Defendants' actual knowledge from the EPA report and DEPE discussions placed the condition within their superior access to information.39 Buyers could not readily observe the off-site hazard.40
The duty therefore reaches known off-site physical conditions that render property substantially less desirable or valuable to an objectively reasonable purchaser.41
The duty to disclose extends to such off-site physical conditions.42
Whether class certification is appropriate when multiple home purchasers allege nondisclosure of a nearby landfill by the developer and broker?43
Yes. Plaintiffs sought to redress a common legal grievance arising from the effect of the nearby landfill, unknown to them, on the value of property purchased from developers and brokers who knew of the landfill.47 Although individual questions of reliance, causation, and damages may arise, the core of the case concerns common issues of fact and law about the duty and the policy of nondisclosure.48 A class action is the superior method for resolving these consumer-fraud claims efficiently and consistently.
Class certification is appropriate in this case.49