345 Mass. 429, 187 N.E.2d 669 (1963)
William H. Skinner and another plaintiff, residents of Connecticut, purchased an airplane from Tober Foreign Motors, Inc., a Massachusetts corporation with its principal place of business in Springfield, on October 3, 1959.1 The purchase occurred in Springfield where the parties executed a bill of sale, an installment contract, and an installment note prepared on a Connecticut form by a Connecticut attorney retained by the defendant.2
The installment contract required payments of $200 per month over twenty-four months with a final payment of $353.34 on the twenty-fifth month.3 Shortly after the purchase the airplane developed engine trouble requiring installation of a new engine at a cost of $1,400.4 To address the financial burden this imposed on the plaintiffs the parties orally agreed in late October 1959 that payments for the first year would be reduced to $100 per month.
The plaintiffs made monthly payments of $100 from November 1959 through May 1960 while keeping the plane in Connecticut.5 In March 1960 the defendant's president informed the plaintiffs that payments would need to return to $200 per month or action would be taken.6 The plaintiffs did not agree to the increase.7 On May 26, 1960, the defendant's president, accompanied by two deputy sheriffs of Connecticut and another man, went to the Windham Airport at Willimantic, Connecticut, took possession of the plane, and flew it to an airport in this Commonwealth.8 After repossessing the plane, the defendant sold it for $4,400.9
The case was referred to a master who found the facts and calculated damages of $2,280 plus interest based on the plane's value of $6,200 minus the unpaid balance of $3,920.10 From a final decree awarding the plaintiffs these damages with interest the defendant appealed to the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts.11
Whether Massachusetts or Connecticut law governs the contract of sale and its oral modification?12
General Laws c. 106, § 1-105 provides that when a transaction bears a reasonable relation to this state and also to another state, the parties may agree that the law either of this state or of such other state shall govern their rights and duties. Failing such agreement, this chapter applies to transactions bearing an appropriate relation to this state.13
Yes. The contract of sale was executed in Springfield, Massachusetts, and the plane was delivered to the plaintiffs there. The defendant had its place of business in this Commonwealth. There is no finding that the parties agreed that Connecticut law should apply.14
In the absence of any proof that the oral modification did not bear such a relation to this State there is no basis for holding that any other law would govern. Thus Massachusetts law governs the contract of sale and its oral modification.1516
Massachusetts law governs the contract of sale and its oral modification.
Whether an oral modification of a contract for the sale of goods requires consideration to be binding?22
Section 2-209 (1) provides that an agreement modifying a contract within this Article needs no consideration to be binding.23
No. Although the oral modification was not supported by consideration, under G.L. c. 106, § 2-209(1) an agreement modifying a contract for the sale of goods needs no consideration to be binding.24 The modification was made late in October 1959 when the plaintiffs faced the unexpected cost of a new engine.25 The defendant agreed to reduced payments to keep the plane rather than accept its return.26
The plaintiffs performed by making the $100 payments from November 1959 through May 1960.27 Therefore the modification was valid and binding, and the defendant had no right to repossess the plane.28
An oral modification of a contract for the sale of goods does not require consideration to be binding.29