223 U.S. 118 (1912)
In 1902 Oregon amended its constitution (Art. IV, § 1).1 This amendment retained an existing clause vesting the exclusive legislative power in a General Assembly consisting of a senate and house of representatives.2 It added a provision that the people reserve to themselves power to propose laws and amendments to the constitution and to enact or reject the same at the polls, independent of the legislative assembly.3 The people also reserved power at their own option to approve or reject at the polls any act of the legislative assembly.4
Specific means for the exercise of the power thus reserved were contained in further clauses. These clauses authorized both the amendment of the constitution and the enactment of laws to be accomplished by the method known as the initiative and that commonly referred to as the referendum.
In 1903 the legislature enacted detailed provisions for the carrying into effect of this amendment.5
By resort to the initiative in 1906 a law taxing telephone and telegraph companies was submitted, voted on and promulgated by the Governor in 1906 as having been duly adopted.6 By this law telephone and telegraph companies were taxed by what was qualified as an annual license two per centum upon their gross revenue derived from business done within the State.7 Penalties were provided for non-payment, and methods were created for enforcing payment in case of delinquency.8
The Pacific States Telephone and Telegraph Company, an Oregon corporation engaged in business in that State, made a return of its gross receipts as required by the statute.9 It was accordingly assessed two per cent upon the amount of such return.10
The suit which is now before us was commenced by the State to enforce payment of this assessment and the statutory penalties for delinquency.11 The petition alleged the passage of the taxing law by resort to the initiative, the return made by the corporation, the assessment, the duty to pay and the failure to make such payment.12
The answer of the corporation contained twenty-nine paragraphs.13 Four of these challenged the validity of the tax because of defects inhering in the nature or operation of the tax.14 These four paragraphs were struck from the answer on the company's own motion.15
The remaining paragraphs in so far as they relied upon the Constitution of the United States rested exclusively upon an alleged infirmity of the powers of government of the State begotten by the incorporation into the state constitution of the amendment concerning the initiative and the referendum.16
The answer was demurred to as stating no defense.17 The demurrer was sustained. The defendant elected not to plead further. Judgment went against it. That judgment was affirmed by the Supreme Court of Oregon.
Whether the enforcement of the guarantee of a republican form of government under section 4 of Article IV of the Constitution, because of its political character, is exclusively committed to Congress or is judicial in its character?18
The enforcement of the guarantee of a republican form of government under section 4 of Article IV is a political question committed exclusively to Congress and is not cognizable by the judicial power.19
Yes. The facts show that Oregon amended its constitution in 1902 to incorporate initiative and referendum powers, that a corporate tax law was enacted by initiative in 1906, and that the Pacific States Telephone and Telegraph Company was assessed under that law before the state sued to collect the assessment and penalties.20 The company's answer rested exclusively on the claim that the initiative and referendum amendment rendered the state government unrepublican in form, and the state courts sustained a demurrer to that answer.21 These facts present a challenge not to the tax itself but to the lawful existence of the state government.22
The rule from Luther v. Borden requires that such claims be treated as political rather than justiciable.23 Applying the rule to these facts, the company's twenty-nine paragraphs of defense, once stripped of non-constitutional claims, all reduce to the single contention that the initiative destroyed representative legislative power and thereby violated the guarantee.24 If accepted, that contention would invalidate every statute enacted in Oregon since 1902 and would require the judiciary to decide whether the state remains republican in form.25
The Supreme Court therefore lacks jurisdiction because the issue is committed to Congress alone.26 The contentions advanced by the company, if sustained, would expand judicial power to determine the political existence of a state and would destroy the constitutional separation between judicial authority over justiciable controversies and legislative power over purely political questions.27