518 U.S. 712 (1996)
John Gratzianna is the owner and operator of O'Hare Truck Service, which provides towing services in Cook and DuPage Counties, Illinois.1 The city of Northlake coordinates towing services through its Police Department and for at least 30 years has maintained a rotation list of available towing companies.2 O'Hare had been on the list since 1965.3 The city's policy had been to remove a tow truck operator from the rotation list only for cause.4 O'Hare and the city's former Mayor, Gene Doyle, had a mutual understanding that the city would maintain O'Hare's place on the rotation list so long as O'Hare provided good service.5
In 1989, soon after being elected Northlake's new Mayor, respondent Reid Paxson told Gratzianna he was pleased with O'Hare's work and would continue using and referring its services.6 Four years later, when Paxson ran for reelection, his campaign committee asked Gratzianna for a contribution, which Gratzianna refused to make.7 Gratzianna instead supported the campaign of Paxson's opponent and displayed the opponent's campaign posters at O'Hare's place of business.8 Soon after, O'Hare was removed from the rotation list.9 The complaint alleges the removal was in retaliation for Gratzianna's stance in the campaign and that petitioners lost substantial income as a result.10
O'Hare and Gratzianna sued in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois alleging infringement of First Amendment rights in violation of 42 U.S.C. § 1983.11 The District Court dismissed the complaint.12 The Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed.13 The Supreme Court granted certiorari to resolve the conflict among the Courts of Appeals.14
Whether the protections against termination for political affiliation or expression recognized in Elrod v. Burns and Branti v. Finkel extend to independent contractors providing services to a government entity?15
Government officials may not discharge public employees for refusing to support a political party or its candidates, unless political affiliation is a reasonably appropriate requirement for the job in question.16 The protections of Elrod and Branti extend to an independent contractor, who, in retaliation for refusing to comply with demands for political support, has a government contract terminated or is removed from an official list of contractors authorized to perform public services.17
Yes. The legal principles from Elrod and Branti bar government from terminating a provider of services for refusing political support or affiliation unless party affiliation is an appropriate requirement for effective performance of the task.18 This rule applies directly to independent contractors because the government cannot impose an unconstitutional condition on a continuing contractual relationship by demanding political fealty.19 The distinction between employees and contractors is not of constitutional magnitude and provides no basis for denying protection.20
Gratzianna operated as an independent contractor on the city's rotation list under a long-standing policy of removal only for cause and with an understanding that good service would maintain his position. After he refused the requested contribution and supported Paxson's opponent, the city removed O'Hare from the list in direct retaliation. No justification unrelated to political association was offered.21 The specific targeting of Gratzianna with a demand for support followed by termination of the relationship therefore violates the First Amendment.22
The protections against termination for political affiliation or expression recognized in Elrod v. Burns and Branti v. Finkel extend to independent contractors providing services to a government entity.23