757 S.E.2d 422 (S.C. Ct. App. 2014)
On August 29, 2007, Jasper County Sheriff Benjamin Riley was driving his 1998 Ford F-150 pickup truck near Ehrhardt in Bamberg County when a vehicle driven by Andrew Marshall Carter II pulled from a side road into Riley’s lane of travel.1 The resulting impact caused Riley’s truck to leave the road and roll over.2 The driver’s door opened in the initial collision with Carter, and Riley was ejected through the open door.3 First responders found Riley’s body eighty-five feet from where he was ejected.4
Riley’s wife Laura, serving as personal representative of the Estate, brought wrongful death and survival claims against Ford Motor Company and Carter based on a products liability negligence theory alleging negligent design of the door-latch system.5 The Estate settled with Carter for $25,000, with the Estate and Carter agreeing to allocate $20,000 to the survival claim and $5,000 to the wrongful death claim, which the trial court approved.6
At trial, the Estate withdrew its survival claim, and the court submitted the wrongful death claim against Ford to the jury.7 The jury returned a verdict in favor of the Estate for $300,000 in actual damages.8 Ford moved for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, arguing the Estate failed to prove both the existence of a defect in the door-latch system and a reasonable alternative design, and also requested a setoff from the verdict in the amount of $25,000.9 The Estate filed a motion seeking a new trial nisi additur.10 The trial court denied Ford’s motions in a form order without explanation and granted the Estate’s motion, ordering Ford to pay an additional $600,000 in actual damages, bringing the total verdict to $900,000.11 Ford appealed each of these three rulings to the Court of Appeals of South Carolina.12
Whether the trial court erred in denying Ford's motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict on the grounds that the Estate failed to present sufficient evidence of a design defect or reasonable alternative design?13
In a product liability design defect action, the plaintiff must present evidence of a reasonable alternative design. The presentation of an alternative design must include consideration of the costs, safety and functionality associated with the alternative design.14
No. The Estate brought wrongful death and survival claims against Ford based on a products liability negligence theory alleging negligent design of the door-latch system. The jury returned a verdict in favor of the Estate for $300,000 in actual damages after the Estate withdrew its survival claim. This verdict demonstrates that the Estate presented sufficient evidence of a design defect and reasonable alternative design to the trial court.15
The trial court correctly denied Ford's motion for JNOV.16
Whether the trial court erred in denying Ford's motion for setoff to account for the Estate's settlement with Carter?17
A non-settling defendant is entitled to credit for the amount paid by another defendant who settled for the same cause of action. When an agreed-upon allocation of settlement proceeds is not reasonable under the evidence, the court may reallocate the funds.18
Yes. The Estate settled with Carter for $25,000 with $20,000 allocated to the survival claim and $5,000 to the wrongful death claim, which the trial court approved. Ford moved for setoff of the $25,000 settlement. The trial court denied the motion in a form order without explanation. The facts establish some evidence of conscious pain and suffering, making an allocation of eighty percent to wrongful death and twenty percent to survival reasonable and entitling Ford to a $20,000 setoff.19
The trial court erred in denying Ford's motion for setoff, and Ford is entitled to a $20,000 setoff from the verdict.20
Whether the trial court erred in granting the Estate's motion for new trial nisi additur increasing the verdict from $300,000 to $900,000?21
The right to trial by jury includes the right to have the jury determine the amount of damages. A trial court may grant additur only when it offers compelling reasons for invading the jury's province, giving substantial deference to the jury's determination of damages.22
Yes. The jury returned a verdict in favor of the Estate for $300,000 in actual damages. The trial court granted the Estate's motion for new trial nisi additur ordering Ford to pay an additional $600,000 for a total of $900,000. The trial court did not offer compelling reasons for the additur because the jury awarded some noneconomic damages and mere disagreement with the amount awarded is not a sufficient basis to invade the jury's province.23
The trial court erred in granting the Estate's motion for new trial nisi additur, and the jury's verdict of $300,000 is reinstated.24