148 N.J. 396, 690 A.2d 575 (1997)
Borden, Inc. owned the Snow Food Products Division and obtained ocean quahog clams from its own four-vessel fleet and from independent boats.1 In 1978 Borden hired Donald DeMusz to captain the Arlene Snow.2 In 1983 Borden entered a charter agreement with DeMusz's newly formed Sea Labor, Inc. to manage the fleet.3 DeMusz formed Sea Work, Inc. to purchase and operate the Jessica Lori for Borden's Shuck-at-Sea project; on July 11, 1984 Sea Work signed an eleven-page Equipment Lease requiring it to offer Borden a minimum of 15,000 pounds of shucked clam meat each week.4
In August 1984 Borden and DeMusz negotiated for a second boat.5 On January 15, 1985 Borden signed a one-page contract with Sons of Thunder, Inc., a company formed by DeMusz, Bill Gifford, and Bob Dempsey, that required Borden to purchase at least 7,680 bushels of ocean quahogs per week for one year with automatic renewal for up to five years unless either party gave ninety days' written notice of cancellation.6 Sons of Thunder purchased the Sons of Thunder boat for $588,420.26 and obtained a $515,000 bank loan after Borden's representative assured the lender that the contract would likely run five years.7
The boat began fishing in February 1986, but Borden frequently failed to meet the minimum purchase requirements.8 After management changes in 1986, new Borden executives stated they would not honor the minimum-purchase obligations.9 Borden acquired Doxsee at the end of 1986, reducing its need for independent suppliers, and purchases from both the Sons of Thunder and the Jessica Lori declined.10 On May 8, 1987 Borden sent termination letters to Sons of Thunder and Sea Work.11
On April 4, 1990 Sons of Thunder sued Borden.12 The complaint was later amended to add a claim for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.13 At trial the jury answered special interrogatories finding that Borden had failed to purchase the required minimum quantities before termination.14 The jury found that Borden had breached its obligation of good faith and fair dealing.15 The jury awarded $362,292 and $412,000 respectively.16 The Appellate Division reversed the good-faith portion of the verdict.17 The Supreme Court of New Jersey reviewed the case as of right under R. 2:2-1(a)(2).18
Whether the trial court properly denied Borden's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict on the claim that Borden breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in performing the contract?19
Every contract in New Jersey contains an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.20
Neither party shall do anything which will have the effect of destroying or injuring the right of the other party to receive the fruits of the contract.21
This obligation exists even when the contract contains an express termination clause.22
The duty to perform in good faith is independent of the right to terminate.23
Yes. Borden knew that Sons of Thunder depended on the income from its contract with Borden to pay back the loan.24 Yet Borden continuously breached that contract by never buying the required amount of clams from the Sons of Thunder.25 After Gallant took Booker's place, he told DeMusz that he would not honor the contract with Sons of Thunder.26
Nicholson also told DeMusz that he did not plan to honor that contract.27 Borden's failure to honor the contract left Sons of Thunder with insufficient revenue to support its financing for the Sons of Thunder.28 Borden was also aware that Sons of Thunder was guaranteeing every loan that Sea Work had taken to finance the rerigging and purchasing costs for the Jessica Lori.29 Thus Borden knew that the corporations were dependent on each other.30
After Nicholson arrived, purchases from the Sons of Thunder and the Jessica Lori decreased.31 Moreover, Borden charged Sea Work fees for the salt and carbon dioxide that the Jessica Lori used to Shuck-at-Sea.32 Eventually, Borden stopped purchasing clams from the Jessica Lori.33 When the Jessica Lori tried to sell to other suppliers, Borden charged it a rental fee for using the shucking equipment.34
Indeed, at the end of the relationship, Borden sent the Sons of Thunder out only in bad weather.35 Despite knowing the desperate financial straits of the three corporations, Gallant still pressured DeMusz to obtain outside financing to pay back the $125,000 advance.36 This conduct destroyed Sons of Thunder's reasonable expectations and right to receive the fruits of the contract.37
The trial court properly denied Borden's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.38
Whether Borden's course of conduct with Sons of Thunder, Inc., Sea Labor, Inc., and Sea Work, Inc. permitted the jury to find a breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing?39
The obligation to perform in good faith exists in every contract, including those contracts that contain express and unambiguous provisions permitting either party to terminate the contract without cause.40
A party to a contract may breach the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in performing its obligations even when it exercises an express and unconditional right to terminate.41
Yes. The corporations were so interrelated that Borden's course of conduct with each supported the jury finding of breach.42 Borden knew the corporations were dependent on each other and that if one company failed the other would most likely fail.43 Borden fulfilled its obligations to Sea Work only for a short time.44 Borden then terminated its contract with Sea Work even though it knew terminating the contract would leave Sea Work with no market to fish the Jessica Lori.45
Borden's conduct with Sons of Thunder included failing to buy the required minimums while knowing of the loan guarantees tying the entities together.46
Borden's course of conduct with Sons of Thunder, Inc., Sea Labor, Inc., and Sea Work, Inc. permitted the jury to find a breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.47
Whether the jury's award of $412,000 in damages for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing was reasonable?48
Lost profits are an appropriate remedy when a buyer breaches the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.49
The UCC's remedies are to be liberally administered to the end that the aggrieved party may be put in as good a position as if the other party had fully performed under N.J.S.A. 12A:1-106 and N.J.S.A. 12A:2-708(2).50
Yes. The jury's award of $412,000, approximately one year's worth of additional profits, for the breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing was a reasonable verdict.51 The expert estimated that Sons of Thunder's yearly profits would have been between $399,513 and $430,516 per year if the contract had run for the five-year term.52 Those estimates were made with a reasonable degree of certainty.53
The jury's award of $412,000 in damages for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing was reasonable.54