559 U.S. 700 (2010)
In 1934, members of the Veterans of Foreign Wars placed a Latin cross on Sunrise Rock, a granite outcropping within the Mojave National Preserve spanning approximately 1.6 million acres of federal land in southeastern California. The cross, made of 4-inch diameter metal pipes painted white and standing less than eight feet tall, was intended to honor American soldiers who died in World War I and has been replaced or repaired over time, most recently in 1998 by private citizen Henry Sandoz who owns nearby land.1 The cross stands visible from Cima Road but not from highways more than ten miles away, and the surrounding area has served as a campsite and site for Easter services, though identifying signs have disappeared.2
Frank Buono, a retired Park Service employee who visits the Preserve, filed suit in the United States District Court for the Central District of California alleging that the cross on federal land violated the Establishment Clause.3 In the initial proceedings known as Buono I, the District Court granted summary judgment to Buono on cross-motions, concluding he had standing and that the display conveyed governmental endorsement of religion, and it issued a permanent injunction against permitting the display of the Latin cross in the area of Sunrise Rock.4 The Ninth Circuit affirmed in Buono II both the standing determination and the finding of a violation, after which the Government did not seek review, rendering the judgment final.5
During the course of the litigation, Congress enacted statutes prohibiting the use of government funds to remove the cross, designating the cross and adjoining land as a national memorial commemorating World War I, and authorizing installation of a replica plaque.6 While the appeal in Buono II was pending, Congress passed section 8121 of the Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2004, directing the Secretary of the Interior to transfer the parcel containing the cross to the Veterans of Foreign Wars in exchange for other privately owned land in the Preserve, subject to equalization and a reversionary interest if the land is not maintained as a World War I memorial.7 The Ninth Circuit noted the potential transfer but expressed no view on its constitutionality.8
After the judgment in Buono II became final, Buono returned to the District Court in proceedings designated Buono III, seeking injunctive relief to prevent the land transfer either by enforcement or modification of the 2002 injunction.9 The District Court in Buono III found that the transfer represented an attempt to keep the cross in place and enjoined implementation of the land-transfer statute.10 The Ninth Circuit affirmed the District Court's decision in Buono III, and the Supreme Court granted certiorari to review the matter.11
Whether Frank Buono had standing to seek enforcement or modification of the 2002 injunction against implementation of the land-transfer statute?12
A party that obtains a judgment in its favor gains a judicially cognizable interest in ensuring compliance with that judgment.13 Having obtained a final judgment granting relief, a plaintiff has standing to seek its vindication and to prevent the Government from frustrating or evading that injunction.14
Yes. Frank Buono obtained a final judgment in Buono II granting the 2002 injunction against permitting the display of the Latin cross in the area of Sunrise Rock.15 In Buono III he returned to the District Court seeking injunctive relief to prevent implementation of the land-transfer statute either by enforcement or modification of that injunction.16 The established facts show that Buono, as the prevailing party from the prior proceedings, possessed a judicially cognizable interest in ensuring compliance with the judgment and preventing the Government from evading it through the transfer.17
The Government's contention that Buono sought to extend rather than enforce the injunction addresses the merits of the relief, not his standing to request it.18 The facts further establish that the District Court possessed jurisdiction to consider whether the transfer frustrated the objectives of the 2002 decree.19 The Supreme Court therefore held that Buono had standing to pursue the additional relief sought in Buono III.20
Buono had standing to seek enforcement or modification of the 2002 injunction against implementation of the land-transfer statute.21
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Scalia concurred in the judgment on the ground that Frank Buono lacks Article III standing to pursue the relief sought in Buono III.22 Scalia explained that the 2005 order enjoining implementation of section 8121 went beyond enforcement of the original injunction, which only prohibited display of the cross on federal land, and that Buono bears the burden to demonstrate standing for each form of relief.23 He noted that Buono repeatedly stated he was offended only by the cross on federal land and had no objection to Christian symbols on private property, so even if offense constitutes injury, Buono would suffer none from the cross after transfer.24
Scalia concluded the District Court lacked jurisdiction to grant the expanded relief and that the order should be vacated.25
Whether the District Court properly enjoined the Government from implementing the land-transfer statute?26
An injunction is an equitable remedy that should be ordered only after considering all circumstances bearing on the need for prospective relief.27 Courts must be particularly cautious when relief implicates public interests and must never ignore significant changes in law or circumstances underlying an injunction.28
