277 Conn. 364, 890 A.2d 1287 (2006)
In May 2000, Robert Right stopped his automobile at a red traffic light when it was struck from behind by a vehicle driven by Kimberly Breen.1 There was minor damage to Right's vehicle, but no physical injuries were reported at the accident scene.2 Right subsequently brought this action against Breen, alleging that as a result of her negligence he had suffered bodily injury leading to both economic and noneconomic damages.3 In her answer, Breen admitted that the vehicle she was operating had struck Right's vehicle but denied that the injuries and damages suffered by Right were a result of her negligence.4
At trial, Right presented evidence concerning his injuries that allegedly had resulted from the impact of the collision.5 Because Breen contended that Right's injuries were the result of other automobile accidents in which he had been involved, Right also presented evidence concerning accidents in which he had been involved prior to the May 2000 collision with Breen—a 1989 head-on collision, an incident in the early 1990s in which he backed a vehicle into a pole, and a 1995 high impact collision—as well as accidents that occurred after the May 2000 collision—a 2001 rear impact collision, and a 2002 low impact collision.6 Using a verdict form provided by the plaintiff, the jury returned a verdict of zero economic damages and zero noneconomic damages, and the trial court accepted the verdict.7
Right then filed motions to set aside the verdict and for additur.8 He argued that under Connecticut case law he was entitled to at least nominal damages because he had suffered a technical legal injury that admittedly had been caused by Breen.9 The trial court granted the motions, setting aside the jury’s verdict and awarding Right $1 based upon the abundant appellate case law cited, premised upon the defendant’s admission of negligence.10 Right filed a bill of costs requesting $3150 in medically related costs and $467.10 in nonmedical costs.11 The trial court awarded the $467.10 in nonmedical costs in addition to the $1 nominal damage award but denied the request for medically related costs.12
Breen appealed from the judgment of the trial court to the Appellate Court, claiming that the trial court had acted improperly when it set aside the jury verdict in her favor and awarded costs to Right.13 The Appellate Court affirmed the trial court’s judgment.14 This certified appeal followed, with this court granting Breen’s petition for certification limited to questions concerning whether the plaintiff was entitled to nominal damages and costs and whether Keller v. Carone should be overruled.15
Whether a plaintiff in a negligence action must be awarded nominal damages, thereby making the defendant potentially liable for costs, when the defendant admits liability but denies having caused the alleged injury, and the fact finder thereafter concludes that the plaintiff failed to prove that he suffered any injury as a result of the defendant’s conduct?16
The essential elements of a cause of action in negligence are duty, breach of that duty, causation, and actual injury.17 Without proof of each of these elements, a plaintiff's cause fails entirely, and he is not entitled to have the question of damages considered.18 Nominal damages are not awarded in negligence actions because actual damages are a necessary element of the action, unlike intentional torts where an invasion of a legal right may support nominal recovery.19
No. Breen admitted that her vehicle struck Right's vehicle at the red light but denied that the collision caused any of Right's alleged bodily injuries.20 Right introduced evidence of multiple prior accidents in 1989, the early 1990s, and 1995, as well as later collisions in 2001 and 2002, to address Breen's causation defense.21 The jury returned a verdict of zero economic damages and zero noneconomic damages on the form provided.22 Because Right failed to prove actual injury resulting from Breen's conduct, the technical legal injury concept from intentional tort cases does not apply and no nominal damages follow as a matter of law.23
Did the Appellate Court properly conclude that the plaintiff was entitled to nominal damages and costs?26
No. The Appellate Court affirmed the trial court's grant of additur awarding $1 and nonmedical costs after the jury's zero verdict.29 It cited Keller for the proposition that an admission of liability establishes a technical legal injury entitling the plaintiff to nominal damages.30 This court now holds that the Appellate Court erred because actual injury remains an essential element of negligence that Right did not prove through the evidence of his other accidents.31
The Appellate Court did not properly conclude that the plaintiff was entitled to nominal damages and costs.32
Whether this court should overrule Keller v. Carone?33
Keller v. Carone's statement that a defendant's admission of liability establishes a technical legal injury entitling the plaintiff to at least nominal damages is overruled.34 It conflicts with the settled principle that actual injury is required in negligence and with the later clarification in Green v. Donroe distinguishing intentional from negligent conduct.35
Yes. Although the certified question is framed conditionally, the court determines that Keller must be overruled to align the law with the rule that conduct that is merely negligent, without proof of an actual injury, is not a significant interference with the public interest giving rise to a right to complain.36 The trial court and Appellate Court both felt compelled by Keller to award nominal damages after the zero verdict, but that result is now corrected.37
This court should overrule Keller v. Carone.38