49 U.S. (8 How.) 441 (1850)
Sill, a citizen of New York, filed his bill in the Circuit Court of the United States for Michigan against Sheldon, claiming to recover the amount of a bond and mortgage which had been assigned to him by Hastings, the President of the Bank of Michigan, while the appellants Thomas C. Sheldon and Eleanor Sheldon, his wife, were citizens of Michigan.1
The bond and mortgage in controversy had originally been given by a citizen of Michigan to another citizen of the same State, and Hastings assigned the instruments to Sill after they were executed.2 In his answer Sheldon pleaded that the bond and mortgage had been originally given by a citizen of Michigan to another citizen of the same State and that the complainant, as assignee, could not invoke the Circuit Court's jurisdiction.3
The Circuit Court exercised jurisdiction and entered a decree for Sill.4 Sheldon and his wife appealed from that decree, and the cause came on to be heard on the transcript of the record from the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Michigan, prompting the Supreme Court to review the jurisdictional objection raised in the answer.5
Whether the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Michigan had jurisdiction over a suit by a New York citizen as assignee of a bond and mortgage originally executed between two Michigan citizens?6
The eleventh section of the Judiciary Act restrains circuit courts from taking cognizance of any suit to recover the contents of any promissory note or other chose in action in favor of an assignee.7 This restraint applies unless a suit might have been prosecuted in such court to recover the contents if no assignment had been made, except in cases of foreign bills of exchange.8
No. Sill, a citizen of New York, filed his bill in the Circuit Court for Michigan against Sheldon, a citizen of Michigan, claiming to recover the amount of a bond and mortgage assigned to him by Hastings after the instruments had been executed between two Michigan citizens.9 Because the assignor Hastings could not have prosecuted the suit in the Circuit Court, the statutory restriction applies directly to Sill as assignee.10
The Circuit Court lacked jurisdiction over the suit.11
Whether the eleventh section of the Judiciary Act restricting jurisdiction over suits by assignees of choses in action conflicts with Article III of the Constitution?12
The Constitution has defined the limits of the judicial power of the United States. It has not prescribed how much of it shall be exercised by the Circuit Court. Consequently, the statute which does prescribe the limits of their jurisdiction cannot be in conflict with the Constitution unless it confers powers not enumerated therein.13 Congress may withhold from any court of its creation jurisdiction of any of the enumerated controversies.14
No. Although Article III extends judicial power to controversies between citizens of different States, Congress possesses the power to establish inferior courts and define their jurisdiction. The assignee restriction withholds rather than confers jurisdiction over a subset of the enumerated cases.15 In this instance the restriction prevents the Circuit Court from hearing the assignee's suit even though diversity exists between Sill and the Sheldons.16
The eleventh section of the Judiciary Act does not conflict with Article III of the Constitution.17
Whether a mortgage securing a debt constitutes a chose in action within the meaning of the assignee restriction in the eleventh section of the Judiciary Act?18
The term chose in action is one of comprehensive import. It includes the infinite variety of contracts, covenants, and promises which confer on one party a right to recover a personal chattel or a sum of money from another by action.19 In equity the debt or bond is treated as the principal and the mortgage as the incident. The remedy obtained is satisfaction of the debt rather than recovery of land.20
Yes. The complainant seeks to recover a debt assigned to him that is secured by the mortgage.21 Because the debt is the principal while the mortgage serves only as special security or lien, the assignee falls within the letter and spirit of the statutory restriction on suits by assignees of choses in action.22
A mortgage securing a debt constitutes a chose in action within the meaning of the assignee restriction in the eleventh section of the Judiciary Act.23