328 U.S. 408 (1946)
Prudential Insurance Company is a corporation organized under the laws of New Jersey.1 For many years prior to 1945, the company conducted a substantial insurance business in South Carolina.2 It maintained over twenty-six thousand policies insuring the lives of approximately twenty thousand residents of the state.3
South Carolina levied a tax on foreign insurance companies.4 The tax equaled three percent of the aggregate premiums received from business done in the state.5 Payment was required annually as a condition of receiving a certificate of authority to carry on the business of insurance within the state.6 No similar tax is required of South Carolina corporations.7
Prior to the Supreme Court's decision in United States v. South-Eastern Underwriters Assn., 322 U. S. 533, Prudential paid the South Carolina tax without challenge for decades after first being authorized to do business in the state in 1897.8 The company maintained that the tax discriminates against interstate commerce and in favor of local business.9 The tax is laid only on foreign corporations and is measured by their gross receipts from premiums derived from business done in the state, regardless of its interstate or local character.10
Congress enacted the McCarran Act declaring that the continued regulation and taxation by the several states of the business of insurance is in the public interest.11 Silence on the part of Congress shall not be construed to impose any barrier to the regulation or taxation of such business by the several states.12 It further provides that the business of insurance and every person engaged therein shall be subject to the laws of the several states which relate to the regulation or taxation of such business.13 No act of Congress shall be construed to invalidate, impair, or supersede any state law regulating or taxing insurance unless the act specifically relates to the business of insurance.14
The Supreme Court of South Carolina upheld the continued exaction of the tax, concluding that it did not violate the commerce clause and was not affected by the South-Eastern decision.15 The case reached the United States Supreme Court on appeal from the state court's judgment reported at 207 S. C. 324, 35 S. E. 2d 586.16
Whether South Carolina's tax on foreign insurance companies discriminates against interstate commerce?17
The commerce clause forbids state taxes that discriminate against interstate commerce when Congress' power lies dormant, but the clause imposes no limitation on Congress' plenary power to consent to or validate such state taxes through affirmative legislation.18
No. The McCarran Act expressly declares that continued state taxation of the insurance business is in the public interest and that congressional silence shall not be construed to impose any barrier to such taxation.19 The Act removes any commerce-clause objection that might otherwise arise from the tax's discriminatory character.20 South Carolina's three-percent premium tax applies only to foreign insurers such as Prudential, a New Jersey corporation that conducted substantial business in the state for decades after 1897, while exempting domestic corporations.21
South Carolina's tax does not violate the commerce clause.22
Whether the McCarran Act constitutes congressional consent to state taxes on the insurance business that might otherwise be invalid under the commerce clause?23
Congress possesses plenary authority over interstate commerce and may exercise that authority to consent to state taxes or regulations that would be invalid under the negative implications of the commerce clause if Congress remained silent.24
Yes. The McCarran Act states that the business of insurance shall be subject to the laws of the several states relating to taxation.25 It provides that no act of Congress shall be construed to invalidate state insurance taxes unless the act specifically relates to insurance.26 South Carolina's tax, which Prudential paid without challenge until the South-Eastern decision, falls squarely within the class of state measures Congress intended to sustain.27
The McCarran Act supplies valid congressional consent.28
Whether Congress has the power to remove constitutional objections to state taxation of interstate insurance by declaring such taxation in the public interest?29
Yes. Through the McCarran Act, Congress determined that uniformity of taxation is not required for the insurance business and placed the full weight of its power behind existing and future state insurance tax systems, including those that differentiate between foreign and domestic companies.33 Prudential, a New Jersey corporation, had conducted business in South Carolina since 1897 and paid the tax without question for decades.34 The record of its continuous success refutes any idea that the tax handicapped it in competition with local business.35
South Carolina's tax therefore rests on the coordinated exercise of all governmental power residing in the constitutional scheme.36
Congress possesses that power and validly exercised it here.37