233 So. 2d 381
The Posner parties executed an antenuptial agreement in 1960 that addressed the disposition of alimony in the event of divorce or separation.1 The agreement was made prior to their marriage.2 After the marriage, divorce proceedings were initiated.3 The chancellor entered a decree granting the divorce to the husband.
Pursuant to the antenuptial agreement, the chancellor awarded the wife $600 per month as alimony. The decree also provided $600 per month support money for each of the two minor children of the parties.4 The wife appealed from the portions of the decree awarding the divorce to the husband and the alimony amount.5 The husband cross-appealed the child support award.6
The Third District Court of Appeal considered the appeals and affirmed the divorce decree and the child support award of $1,200 per month.7 The three appellate judges each took a different position on the antenuptial agreement.8 One view held that the parties may validly agree on alimony but the trial court is not bound.9 Another held the agreement void as against public policy, and the third held it binding like property settlements upon death.10
The district court certified the question of the validity and binding effect of the antenuptial agreement as one of great public interest. The Supreme Court of Florida accepted jurisdiction under Section 4(2), Article V of the Florida Constitution.11 The matter came before the court on rehearing granted on the petition for certiorari to review the district court's 1968 decision reported at 206 So.2d 416.12
Whether an antenuptial agreement respecting alimony in the event of divorce or separation is valid?13
Contracts intended to facilitate or promote the procurement of a divorce are illegal as contrary to public policy.14 Antenuptial agreements settling alimony rights upon divorce are no longer held void ab initio as contrary to public policy.15 Such agreements are valid if they meet the stringent rules prescribed in Del Vecchio v. Del Vecchio for ante- and post-nuptial agreements settling property rights upon death.16 The divorce must also have been prosecuted in good faith on proper grounds.
Yes. The Posner parties executed an antenuptial agreement in 1960 that addressed the disposition of alimony in the event of divorce or separation prior to their marriage. After the marriage, divorce proceedings were initiated and the chancellor entered a decree granting the divorce to the husband and awarding the wife $600 per month as alimony pursuant to the antenuptial agreement.17 The Supreme Court of Florida held that such agreements should no longer be held void ab initio when tested by the Del Vecchio standards and when the divorce is prosecuted in good faith on proper grounds.18
An antenuptial agreement respecting alimony in the event of divorce or separation is valid if it meets the Del Vecchio standards and the divorce is prosecuted in good faith on proper grounds.19
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Ervin, C.j., And Drew, J.
Judge Spector adhered to the view that antenuptial agreements which meet the tests enumerated in Del Vecchio v. Del Vecchio are valid and are not void as being contrary to the public policy of this State.20 He agreed that an amount of alimony stipulated in a valid antenuptial agreement may be subject to modification under Section 61.14 upon a showing that the wife's circumstances have so changed since the amount agreed upon was incorporated in a divorce decree that it would be inequitable to limit her to the agreed amount.21 Spector noted that such a contingency arises when the wife becomes afflicted with ill health and its attendant high medical expenses, which might render the agreed amount inadequate and force her to become a public charge.22
He emphasized that the statute was enacted during the depression to provide relief when changed circumstances require equitable adjustment.23 Modification should be exercised only upon the strongest and most compelling reasons after the wife demonstrates increased need.24
Whether such an antenuptial agreement is binding on the trial court in a divorce proceeding?25
An antenuptial agreement respecting alimony is a valid and binding agreement between the parties at the time and under the conditions it was made.26 The question of its future binding effect when presented to the Chancellor for approval and incorporation in the final decree should be decided under applicable statutory law relating to postnuptial contracts.27
Yes. The Supreme Court of Florida held that the antenuptial agreement, if entered into under the conditions outlined in Del Vecchio v. Del Vecchio, was a valid and binding agreement between the parties at the time and under the conditions it was made.28 The chancellor had incorporated the $600 per month alimony award from the agreement into the divorce decree.29 The court instructed the district court to vacate that portion of the decree and remand for further proceedings consistent with the opinion recognizing the agreement's binding character at the time of execution.30
The antenuptial agreement is binding on the parties at the time it was made, subject to the trial court's consideration under statutory standards for postnuptial agreements.31
Whether the alimony amount stipulated in such an antenuptial agreement may be modified upon a showing of changed circumstances under Section 61.14, Florida Statutes?32
Under Section 61.14, Florida Statutes, when a husband and wife have entered into an agreement for payments for or instead of alimony, either party may apply to the circuit court for a judgment decreasing or increasing the amount of alimony upon a showing that the circumstances of the parties or the financial ability of the husband has changed since the execution of the agreement.33 The court has jurisdiction to make orders as equity requires with due regard to the changed circumstances.34
Yes. The Supreme Court of Florida assumed that the parties to this litigation knew of the existence of Section 61.14, Florida Statutes, when they made their agreement in 1960 and that their capacity to make the agreement was and is limited by same.35 The court held that the question of modification of such antenuptial agreements upon a showing of a change in circumstances after the entry of the decree of divorce should be decided under Section 61.14, Florida Statutes.36 The chancellor had awarded $600 per month alimony pursuant to the agreement, but the matter was remanded for further proceedings on modification.37
The alimony amount stipulated in the antenuptial agreement may be modified upon a showing of changed circumstances under Section 61.14, Florida Statutes.38
Related opinions on this issue
Joined by Ervin, C.j., And Drew, J.
Judge Spector agreed with the view that an amount of alimony stipulated for in a valid antenuptial agreement may be subject to modification under the provisions of Section 61.14, Florida Statutes, upon a showing that the wife's circumstances have so changed since the amount agreed upon was incorporated in a divorce decree that it would be inequitable to limit her to the agreed amount of alimony in the face of such changed circumstances which require an increase in alimony to maintain a standard of comfort which the agreed amount would have afforded.39 He observed that the nation is experiencing an inflationary trend that may also be the basis of a finding by the chancellor that circumstances have so changed as to require equitable adjustment under the statute.40
Spector stressed that the husband's ability to pay more is considered only after the wife has convincingly demonstrated an increased need on her part because of her changed circumstances.41