No. The District Court in Buono III failed to engage in the appropriate equitable inquiry when it enjoined implementation of the land-transfer statute.29 The established facts demonstrate that while the appeal in Buono II was pending, Congress passed section 8121 directing the transfer. The statute directed transfer of the parcel containing the cross to the Veterans of Foreign Wars in exchange for other land in the Preserve, subject to a reversionary clause if the land was not maintained as a World War I memorial.30
The District Court dismissed the statute as an illegitimate attempt to keep the cross in place.31 It did so without adequately considering the context that private citizens erected the cross in 1934 to honor World War I soldiers.32 Congress later designated it a national memorial.33 The transfer represented a legislative judgment to resolve the controversy while accommodating the symbol's complex historical meaning.34 The court also failed to evaluate whether transfer to private ownership would eliminate any perception of governmental endorsement that the 2002 injunction had addressed.35
The Supreme Court held that the District Court erred by treating the statute as an evasion without properly weighing Congress's authority and the changed circumstances.36
The District Court did not properly enjoin the Government from implementing the land-transfer statute.37
Related opinions on this issue
Justice Alito joined the majority opinion except as to the remand.38 He would decide the remaining questions on the record and hold that the land-transfer statute may be implemented.39 Alito emphasized the unique factual circumstances surrounding the Sunrise Rock monument that presented Congress with a delicate problem.40
Veterans of World War I erected the cross in 1934 to honor fallen American soldiers on federal land in a remote area where land boundaries often are not marked, and local citizens maintained it for decades.41 After litigation resulted in an injunction, Congress enacted a land exchange transferring the parcel containing the cross to the VFW in exchange for other land, requiring that the parcel be maintained as a World War I memorial and including a reversion clause if not so maintained.42
Alito concluded that the transfer was designed to eliminate any perception of governmental sponsorship while avoiding the symbolism of destroying a long-standing monument.43 A well-informed reasonable observer would know the land is privately owned and the new owner is under no obligation to preserve the present design, so the transfer would not violate the endorsement test.44 The transfer was not motivated by an illicit purpose; Congress sought to commemorate the Nation's war dead and to avoid the symbolism of demolishing the monument.45 Justice Alito stated that he would reverse and remand with instructions to vacate the order prohibiting implementation of the land-transfer statute.
Justice Stevens dissented. He argued that the land-transfer statute did not cure the Establishment Clause violation found in Buono II.46 Stevens maintained that the District Court's injunction prohibited the Government from permitting the cross's display in the area of Sunrise Rock.47
The transfer statute directed conveyance to a private entity that intended to maintain the cross in its current location while including a reversionary clause to ensure maintenance as a memorial.48 He concluded that the transfer constituted an affirmative government act designed to keep the cross in place and thus amounted to permission, continuing or even accentuating governmental endorsement of a sectarian symbol.49 Stevens would affirm the judgment below.50
Justice Breyer dissented. He contended that the District Court's decision to enjoin the transfer was a reasonable exercise of its broad discretion to interpret and enforce its own orders.51 Breyer noted that the court had to construe the injunction in light of its purpose and history.52
The surrounding facts included congressional designations of the cross as a national memorial, prior prohibitions on removing it, the reversionary condition, and the Government's active role.53 These facts supported the conclusion that the transfer would permit and facilitate public display of the cross and frustrate the injunction's purpose.54 He argued that the case principally involves principles of injunction law rather than novel constitutional questions and that the Ninth Circuit's judgment should be affirmed.55
Whether the District Court adequately considered changed circumstances and congressional action when addressing enforcement of the prior injunction?56
Courts must consider whether changed circumstances undermine the basis for continued equitable intervention, and a court must ensure prospective relief fits the remedy to the wrong previously established.57
No. The District Court in Buono III did not adequately consider the changed circumstances presented by the land-transfer statute or Congress's institutional role in balancing competing interests.58 While the appeal in Buono II was pending, Congress passed section 8121 directing transfer of the Sunrise Rock parcel to the Veterans of Foreign Wars.59 The statute embodied a legislative judgment to accommodate a symbol that had stood for decades, had been designated a national memorial, and carried complex meaning beyond purely religious expression.60
The District Court instead concentrated solely on the religious aspects of the cross and treated the statute as a sham without reassessing whether transfer to private ownership would affect any perceived governmental endorsement or whether the reasonable observer standard remained appropriate in light of the new ownership.61 The court also failed to consider less drastic relief before nullifying the legislation.62 The Supreme Court held that the District Court should have evaluated the request for relief in light of the objectives of the 2002 decree and the new statutory framework.63
The District Court did not adequately consider changed circumstances and congressional action when addressing enforcement of the prior injunction.64