206 Conn. 229, 537 A.2d 468 (1988)
On the afternoon of November 20, 1976, the defendant Norman Russ and his two month old daughter visited the home of Arthur Polmatier in East Windsor.1 Polmatier lived there with his wife Dorothy and their eleven year old son Robert.2 Robert noticed a disturbance and saw the defendant astride Polmatier on a couch beating him on the head with a beer bottle while Polmatier exclaimed that the defendant was killing him.3
The defendant then took a box of 30-30 caliber ammunition from the bottom drawer of a dresser in Polmatier’s bedroom and a 30-30 caliber Winchester rifle from the closet in his brother-in-law’s bedroom.4 He returned to the living room and shot Polmatier twice, causing his death.5 About five hours later, the defendant was found sitting on a stump in a wooded area approximately one half mile from the home, naked, with his daughter in his arms wrapped in his clothes and the rifle with him.6
The defendant was taken to a local hospital and later transferred to Norwich Hospital or the Whiting Forensic Institute while in custody.7 He was charged with the crime of murder but was found not guilty by reason of insanity.8 Dr. Walter Borden testified that at the time of the homicide the defendant was suffering from a severe case of paranoid schizophrenia that involved delusions of persecution, grandeur, influence and reference, and also involved auditory hallucinations, and that the defendant was legally insane and could not form a rational choice but that he could make a schizophrenic or crazy choice.9
Dorothy Polmatier, executrix of the estate of her deceased husband Arthur R. Polmatier, brought this action against the defendant seeking to recover damages for wrongful death.10 The substitute complaint alleged that the death resulted from an assault, beating and shooting by the defendant.11 After a trial to the court, the state trial referee rendered judgment for the plaintiff on the first count and awarded compensatory damages, from which the defendant has appealed.12
Whether an insane person is liable for an intentional tort?13
Connecticut adopts the majority rule that an insane person is liable for intentional torts.14 The rule is reflected in the Restatement (Second) of Torts § 283B.15 Insanity or other mental deficiency does not relieve the actor from liability for conduct which does not conform to the standard of a reasonable man under like circumstances.16 The rule is also reflected in § 895J.17 This rule rests on public policy that where one of two innocent persons must suffer a loss it should be borne by the one who occasioned it.18 Relatives will be led to restrain the insane person.19 There will be redress for injuries rather than the anomaly of an insane person with wealth depriving another without compensation.20
Yes. On the afternoon of November 20, 1976, Norman Russ visited the home of his father-in-law Arthur Polmatier in East Windsor with his infant daughter.21
Polmatier resided there with his wife Dorothy and their son Robert.22 During the early evening Robert observed Russ astride Polmatier on a couch striking him on the head with a beer bottle as Polmatier cried out that Russ was killing him.23 Robert ran to seek help.24 Subsequently Russ retrieved a box of 30-30 caliber ammunition from a dresser in Polmatier's bedroom and a Winchester rifle from his brother-in-law's closet.25 He returned to the living room and shot Polmatier twice resulting in his death.26
Approximately five hours later Russ was discovered sitting on a stump in a wooded area half a mile away naked holding his daughter wrapped in his clothes and in possession of the rifle.27 Russ was hospitalized and later confined at Norwich Hospital or the Whiting Forensic Institute.28 He was charged with murder but found not guilty by reason of insanity.29 Psychiatrist Walter Borden testified that Russ suffered from severe paranoid schizophrenia with delusions and hallucinations rendering him legally insane and unable to form a rational choice though capable of a schizophrenic choice.30
Dorothy Polmatier as executrix of Arthur Polmatier's estate initiated this wrongful death action against Russ alleging assault beating and shooting.31 Following a trial the state trial referee entered judgment for the plaintiff on the compensatory damages count.32 The defendant was found insane yet performed the external manifestations of beating and shooting which constituted acts under the Restatement because they were not reflexive or convulsive but the product of a crazy choice.33 The trial court properly held him liable for the intentional tort.34
An insane person is liable for an intentional tort.35
Whether the trial court should have determined whether the defendant intended the act that produced the injury?36
For tort liability an act is an external manifestation of the actor's will under Restatement (Second) of Torts § 2 and comment b.37 An insane person may have an intent to invade the interests of another even though the reasons and motives are entirely irrational under § 895J comment c.38 A rational choice is not required.39 The trial court need only implicitly determine that the conduct constituted an act.40
No. The trial court implicitly determined that the defendant committed an act in beating and shooting Polmatier.41 The defendant took ammunition and the rifle then shot the decedent twice.42 The psychiatrist testified the defendant could make a schizophrenic or crazy choice.43 The defendant's behavior was not reflexive convulsive or epileptic and therefore constituted an external manifestation of the will under the Restatement definition even though the underlying reasons were irrational delusions of persecution and grandeur.44
The trial court did not err by failing to make an explicit separate finding on the first prong of the two-pronged analysis.45
The trial court did not err by failing to make an explicit determination on whether the defendant intended the act that produced the injury.46
Whether the trial court should have determined whether the defendant intended the resulting injury?47
Intent under Restatement (Second) of Torts § 8A denotes that the actor desires to cause consequences of his act or believes that the consequences are substantially certain to result from it.48 It is not essential that the precise injury which was done be the one intended.49 Under § 895J comment c it is not necessary for the defendant's reasons and motives to be rational in order for him to have the intent to invade the interests of another.50 Intent is not an essential element of the wrongful death cause of action under General Statutes § 52-555.51
No. The trial court properly concluded that the defendant intended to beat and shoot Polmatier.52 The defendant gave statements to police and to Dr. Borden that he intended to punish Polmatier and to kill him in self-defense based on his delusions.53 The trial court awarded compensatory damages on the assault and battery count.54 The defendant's explanations were similar to the Restatement illustration of irrational reasons.55
The court was not required to find a rational purpose or desire for the precise resulting injury.56 The trial court did not err on the second prong.57
The trial court did not err by failing to make an explicit determination on whether the defendant intended the resulting injury.58