22 N.Y.2d 579, 293 N.Y.S.2d 897, 240 N.E.2d 860
In this case, the plaintiff, a member of the public, was repeatedly threatened with personal harm.1 Despite these threats, the municipality failed to provide special protection.2 As a result, the plaintiff eventually suffered dire personal injuries due to the lack of such protection.3
The facts surrounding these events are amply described in the dissenting opinion.4 No useful purpose would be served by repetition of those details in this opinion.5
This appeal presents the issue in a very sympathetic framework.6 It concerns the liability of a municipality for failure to provide special protection to a member of the public who was repeatedly threatened with personal harm and eventually suffered dire personal injuries for lack of such protection.7 The issue arises upon the affirmance by a divided Appellate Division of a dismissal of the complaint.8 This dismissal occurred after both sides had rested but before submission to the jury.9
Whether a municipality may be held liable for failure to provide special protection to a member of the public who was repeatedly threatened with personal harm and eventually suffered dire personal injuries for lack of such protection?10
A municipality is not liable for failure to provide special protection to a member of the public who was repeatedly threatened with personal harm and eventually suffered dire personal injuries for lack of such protection.11 The amount of protection that may be provided is limited by the resources of the community and by a considered legislative-executive decision as to how those resources may be deployed.12 For the courts to proclaim a new and general duty of protection in the law of tort, even to those who may be the particular seekers of protection based on specific hazards, could and would inevitably determine how the limited police resources of the community should be allocated and without predictable limits.13 Before such extension of responsibilities should be dictated by the indirect imposition of tort liabilities, there should be a legislative determination that that should be the scope of public responsibility.14
No. The facts of this appeal do not indicate that the police authorities undertook responsibilities to this particular member of the public who was repeatedly threatened with personal harm and eventually suffered dire personal injuries.15 There is no showing that the authorities exposed the plaintiff to risks which then materialized into actual losses.16 Accordingly, the municipality is not liable.17
The order of the Appellate Division affirming the judgment of dismissal should be affirmed.18